Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Labour's Left the last time round

Socialist Organiser no. 41, 16 May 1981 · scan p. 13 · about 986 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

leadership in the same way as Hitler and the Communists did. There is no difference whatever between them".

Expulsions increased. In July 1954 Socialist Outlook was proscribed. Resolutions from 119 Labour Parties opposed the ban.

German rearmament became a burning issue. A pamphlet, It Need Not Happen, had a mass sale, and at the 1954 conference the Bevanites' opposition to German rearmament was lost by only 3,270,000 to 3,022,000. The Bevanites did not pose the issue in internationalist terms, as the Trotskyists did. but cashed in on nationalistic anti-German sentiments. Bevan stood against Gaitskell for Treasurer and lost by 4.338.000 to 2.032,000.

for union democracy against the right-wing Arthur Deakin of the TGWU, many of whose docker members had split to join the Stevedores and Dockers' Union. Meetings were held, pamphlets were produced, Tribune was sold at the dock gates. but the intervention in the docks, as distinct from "brainstrusting', was untypical.

Bevan, like Benn today, certainly failed to stimulate and support direct action by workers.

SPLIT

Nuclear disarmament was now becoming a major issue.

Bevan clashed with Attlee in the Commons (March 1955), and this was followed by a revolt of left MPs. The PLP voted to withdraw the whip from Bevan, but his expulsion was lost by one vote on the NEC.

From then on it was anti-climax. Gaitskell won both the Treasurership and Leadership elections from Bevan at a canter in 1955. Nye settled for domestication and the promise of influence.

He joined Gaitskell's Shadow Cabinet, and won the vote for Treasurer in 1956. But then in 1957 he broke dramatically with his followers, denouncing unilateral disarmament at the 1957 conference. "Bevan into Bevin" , remarked the Telegruph, referring to the rightwing ex-Foreign Secretary and TGWU leader.

He ended as the faded and not too credible elder statesman at Gaitskell's elbow in the 1959 election. Bevan died in 1960. In October 1964, after '13 wasted years' , the day of the Bevanites finally dawned, as Wilson formed a government with Crossman, Greenwood, Davies, Wigg and Castle. The resi we know to our cost.

Two points strike us today: the extremely narrow range of issues on which the Bevanites campaigned, and their almost complete lack of success.

It was, of course, a different world. The achievement of the Attlee years was generally seen not as a reorganisation of capitalism carried out within a broad consensus, but rather as an important, if limited, step in the direction of socialism. The leadership's prestige, and its close links with a and its relationship with the trade unions, underestimated by previous writers such as David Coates.

We have to remember that despite austerity, rationing, and the use of troops against strikes and in Greece and Korea, Labour achieved its highest-ever vote in the lost 1951 election - almost 14 million as against 11.5 in 1979. As Bevanism' emerged between 1947 and 1952, individual membership increased by 406,037. Trade union affiliate membership was 27% higher in 1957 than in 1947, individual membership 50% higher. The biggest increase occurred between 1951 and 1954. as Bevanism peaked.

Jenkins sees an unimpeded and gradual march of the Left in the Party and unions since the '50s. •Whatever controversy may surround the record of the Wilson governments, it was a period of steady advance of the Left within the unions and the Party, the kind of development which Aneurin Bevan projected • and worked for' This kind of analysis misses and obscures the reasons for the conjunctural ebbs and flows, reverses and steps forward. It is related to Jenkins' conception of a strong organic Left, gradually and inevitably maturing in tune with objective circumstances. There is a certain over-optimism and fatalism, as if the Bevanites could have done no other than they did.

This in turn leads to an underappreciation of the serious weakness of the Labour Left, then and now, and an under-estimation of leadership and organisation. Bevanite organisation, we are told, was quite adequate for their perspectives. Basically, the Party organisation itself was sufficient.

Once the Brains Trusts became popular, Jenkins argues, Socialist Outlook, the Trotskyist-influenced paper. " ... became superfluous to the Left's requirements and the development of its struggle"

Now Jenkins is quite right to stress that a 'hard left' should swim in the stream of a developing broad left current, relating to its concerns order to clarify it. To do this, however, it will need to produce its own agitation and propaganda.

ership would take decisio and articles would be types for Tribune before the gro:

had even a chance to meet!

Despite this, Jenkins' bai should be a must to order fro your library.

Howell has done a uset job within the confines of short pamphlet. In particula he stresses the Bevanite:

striving for an internation:

perspective, and he analyse the forces at work within th unions to show that they di not present a monolithi right face. He shows the spec fic and at times autonomou processes at work, rather tha seeing changes within the un ions as having a one-to-on:

relationship with changes it the Party.

Howell comes closer tha:

Jenkins to explaining th:

crucial failure of Bevanism Objective constraints wer important, but central was th:

view that a Parliamentary Lat our government had the pone:

in itself to destroy capitalism and by gradual means. The mass movement was inessent.

ial, often a problem.

This optimistic view of the state was, of course, strengthened by the 1945 experience. The result was, as Ralph Miliband has pointed out, ... Parliamentary Beranism was a mediation between the leadership and the rank and file opposition. Harold Wilson But the parliamentary Bevanites, while assuming the leadership of that opposition, also served to blur and to blunt both its strength. and its extent"

Within the Left's parlia mentarianism, Howell correct. ly points to the castrating effect of 'unity to win elections' Howell also stresses the deradicalisation process operat-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 41

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →