Why Did We Lose Norwood?
Socialist Organiser1981 1981-05-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
by Les Hearn REAGAN'S (free enterpri sramme to w EVERY cloud has a silver lining, was the motto of the Tory press as it reported the election results on May 7th. And the silver lining was the defeat of Ted Knight in forwood.
The media hailed it as a rebuff for the left. Ted Knight himself, corsered by the gloating media. people, put the result down to press smears.
The "rebuff-for-the-left" theory is certainly wrong: many well-known left-wing candid. aves. like Steve Bundred in Istington North, Tony Banks in Tooting, Frances Morrell in Istington South and Ken Livingstone in Paddington won with bigger-than-average swings.
But press smears aren't a full explanation, either. Papers like the 'Standard' have done all tbey can to brand Knight as an irresponsible fanatic; but their latest blow for e is te lalt a proun pa ents a rout efforts have been puny compared to the media campaign against Tony Benn, which Benn has survived with no damage at all to his electoral popularity.
Was Knight's defeat
triumph for the Social Democrats? Probably not. Stephen Haseler got 3,700 votes in Norwood; but everywhere else the Social Democrats flopped badly, and in Streatham [another of the Lambeth constituencies], there was an even bigger swing from Labour than in Norwood, without the help of a Social Democrat. It's quite probably that most of Haseler's 3,700 were voters who would otherwise have gone Tory or not voted at all.
So was it Lambeth Council's big rate rises? That seems to be part of the truth.
Labou pattern can be made of Is three worst results -Streatham, Norwood and CHEMICALS possible adverse effects of ten controversial prescription drugs, the ten being the most common. ly prescribed drugs in the US, accounting for one prescription in every six.
They include Valium, Librium, the anti-ulcer drug cimeti. dine, the painkiller proposyphene, and several gthers with a variety of side-effects such as addiction or which may be dangHampstead - it is a pattern of losses for Labour in middle-class areas in Labour-controlled high-rate-raising boroughs.
In working-class areas, the picture was different. Islington, where the rates are just as high as in Lambeth, had a very big swing to Labour, so did Newham, where the council imposed a 52% rate rise last month.
In Camden, which has the highest rates in the country, left-winger Charlie Rossi [in Holborn] and right-winger Anne Sofer [in St. Pancras North] gained about average swings to Labour, and Labour did badly only in Hampstead.
In Lambeth itself, candidates standing to the left of Ted Knight won the more working-class constituencies of Lambeth Central and Vauxhall, with results that were bad by London standards but much better than o 8698 erous if taken with certain other drugs.
The programme already marked a significant retreat from an original proposal for information inserts with 375 drugs, which aroused strong protests from the drug industry. Pharmacists claim that the inserts are not really necessary because there are several books on the market which give results in Norwood, and in Lambeth generally, must be more complex.
Labour voters are usually pretty tolerant and undemanding - partly out of class loyalty, partly out of political cynicism.
But they are not tolerant towards people who play with their hopes and aspirations.
And that's what Ted Knight has He has promised a fight against the Tories. He has presented himself as the champion of militant socialism. And what has resulted? A small flurry of demonstrations and declarations - and then the huge rate demands, and then the cuts, just the same sort of cuts as in Labour boroughs which made no pretence of being militant.
Halfway
When Knight did start organising against the Tories, there was a response that showed that enthusiastic mass support could have been won on the streets and in the polling booths for a consistent stand. But the aboutturn disillusioned not only marginal Labour voters, but also many Labour activists.
There is a general lesson here for the whole left, and also for the new GLC Labour group. Those who make a revolution half-way dig their own graves, said Saint-Just. The same goes for those who start a serious struggle and turn back halfway.
information about drugs, and, anyway, the patients can always ask their local chemist.
But suppose you can't afford the books, or can't understand the scientific language. And who's going to have a discussion with their local chemist [who may not be willing or able to explain anyway] while a queue of irate customers builds up behind them?
So, while a tiny reform is withdrawn in the US, what is the situation in Britain? Patients in Britain have to swallow the tablets and trust the doctors. Perhaps we should be pushing for more information about the medicines we take.
ONCE AGAIN, the system whereby adverse side-effects of new drugs and interactions with other drugs are detected by the drug industry has fallen down. Research recently publ ished in the US on the antiulcer drug cimetidine shows that Labour's greatest ever result in Hornsey was achieved with us sending not one word of copy to the paper, and with it printing a litany of attacks on Throughout the campaign it was clear that there was strong support for the Labour programme of attacking the Government and changing the transport policies to aid working people; but the press attacks on the Labour Party had led to some confusion among supporters over what we were actually proposing.
Our strategy for the election was to decide on what issue we wanted to fight, and stick to them, thus forcing the Tories to answers us on our ground. So far as we were concerned, the issues on which we fought the campaign were the withdrawal of Government funds from local government, unemployment, nuclear waste and weapons, and the Nationality Bill.
Through the campaign the Labour canvassers were finding the largest swings to Labour on council estates where the effect of the Tory government was at its most tangible — rent increases and a 43% rate rise, together with in addition to reducing acid production in the stomach (its intended role), cimetidine also significantly reduces blood-flow through the liver. A common dose would cut flow by 25%.
Now, the liver, in addition to being the power house of the body, also deals with foreign chemicals circulating round in the blood, which as far as the body knows may be poisonous, and converts them into harmless waste products. These foreign chemicals obviously include any other drugs that a patient may be taking.
But people with ulcers are often suffering from anxiety, for which the drug propanolol (an anti high blood pressure drug) is a recommended treatment. So if you were given ordinary doses of propanolol while also taking cimetidine, the level of propanolol in the blood would be about 25% above the normal level because of the reduced flow of blood through the liver.
worked to get the Labour vote out - certainly more than al any other local election, and only 200 less than helped • try to f9t As the retres ctede in in it was clear where the Labour victory had come from; the turnout on council estates was higher than the constituency average — nearly every polling district reported turnour Activists in Hornsey see this as only the start - a massive recruitment drive will now be getting under way to boost membership (already about 1200) by bringing into membership all the people who voted Labour last week -all those who get a raw deal from society.
The most vital thing is for the Labour GLC to carry out the programme it was elected on, and to mount the strongest possible opposition to the Tory Government. Credibility for the labour movement can only come from the realisation of the Labour programme.
The Hornsey result is not unique; it shows that if the Party relies on its own resources, and its own people, and continuously campaigns on all the issues, then victory is there to be won.
You would be experiencing an overdose of a drug which produces its own nasty sideeffects, and this has in fact happened to patients in the US.
Worse still this effect could have been predicted two years ago on the basis of the then current knowledge of how cimetidine works, and in any case should have been picked up by observation of patients after it was put on the market _ observa ion which was not done.
Cimetidine is the first of 18 class of drugs called H2-blockers to be put on the market. Can it be that safety checks were skimped so as to be first on the scene?
Another H2-blocker has since appeared which does nOt have this side-effect? Was there a race between the two?
(P.S.: Cimetidine also has this effect on valium, phenytoin [an anti-epileptic drug] and warfarin [taken to prevent thrombosis: an overdose causes internal bleeding]).
Scan page 4
May
----- pull-quotes -----
Let then read DOOKS
of Labour voters of 66%, and in two cases nearly 80%. Drive