Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[JOHN McILROY examines the Bevanite moveme 1950s and…]

Socialist Organiser no. 41, 16 May 1981 · scan p. 13 · about 697 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

JOHN McILROY examines the Bevanite moveme 1950s and its lessons for today, in a review of two s the movement: 'Bevanism — Labour's High Tide' Jenkins [Spokesman Books, £12.50], and 'The Rise of Bevanişm' by David Howell JILP, 45p].

THIRTY YEARS ago this April, Nye Bevan, Harold Wilson and John Freeman resigned from the Attlee government, concerned over defence expenditure and the introduction of charges into the National Health Service.

Korea had brought home to the Left the extent of the Government's subordination to US policy, and the ambitious Cold War springs of that policy. They feared the distorted priorities this subservience would impose particularly in relation to reforms at home.

In his resignation speech, Bevan widened the front and attacked the government for a loss of socialist direction. It is from this date that Bevanism - the Left's reaction to the limitations of the 1945 government — is usually dated.

In fact, Bevan placed himself at the head of a movement which was already developing in response to the policies of the government to which he had belonged for five years.

It was only a matter of months before that, as Minister of Labour, Bevan had been involved in the imprisonment of striking dockers under the notorious Order 1305 (an anti-strike law introduced during the war, and continued by the Labour government after 1945).

A Keep Left group of MPs to some extent associated with Tribune had been established, and was to provide several of Bevan's adjutants. This group had already produced pamphlets, and in fact had taken the struggle into the constituencies, organising the first Brains Trusts.

In 1949 the Socialist Fellowship had been established, involving not only the British Trotskyists but MPs such as Ellis Smith and Tom Braddock and leading trade unionists such as Jim Figgins of the NUR and Jack Stanley of the Constructional Engineering Union. Some of these people split away when the Trotskyists supported North Korea against the United Nations troops, but the Fellowship and its associated newspaper, Socialist Outlook, made such a strong impression that it was proscribed in mid-1954. Many of its supporters were to constitute the ranks of Bevanism.

The Bevanite MPs met regularly as a group throughout 1951. From 15, the group grew to 30. However, they never grouped together even all the Parliamentary Left.

Ten specialist groups were set up to study policy. Tours and itineraries for speaking engagements were established, and spokesmen appointed to put the group line in Parliamentary debates.

During the summer pamphlets One Way Only and Going Our Way? were produced Labour's defeat in the autumn 1951 electien provided new impetus. Tribune pointed out that if the voting patterns for all constituencies had followed those for the Bevanite MPs, then the narrow defeat would have been a comfortable victory. •In March 1952 Bevan Ont of the ¡tudies of by Mark and Fall Aneurin Bevan 57 MPs voted against defence proposals.

The Parliamentary Labour leadership's line was to vote with the Tories: it was Labour, after all, that had started a huge rearmament drive and sent British troops to Korea. A campaign by the Right in both unions and Party, backed virulently by the Press, led to a Parliamentary Labour Party vote that the Bevanite group should be disbanded.

The Bevanites adapted to the ban by splitting their activities into two fields. The 'first eleven' consisted of the MPs meeting clandestinely each week at Crossman's house. The 'second eleven' consisted of the most organisationminded of the parliamentary Bevanites, meeting with Iribune activists to plan propaganda and constituency work.

At the 1952 Conference, the group won six out of the seven constituency seats on the National Executive. Bevan stood against Morrison as Deputy Leader, but was deteated by 194 votes to 82. During 1953, hundreds of Brains Trusts were held -up to eight a week — attracting thousands of constituency activists.

But the right-wing witchhunt gathered momentum. The feel of the times can be gauged by the comment of Will Lawther of the miners' union, "The opinion of the trade unions is that the Beyanite activities are a deliberate attempt to undermine the Tribune took up the cudgels ive dimensions of Bevanism

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 41

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →