Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Being ruthless the Ripper

Socialist Organiser no. 43, 13 June 1981 · scan p. 11 · about 1,735 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

Crowds at the Ripper trial: should socialists support a The government of President Duarte is being buffeted from both left and right demonstrate their capacity to bring things under control. In the meantime, violence itself threatens to impose its own grim solution. anti-government forces which demonstrated that these forces constituted Salvadoran authorities confirmed that the guerillas had received substantial expended considerable material. As a result, their need for military resupply IN THE DAYS when a poster of Che was part of the obligatory wallpaper of any half-way radical student, Regis Debray's book, 'Revolution in the Revolution' • was part of the obligatory reading.

True, Che had commented with some scorn about Debray's character :

but didn't Debray languish for three years in a Boliy.

ian prison for his beliefs?

Now Regis Debray has been installed as a foreign policy adviser to Mitterand.

Are we to expect Mitterand to lead machine-gun waving guerrillas in a final assault on the Bourse?

No. Mitterand's foreign policy, despite his much.

publicised sympathy for 'liberation movements' differs only tactically from that of US imperialism; he feels their transparent propping up of Central American dictators will only pave the way for a 'communist takeover' On the central question of nuclear arms, he has no differences - even to the extent of publicly backing the siting of new US missiles in West Germany, thus stabbing in the back the opposition inside the Social Democratic Party in West Germany.

Perhaps the best comment on the Mitterand government comes from his finance minister Delors:

"We want France to remain a country where foreign capital can be placed and invested in complete security."

So how does the 'Marxist' Debray end up in such company? It seems a far cry from the Bolivian jungles.

Or perhaps not.

For there is a common thread leading from the romantic guerrillaism of his Bolivian days to his close political support for Allende in Chile and now his participation in a 'Socialist' government, which explicitly disavows anti-capitalist aims: failure or refusal to imagine that the working class can be the subject of history, can define their own aims and programme: They always require some other agency, whether tightly organised armed bands, or 'teft' governments to make the revolution. And after the Bolivian debacle and the fall of Allende even that sort of "revolution' recedes.

Debray, the 'Marxist' without ties to the working class, lost his faith in the masses being able to make their own revolution. Or perhaps to quote another fallen prophet of that decade: 'You had no faith to lose and you know it."

IT'S THE POOR WHAT GET THE BLAME Social Services Secretary Patrick Jenkin is well pleased with his Social Security snoops. 'In view of the success of the technique to date, we expect to make fuller use of the Specialist Claim Control Teams next year."

GRAŻ He claims they've saved the DHSS £40 million. But a 'Guardian' investigation in the Midlands shows another side to the story. In 13 cases taken up by Birmingham Tribunal Unit - an independent body that helps claimants appeal to tribunals against SS decisions - the DHSS won in only two. 8 were thrown out by the Tribunal; 2 were dropped by the DHSS as soon as they heard the women were being represented; and one has gone to further appeal.

The DHSS lost cases that were aimed at saving £15,000, they lost one claim to recover £1,000 in benefit; and they • had to pay back £3,000 in withheld benefits. In the meantime single mothers were left without any money for up to 16 weeks.

The women who succegs.

ully appealed Claimed thei had been harassed, accused of having sexual relationships with visitors to their houses (in one case with the woman's brotherin-law), and interrogated about lovers who were alleged to be supporting them.

So Patrick Jenkin's figure of £40 million "savings' needs to be taken with a pinch of salt. But even if it were accurate, could any 'saving' justify the humiliation, invasion of privacy, smears and insinuation, not to mention real poverty and anguish forced on the 'suspects'?

Do rich tax dodgers and the real major frauds get found guilty and punis hed before they even hav Sea chance to defend ther selves?

THE POOR GET POORER The low-paid are worse off now than they were 100 years ago. The Low Pay Unit, using Department of Employment figures, calculate that the lowest paid male manual workers earned less last year, relative to average wages, than in 1886 when official figures were first collected.

And their numbers are growing. There were ½ million more low-paid workers in 1980 than in 1979. They estimate that 30% of the full-time adult workforce [2 million men and 2.7 million women earn less than £75 for a 40 hour week, and another 2.75 million part-time workers earn less than £1.90 an hour.

And the rich.

THE FINEST AND FAIREST "It is obvious that judges in this country are shrewd men and I still maintain that we have the fairest system of justice in the world" • said PC Olds after the sentencing of the two Hells Angels who had shot him.

