"The principle'
Socialist Organiser1981 1981-05-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
THREE MONTHS and three separate libel writs later, Paul Jennings' letter (Tribune, May 1) is the first attempt by the Workers Revolutionary Party to justify Vanessa Redgrave's "recourse to the capitalist courts" against both the printers and individuals connected with the Labour movement paper Socialist Organiser. We are told that Socialist Organiser's criticism of the WRP had 'nothing whatsoever to do with legitimate political differences of opinion' and that "the capitalist courts" were "the only way to clear" Vanessa Redgrave's name.
For an organisation that accuses opponents of being (among other things) police agents, it is not clear what for Paul Jennings is the difference between a legitimate and a "wholly non-political" criticism. Presumably it is whether it is aimed against the WRP or not. Socialist Organiser would not accept such a definition, nor do we believe it is only "legitimate" to criticise policies but not the nature and practices of organisations espousing them. We would not only criticise Stalinist parties because they had wrong ideas!
However outspoken, Socialist Organiser believes the quoted statements to be justified, and indeed indicated the source of some of the evidence in the original article (a fact conveniently omitted from Paul Jennings' quote).
The statements were made because they could be backed up, and now Paul Jennings has repeated them in Tribune we and others would be happy to provide the evidence in these pages. What we are not prepared to do is to say they are "untrue" and 'unfounded" because the WRP asserts that they are and threatens us with "the capitalist courts" and the inevitable heavy legal costs.
Paul Jennings finds the reasons for the criticisms "especially curious" , although the political basis for them was spelt out at length in a later issue of Socialist Organiser. Although he doesn't mention this statement, he must have read it because it was the immediate subject of a further libel writ from Vanessa Redgrave..
He must also know that the subsequent libel writ means that the statement cannot be summarised fully in reply to his letter. That presumably was the intention of the writ.
Vanessa Redgrave was not mentioned in the original article, nor was the "Youth Training moveapparently "the capitalist courts" are the only way "to clear her name" • This is not true.
There has yet to be a "repudiation" in the pages of Neu'sline. Presumably this is not "the firmest possible way" , although it sias the way the WRP chose to deal recently with what it regarded as unfounded accusations in the rich Tory press (Daily Telegraph and The Observer).
There has been no request for a right of reply in the pages of Socialist Organiser, although a conditional one was offered after the legal threats. There has been no reply to the offer of a jointly agreed Labour movement inquiry to investigate the statements. Paul Jennings' letter does not even mention this, although it is scarcely a secret.
Already Tony Benn and six other Labour MPs, as well as Chris Mullin, Vladimir Derer and many other individuals and organisations in the Labour movement have supported the call for such an inquiry, and condemned Vanessa Redgrave's and the WRP's use of the courts against a Labour movement paper.
It would have been interesting to hear Paul Jennings' explanation of the apparent rejection of the type of inquiry Newsline often calls for in relation to other organisations. Is the rejection of an open inquiry inside the Labour movement because there is not the confidence to make a political response to our comments?
The legal action that Paul Jennings' letter seeks to justify involyes more than a refusal to debate the issues inside the Labour movement. It flies in the face of the basic principle that we should sort out disputes inside the Labour movement, and not bring the courts in. And it seeks to "settle"
an argument by using financial and legal threats, which money has given Vanessa Redgrave access to.
" That is the only explanation for the succession of libel writs, including against the secretary of Socialist Organiser for writing & letter to supporters explaining what was happening and the need to raise money to cover the legal costs. And it was the threat of bankruptcy that forced Socialis:
Orgamiser's printer to delete al reference to the WRP from the paper, including a simple finan cial appeal. On these issues Pau Jennings'* letter is '' silent JOHN BLOXAN