Useless,o misused?
Socialist Organiser1981 1981-05-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
squeeze on the rates ICE MAURICE LUDMER, a leading fighter against racism and fascism, died on May 14th of a heart attack, aged 54.
He had worked with the War Graves Commission after the war and witnessed Belsen in 1946. He said in an interview last year, "I took an oath then to fight fascism"
In the '50s and '60s he worked closely with the national minorities workers' organisations, and in Birmingham in 1960 _uamer CP refused to take an adequate stand against Powellite racism.
Striving to win the organised working class to the anti-racist struggle, he became increasingly involved in Birmingham Trades Council and was President from 1979. He was instrumental, with the Trades Council and national minority workers' and other organisations, in forming Birmingham CARF in 1977, and he was Chairman asd Honorary President.
He was a prominent investigative journalist, working to expose fascism as editor from 1975 of the anti-fascist monthly Searchlight, and also in work for television. He was a founding member of the Anti-Nazi League.
I'D LIKE TO add a footnote to my interview with Ken Livingstone published in SO no.38.
In that interview, Livingstone told me what he saw as the strength of the broad London Labour Party left-wing current of which he is part. Its policies 'may not be ideologically perfect', but it has 'a strong commitment to make sure [the policies] are implemented' - in contrast to 'some more theoretical tendencies' I did not pursue that argument much in the interview. There were too many other issues to chase. But some comments made by Livingstone rary?
is 'abstentionist', and that 'the no cuts position requiring rate rises has been a necessary temporary retreat whilst the forces are assembled" for a fight.
Yet Briefing comrades in Brent have been arguing for this 'temporary retreat' for at least two years now. And, rather than moving towards a stand against rate rises, this year Briefing supporters dropped even their previous 'no rent rise' policy in Brent.
PETE FIRMIN, Brent. and in the whole of Wales only 1421 persons can be found who match up to the SDP's demanding intellectual standards. Denis Healey HEALEY PERSECUTED Spare a thought for poor Dennis Healey. His application to join the National Union of Journalists Freelance Branch is being blocked on the spurious grounds that he doesn't make a living from journalism and that he is a member of the scab 'union', the Institute of Journalists. What will they think of next?
since being elected Labour GLO
leader raise the same point from a different angle.
Pursued by goggle-eyed Fleet Street reporters who demanded to know whether he was really a Mathiehad neversed Mary and that he had never read Marx and preferred to be called a 'radical' The implication was clear: that he had never seen it as sufficiently important to read Marx.
The traditional Labour Left has long lived on ineffectual good intentions. Much of the Marxist Left has contented itself with sectarian self-justification as a substitute for real involvement in the mass movement. On both sides, policies are debated with little reference to putting them into action. Against this background, Livingstone's stress on shelving the quibbles and getting on with some action, even not ideologically perfect' makes sense.
Better someone who doesn't read Marx but who starts a real fight against the Tories and the right wing, than a Marxist for whom each book leads only to the next book and never to action. Better also than people like Ted Knight or (in a different context) Eric Heffer, who use their Marxist education to spin arguments for retreat when it is time for an all-out fight.
But is theory really so useless? Or is it just mis-used?
The Labour Left's policies have not just failed for lack of energetic people. They have failed because they are based on no clear theoretical understanding of capitalist society and the conservative forces within it. Efforts to get the capitalist state to legislate harmony and justice are bound to end in farce.
What is to stop the current London Labour programme becoming equally utopian? What is to stop the GLC Labour Left ending up like the Camden Council Labour left (of which Ken Livingstone is also part) -who approved cuts for the sake of making a compromise with LOCAL COUNCILS will lose £450 million of their grants from the Government if they don't cut their spending for 1981-2 to 5.6% lower than their 1978-9 figures.
This will fuel the rate rise spiral, as councils who can't make up the cut will put in a supplementary rate demand. In metropolitan county areas such as Manchester it could mean two supplementary rate rises [Greater Manchester has 'overspent' by £22 million and Manchester City council by £13.6 million].
The 'temporary' option of rate rises to buy time to build up a fight against the Government is becoming institutionalised into a strategy of making the ratepayers bear the cost of a vindictive Tory government. So the Tories win either way, either forcing through cuts, or forcing high-spending urban areas [mostly Labour-controlled] to take a disproportionate share of the cost of local services -or both.
And the working class again expected to pay.
IN SCOTLAND, mentary rate opti a possibility. This crunch in Lot the ›pleI is even coul id to ian next Marx Write back Organiser, Court, Lon the Labour Right and thus stopping the Labour Right doing a deal with the Tories?
The Camden council left's compromise, it seems to me, was based on an over-emphasis on 'getting something done' in the council chamber and the corridors, at the expense of a broader political view. I hope I'm wrong - but the same overemphasis could be fatal for the Labour GLC.
The point is not how much better a GLC leader Ken Livingstone would be if he took a month off to study Capital and the Communist Manifesto - nor that the GLC Labour group should adopt Socialist Organiser as a theoretical advisory team!
The point is that a broad left which focuses on assembling forces for the immediate fight against the right wing, and which plays down theoretical precision, is not enough - at least not on its own.
We also need an organised left wing which focuses on political and theoretical clarity, which sets out to educate as well as to organise, and which mobilises the diverse talents and experience of its supporters into a collective effort to make theory a guide to action and practical experience a guide to theory.
That's what we must try to build in the Socialist Organiser MARTIN THOMAS, London.
to Socialist c/o 214 Sickert san N1 2SY January.
The Local Government [Misceilaneous Provisions| [Scotland] Bill, now winding its way through the Lords, will give the Secretary of State for Scotland the power to order any council to reduce rates if he considers them 'excessive' If they refuse, he can immediately cut the Government grant by an amount equivalent to the income raised by the 'excessive' rates. In Scotland the law prohibits supplementary rates, and short-term borrowing is allowable only against expected income.
So a cut in Government money would lead to an immed. iate crisis. Lothian put in a 50% rate increase for 1981-2, which is definitely regarded as excessive by George Younger, the Scottish Secretary. By mid-January, it is expected to have its grant stopped, which will mean defaulting on its loan repayments and the receiver being brought in.
Will Lothian, which effectively has its back to the wall, be the first council to confront the Government head-on?
The alternative is frantic cuts in the next six months.
If Lothian is to take on the Government and win, massive working class industrial and political action will be required. That has to be built for now