Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

['We've also spent a lot of this first…]

Socialist Organiser no. 42, 30 May 1981 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 702 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

'We've also spent a lot of this first couple of weeks considering our relationship to the Labour Party outside. Almost all my first two days were spent in drawing up proposals, which the Labour group agreed, to reduce the powers of •the leadership.

"We've removed all patronage from the Leader by Vladimir Derer* ANOTHER • stage in the strugle for mandatory reselection may well have ended by the time this issue of Socialist Organiser reaches its readers. But even should this be so, and it is by no means certain, the struggle for mandatory re-selection is bound to go on in some other form.

Following the West Bromwich West farce (the General Committee [GC] of this Constituency Labour Party [CLP] decided by 23 votes to 21 to 'shortlist' the sitting MP even though another nominee was backed by eight nominating bodies) the Labour Party National Executive Committee [NEC]'s Organisation Committee is proposing that every GC delegate must be given a copy of the NEC guidelines to reselection.

These, it is also proposed, must make it clear that a shortlist of one is acceptable only where the only nominations are for the sitting MP.

This proposal, however, was carried by 9 votes to 7.

The majority was so narrow partly because, somewhat unusually, both Michael Foot and Dennis Healey were present, but also because some NEC members who could normally be counted on to vote in favour of democratic reforms failed to do so on this occasion (Neil Kinnock and two members representing the trade union section voted against the proposal).

Thus the NEC's deci.

"We're also setting up an ethnic minorities committee, which will have a wider remit than just the staff in this building = it will campaign on the Nationality Bill and issues affecting minorities right the way through London. It will start out by havsion remains in doubt.

The case in favour of a "shortlist of one' is an extremely poor one. It rests on a seeming ambiguity in the working of the Party constitution and a badly worded sentence in the NEC's guidelines to re-selection.

The constitution lays down the following:

'The Executive Committee of this Party [the CLP] may tender such advice as it deems necessary to the General Committee on the nominations found to be valid, and may suggest to the General Committee the manner in which they shall be dealt with (Rules for Constituency Labour Parties, Clause XIV, Section 7(e)).

All this means is that the amend the proposed manner General Committee may in which the nominations are dealt with, in practice mainly to add further nominees. In other words, the final decision on this must rest with the General Committee.

The end of the above paragraph, however, reads as follows:

'The. General Committee shall then fix a date for a special meeting to decide which nomination, if any, shall be submitted to the National Executive Committee for endorsement as prospective Parliamentary candidate This means that it is the 'special meeting' and the 'special meeting" alone which can decide 'which nomination, if any' shall be sent to the NEC. If the 'shortlisting and reduces the choice to only one nominee, the 'special meeting' cannot take this decision, since it would not have the opportunity to consider the relative merits of all the nominees, or, should this not be practicable, at least of those shortlisted.

Since the constitution requires that the choice as to who shall be the prospective parliamentary candidate be made by the 'special meeting , any attempt to pre-empt its decision at another meetine must be regarded as unconstitutional. This quite apart from he fact that selection by catference by shortlisting de prives validly nominated candidates of their constitutional right to be heard and judged by the only body entitled to do so, and arbitrarily rules out the choice of the nominating bodies made under the constitutional procedure required by Section 3 of Clause XIV.

The present guidelines issued by the NEC do not make the case of the anti;

reformers any better. Reference to them merely highlights the unfortunate fact that instead of being explicit, the guidelines, like the constitution, need interpretation. The argument in favour of the

Scan page 4

age 4

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 42

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →