Neither jibes no insults
Socialist Organiser1981 1981-05-02Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
IS OLIVER Maurer and John Cunningham's criticism (SO 9: of my article The SWP and he Labour Party raises some Important points, I would like to reply briefly.
: The flea-elephant analogy Is a rather hackneyed image aten used to give verbal force • ar. argument about relative Eur and to induce a sense of marty: to bring people back to es-- where inflated estimates .: ÷ -importance are operating .. ..=* minds.
zould never criticise the S7.? for being small. What is to - criticised is their failure to - *e to this, their delusions of zardeur. their inflated belief i-=: they constitute an alter-ace to the Labour Party for :: 'ands of workers. In this ..ation it is essential to argue - -tully that their assessments -r from a politically debilita-e lack of proportion.
• suggestion that that distinction. Gardners was not the SWP's Minneapolis or even Cowley Assembly Plant, by a very long chalk. The political direction of the dispute was 'Broad Left' - the political basis of its leaders such as John Tocher and Tommy McAfee.
3. If the SWP can't mobilise its own members, who can? The problem is that it lacks the ability to influence and mobilise wider potentially important layers of workers in the way even the CP did from the '20s to the '60s. It is in no position to mobilise workers on the scale of the LCDTU a decade ago.
The problem again is that it does not come to terms with this - witness the lightminded resolutions for strike action passed at Rank and File conferences with no chance of them being acted upon.
4. Again, if the SWP is not actively committed to its own front, the Right to Work Campaign, then who is? Fair dos, this campaign was very useful indeed in highlighting the problem of unemployment: much less so in mobilising support to fight it.
I think the reason for this stems from the SWP's failure to grasp the powerful attachment of workers to the existing labour movement and the fact that the existing leadership runs the show not simply through organisational mantical basis for that commitment?
My own view would be that the SWP failed to attempt to educate and develop the youth attracted to the ANL by raising. for example, the question of the link between immigration controls and racism, by pushing for the ANL to support workers' defence, by arguing against those who supported state bans.
6. Surely the comrades are not seriously arguing that the SWP's internal democracy is in any way adequate. They should talk to the members of the various expelled oppositions from Workers' Fight to the ISO on this question.
This is a key area, where we have to tell the truth and not try to brylcreem SWP members with diplomatic evasions. The SWP represents a gross caricature of the democratic centralism it claims to support.
7. Now who's into insults and jibes? 'Crude Trotskyist' -moi? My mum says that's like calling Nat Cole a rough blues shouter or Viv Richards a crude slogger!
Finally, I hope that future writers will not take the comrades' advice on pussyfooting. but will continue to express themselves thoughtfully but, where needed, forcetully. The best elements in the SWP, as in the labour movement generally. appreciate a little plain talking.
JÓHN McILROY proposing that a campaign be built over the coming year on a 'no rate rise' basis, with particular emphasis on the trade unions, in order to test its 'feasibility' - not, as comrade Woodward suggests, to decide there and then whether or not it was feasible.
The purpose of the conference was to bring together labour movement bodies throughout the region to gain support for such a move.
As for the delegates who made it clear that 'it would mean conflict with the unions" these were mainly the branch officials of the local unions -many of whom had not even consulted their membership on the question of rate rises, never mind attempted to build support for such a stand. But this is the crux of the whole issue.
At a Regional Labour Party aggregate held at the end of last year, there was general agreement that rate rises meant a cut in working-class living standards and would become impossible anyway because of proposed government legislation. There was also a trend present at the aggregate, and dominant at the special conference, that argued 'people have to pay for their services' ,and 'we would have to convince people the services were 'value for money' ernment stops cutting back on Advertisement ACTION After Wembley:
organising for left unity Edinburgh. itant' and Afghanistan