Don't separate unemployed
Socialist Organiser1981 1981-06-27Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
SOCIALIST Organiser has recently argued that unemployed workers should join existing unions and at the same time a special union for unemployed workers should be established. It is in fact incorrect to raise the call for a special union of unemployed workers at this point in time for three reasons.
The vital necessity today is to stress the unity of unemployed and employed workers. It is the latter who have the muscle and power to help their wageless brothers and sisters.
We must emphasise that the unemployed are workers and should have full rights in the existing labour movement organisations.
We do not argue for separate organisations for blacks or women but for specific facilities and treatment within the existing workers' organisations. We should do the same with the unemployed, otherwise we institutionalise and give greater strength to the argument that they are different from employed workers.
Secondly, this demand lets the leaders of existing unions off the hook. All too often they see unemployed members as a burden and/or as a militant danger. They would be only too pleased to be free from their responsibilities and see the TUC establishing a token unemployed workers' union.
The way to push these leaders into action and mobilise the employed to fight unemployment is to have a strong presence from aware unemployed workers inside the TGWU, AUEW, GMWU, ASTMS, etc. is a dual one, but the additional call for a separate organisation removes the stress and emphasis from the central objective of getting the unemployed into the existing unions and provides a way out for those who oppose such moves.
Thirdly, a separate unemployed workers' union is likely to be extremely weak. To a strong degree they are dependent on the aid of the employed. In practice a separate organisation can provide a means of isolating and disenfranchising unemployed brothers and sisters, as energy and imagination is diverted into organising separately rather than recruiting to existing organisations.
The Ansells workers, tor example, have maintained their TGWU branch with access to all labour movement bodies. They should put their energy into recruiting to the TGWU and forge links first of all with other TGWU unemployed workers such as the Liverpool unemployed branches. Then as TGWU members they should attempt to forge links with unemployed members of other unions.
How this process develops, we cannot say. At some time in the future the demand for a separate organisation may be valid.
Now we need to put all our energies into getting the unemployed into the organisations which have the power and capacity to lead the fight against unemployment and the system which breeds it.
SEAN SOUTH, Manchester.