And well he might.

The jury had thrown out the Police's preferred charge of attempted murder for the lesser charges of wounding, attempted robbery and possession of firearms. Jim Jardine, Chairman of the Police Federation, called it a travesty of justice and attacked the jury:

"I cannot see how any jury reached those decislons. I thought it was an open and shut case of attempted murder.

The press echoed those sentiments and orchestrated it to a public outcry.

The "finest fairest system" pulled off a happy ending.

If the police couldn't have their way with the jury, then the "shrewd" judge showed he shared their thirst for retribution.

And to prove the point, he handed out sentences of life and 17 years to two men both in their twenties.

P2: NOW THE STRIKE In Italy, the P2 saga rolls on. Now Italian workers are taking action over the scandal which has already led to the downfall of the government and one officer in the Finance Police Corps shooting himself.

The list of 953 alleged members of the secret Masonic lodge P2, implicated in a web of top-level fraud, espionage and mysterious deaths, included almost all the top people on Italy's leading newspaper 'Il Corriere della Sera' : its editor, Franco di Bella; its publisher, Angelo Rizzoli; the Rizzol newspaper chain's Managing Director, Tassan Din; jailed banker, Roberto Calvi, who owns 40% of the paper; plus leading columnists and contributors.

Now journalists and printers at Corriere della Sera' are on indefinite strike calling for the suspension of all alleged P2 members on the staff. They have been joined by other papers in the Rizzoli chain, who are pushing the same demands.

ALTHOUGH I agree with

most things that Jo Thwaites writes about the 'Ripper Trial' (SO 42), it is unfortunate that she limits herself to two main points -the differentiation made between 'respectable' women and prostitutes, and the incompetence of the police in tracking Sutclifte.

Although these are issues raised by the bourgeois press in one form or another, and there is an obvious need to write a socialist analysis of them, it is a pity that Jo Thwaites overlooked other issues thrown up by the case.

Most of the time in court was spent debating' whether Sutcliffe was guilty of murder or whether 'diminished responsibility' was a mitigating circumstance.

In this context it does not help when Jo Thwaites uses the loose, meaningless term 'mad' , although she is correct in saying that there is a direct line between what is seen as 'normal' sexist behaviour and Sutcliffe's murders.

(Which is not to say that every sexist would carry out such acts)

However, Sutcliffe has been given a life sentence, and the judge wishes him to stay in jail until he dies.

Meanwhile many people (Labour Party supporters among them) have been saying that Sutcliffe should be shot, hung, hung drawn and quartered, or axecuted whatever other way you care to think of.

A FEW issues ago you covered events in El Salvador, and in SO 40 you reported on International Gay Association work in Latin America. The US Embassy in London has responded in the terms of a letter dated 27 May.

It demonstrates supine support for the Duarte regime. The US is clearly buttressing the regime for its own capitalist profit.

The arguments used to justify military aid to El Salvador are similar to the UK Government's arguments for their continued military presence in the north of Ireland.

IAN DUNN, Edinburgh.

IN SOCIALIST Organiser 41 you pointed out that racist attacks had been carried out by skinheads.

By pointing out when. ever skins happen to be racist you can create a prejudice against skinheads. In the same way the capitalist papers build up racism by pointing out whenever criminal happens to be black. harsh sentence?

Socialists, I hope, will agree in rejecting these barbaric penalties. But what many fail to realise is that a life (until death) sentence can be even worse. For Sutcliffe life in prison will be specially hellish because he will probably spend most of his time in isolation, on account of fear of attack by other prisoners.

I would argue that such people as Sutcliffe should receive help ('treatment' or 'assistance' sound almost sick words). I do not mean became urgent. electrical treatment or drugs, but rather therapy through talking out his problems. This may sound over-liberal, but in my limited view it is the only real way of helping such people. And if the relevant helpers and community officials were satisfied that people like Sutcliffe had overcome their problems, then they should be released This should apply under a socialist or a capitalist system, although only a socialist system would be Writeback Write back to Socialist Organiser, c/o 214 Sickert Court, London N1 2SY. likely to take this attitude. Socialists who greet the life sentence for Sutcliffe are only supporting a long drawn out or tortuous version of the death. sentence.

In many revolutions prison gates have beer. broken down and all the prisoners released. Let us not forget that sexua: prisoners, even murderers. are also victims of the way in which our society operates.

A London SO

----- pull-quotes -----

faith Ose

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 43

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →