The strings and the trap
Socialist Organiser1981 1981-06-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Due for linecks - and not giving in! The articles on this page are taken from the latest issue of Women's Fightback. There's lots more, including a big feature on the Women's Festival.
Copies 10p each, plus postage, from 41 Ellington Street, London N7.
I WENT down to the Roy. al Pride picket line at two in the afternoon. It was pouring with rain. Jean, Helen and Marie, three of the strikers, were sitting on a milk crate huddled under an umbrella.
I asked the girls to start at the beginning.
•Well, in November we started negotiating for a rise of at least 10%, after two years of only getting 5%. The boss, Novak, said he would consider it if he got plenty of orders in at the Birmingham trade exhibition!
After the exhibition he said he couldn't give us a rise at all - in fact he said we'd have to have a 20% cut.
'At the time, there were about 27 workers not counting office staff. About 10 of the production workers were blokes. Most of the girls were doing skilled production obs, while the men did Should women be paid to look after their own kids?
We discussed this quest.
ion at the latest Women' Fightback forum in London. Zöe Fairbairns, author of the novel 'Benefits' and of a recent controversial article in Spare Rib on this topic, outlined her views.
We must have something to say, she argued, to all those women who do choose to stay at home and look after kids. It's patronising to suggest that they don't know what they want, have been conned by the motherhood myth, etc. They're doing the work for no. thing, and they need money, need to break out of their dependence and poverty.
So whatever we call it they should have money, as this increases their choices.
'Whatever we call it' turned out in the discussion to be vital. We explored the seeming contradiction that on the one hand we were all wholeheartedly. in favour of mainly packing and labouring.
'Well, the girls all refused to take a cut in wages, but Novak got the lads in his office one by one and told them that if they refused he'd bring in YOPS workers and they'd get the sack.
'At this point we all felt it was time we got the union in.
'It wasn't just the low wages that made us so angry, although this was T.he breaking point. We'd also had to put up with rubbish health and safety conditions - for years we'd had several bloody great holes in the tloor that were about three feet deep! We'd no canteen facilities either, and only two toilets in the place.
'Everyone joined the union, FlAT. By this time it was mid-November.
'When Novak discovered we'd joined a union he massively Increasing Child Benefit, and yet felt distinctly alarmed 'home responsibility pay. ments' or 'caretakers allowance' on the other hand. Generous maternity leave and payments were one thing, payment for staying home with your kids was quite another.
What was the substance behind this apparently fine line which divided open-armed welcome for the one, and horrified rejection of the other?
You could sum it up as 'strings' and 'traps' STRINGS: the idea of wages or 'payment for' something definitely im. plies obligation. Peare were expreased that payment for childsaw ail the lads individually and told them that he'd put their wages up to full union rates if they left the union - so all but three of the lads dropped out. He then offered all the workers a 5% rise from April - if things picked up...
'We tried to negotiate for the nationally agreed rise, which was 9.7%, but he refused to negotiate with FTAT.
On February 27th we came out on strike. Though the office staff and some of the men crossed the picket line, he couldn't carry on production because all his skilled workers lus!) were on strike. So all the scabs were sacked after two weeks, which shows where scabbing gets you!
'In March, after we all got letters saving we'd 'dismissed ourselves . we orcupied the factory. We managed to get in by follrare. for example. carried tae implication of whoever does the paying setting the standards and conditions, in a situation where women are powerless to bargain or negotiate. And it could so easily be used to restrict the choice for women who preferred to get a job: as as excuse, for example, to close down nurseries.
Whereas the same money given as maternity leave pay is something won and controlled by collective strength, and acknowledges that the woman IS still part of the workforce but on leave.
THE TRAP: It was remarked in the discussion that when we talked about people being paid to stay at home to look after the kids. we couldn't help owing the van driver in. But we wert only in caeupation two dars because Novak got a Crown Court injunction and the union said we had to leave.
So we ve been out on the picket line day in. day out, for the last weeks! saying 'she' - assuming it must be the woman. And of course this is precisely the assumption that is prevalent in society as a whole. One woman related her own experience: when her baby was born. she and her husband had decided to take equal shares in work and child• care and both work part-time. But his earning power was so much greater that they'd been unable to keep it up, and now he works full time, and she has a part time job and does most of the parenting.
So, is paying a woman to stay at home falling inlo the trap of accepting that that's what women do or want to do - and isn't that what we're fighting against?
'Last Wednesday he called us all in for a meeting. He offered us our jobs back, but no union. Of course we refused. Especially as he threatened that he make us pay for all the trouble we'd caused!
'The last two fellas left Shoulds't the nurseries and the jobs and the rights at work [including the rights of men to work shorter hours at the same pay rales| come first, so that women have a REAL choice, before we start assuming that everything women choose to do now is from any real, free choice?
It's a bit of a joke to say women 'choose' at the moment.
The title of the meeting was 'Benefits and a Woman' 's right to Work'. Where Zöe tended to place the emphasis on giving women a real choice to stay home, the rest of us agreed that the drift should be the other way, in a situation where the choice to have a job Lalbeit a boring and low paid job, was being denied and women are being dragooned into full-time motherhood in conditions of isolation and poverty - which would be only marginally alleviated by a state benefit doled out for our services in the home.
GERRY BYRNE us after this meeting. so now there s only us giris left. We're still absolutely determined. though. Either we get back in with the union or we'll make sure that Novak never produces another headboard Wo ve had quite a lot of support from other unions. Agecroft Colliery. Chlorides, Schreiber and Gardners workers have all been great. The Manchester and Salford Trades CAN LABOUR LEAD WOMEN AGAINST THE TORIES? Women's Fightback rally at National Labour Women's Conference, Buxton:
Sunday 14th June, 12.45, the Sandring ham Hotel, Broad Walk.
SPEAKERS:
Tony Benn Barbara Switzer (TASS • Elsie Broar (Royal Pride Strike and People's Marcher.) things harder Wit le got the housework and kids to look after as well as the strike.
Bring in a strike means more than just be ingon the picket line in all urt of weather. We havt a lot of correspondence to write, leaflets to produce and meetings to speak al neariy every night o! the week. We dividt all the work equally between Us.
'Speaking at meetings
----- pull-quotes -----
Ruyai Pride Strike KED