Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The strange case of Newsline's switch on Be

Socialist Organiser no. 40, 2 May 1981 · scan p. 8 · about 1,124 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

for merely providing man deeply concerned the Tories with the future polices of tr Newsline thinks Benn knows willfully trying to break he can't win. "So what then mass movement and is he playing at?", they ask unnecessary diver. indignantly. In the agent and (Emphasis added). The spy-obsessed WRP world the no two answers to a q question translates auto- when it's put like that!

at, Mr pro-EEC, and pro-armed ulterior motive, who is he Benn? Whose game a serving, whose agent is he? playing? Who are you I work- Of course, if Benn didn't These are the fundamental ing for? What sort of : writer of these things and would The Newsline writer goes on obviously thinks he rhetorically, "Is this [standing The clue, which he shar against Healey] the action of a the reader is in the ans PAGE 8 The News Line Wednesday April 15, 1981 PAGE 8 The News Line Monday April 6, 1981 This | April 6, 1981 morning ...

morning. _ Benn's right In the past three days there has bee reaction is condemnation of Benn than there has beet Labour Parties where there is protout disy Healey. They say it is not helpful t Labour's ranks - and Benn has provided been busily telephoning the capitalist thoroughly-hated Tories have only one card to NEWCI INC NEWOLING, daily 'newspaper' of the WRP, has unmasked a new Tory agent [or worse] in the labour movement - Tony Benn!

In virulently hostile ed itorial on 1L-I.L_. ine Labour Veputy Leadership elections entitled 'The strange case of Mr Benn' (15. 4.8t), he is denounced for splitting the left, for going against 'the trade unions', for defying the majority of Tribune MPs who oppose his candidature, and ammunition!

matically to mean: what is the questions of all WRP life.

Fi about ne Labour Party and ar ati-Tory struggle, or someone who is : up the create sions ere are uestion So have you got th Are you forces"

agent stand, Healey would be none are you? The Newsline knows. obligingly cease to be deputy es with leader too! Therefore by swer to opposing him in the election adewood perfent -• _thanu W€ the question: what will be the result of the election if Benn loses it? The profound thinkers of the WRP have succeeded in working it out in advance: if th Benn loses, Healey will be Cc deputy leader. Thus, concluan des the editorial, "By his actan ion, Benn is consolidating Ssp Healey" ', who is "pro-NATO, th co cic *st thi an Tr. enn is aiding the " ATO, pro-EEC, pro-IMF 'o-armed forces" cause. Since for the Newsline e WRP all the world's i arre novel and all the 1 id women in it either ag Id their dupes or intre 'y-hunters — themselve: at translates for the h. re readers into sometł ›se to the view that trange' Mr. Benn knows is and works to achiev, d therefore must be... eti Benn, like advocates sistance to the Tories an: bour councils who admi proand and 1 Le men ents epid ardhing the ; all e it d to ,nISter the cuts, is thus bracketed as one of "Thatcher's people" - and implicitly as worse.

There is a political logic to this of course. Yet it was very sudden, Newsline's chiming in with the anti-Benn crescendo of the Tory press. Until the previous day it had championed Benn and supported his candidacy! Its first response was a reflex-left attack on Foot and Co. ('Foot shows his colours"' April 3rd). An editorial (''Foot shows his real colours" , April 4th) went right down the line for Benn against Foot and his Tribunite allies:

"This (Foot's argument) is intended to try to put Benn in the position of a splitter who is disrupting realey. In reality it is an argument against ever having an election for the leading posts since there will never be an ideal occasion to nold it... Foot appeals to Benn on the basis of party unity, but this is simply a cover for capitulating to the blackmail of the right wing (emphasis added) who keep threatening to join the Social Democrats unless they get their way in That is not at all badly put. Aneditorial (''Benn is rignt io stand", April 6th) continues in the same strong terms. Healey is 'the IMF's man in the Shadow Cabinet". Trade union "bureaucrats" who say Benn's candidacy is 'not helpful to party unity" 'have been stirred from their sleep because they see another challenge to the right wing in to someone helping the right wing strengthen their position.

Ten days later Newsline threw the book at Benn in an editorial "Mr. Bern the ardent Zionist", which was a meandering diatribe clearly aimed at the WRP's friends, the Arab generals and million aires who run Libya and Iraq.

The editorial, which also denounced the vigorously anti-Zionist SWP as proZionist, may have been aimed to explain its change of line to the WRP's Arab wellwishers.

Why the change of line? No explicit explanation is offered to Newsline readers (though the encoded references pointed WRPers towards the 'explanation' that Benn is some sort of an 'agent').

Libel

My opinion is that it was probably the WRP's response to Benn's signing the SO condemnation of the WRP's libel case and the call for a Labour movement inquiry: nothing else in the situation was new at that point. The precise explanation doesn't matter very much though.

The point of tediously tracing the line' of the WRP on this is that it shows graphically what the WRP is. No political organisation, whose members possessed and exercised normal critical judgement or were influenced by the common human need for consistency and its corollary. rational explanation tor changes and about-faces could make such an erratic zIg-zag, expiainea only by half-hidden insinuation based on assertion and black-isreally-white logic.

The point is that the WRP, which began as a genuine political tendency, has long since become a depoliticised apparatus which uses politics and political ideas where they serve its leaders' interests and drives, but for which politics is no longer central or the determinant of what it does (and doesn't do) or who it will ally with.

Spies The apparatus is self-perpetuating with unstable politics " and a membership conditioned to think of the world in essentiallv apolitical terms of spies and conspiracies on the one hand, and, on the other, to blindly follow every word of an infallible and all-seeing leadership, which does, says (and gainsays) what it likes. Actions which define

----- pull-quotes -----

MONDAY to stand KICK OUT THE TORIES! : democracy and the Pamphlet for a

Strange of Mr

April 15, 1981 • case Benn

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 40

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →