Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[I READ with interest Gerry Byrne's article, The…]

Socialist Organiser no. 44, 27 June 1981 · scan p. 2 · about 770 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

I READ with interest Gerry Byrne's article, The strings and the trap, which appeared in SO 43. While I would agree with Gerry when she points out that the vast majority of women have no choice about whether or not they stay at home, I feel that by concentrating on this aspect she has lost sight of what the original article in Spare Rib was actually about.

I am a single parent and as such do not fall into the category: "eing either a housewifu fur paid domestic slave) e: if being unemployed. I ar not required to register for work and don't get dole. Instead, as a single parent, I am eligible for a supplementary benefits allowance.

I am therefore in the 'privileged' position of being treated as an independent person - this being changed only if I decide to live with a man, in which case I would, like a married woman, become his dependent.

Zoe's article addressed itself to ways in which women with children who are living with or married to men can still be treated as independent people. Surely feminists we would support treating women as independent people.

We should be against the cohabitation rule and support the consequential extension of such payments (perhaps called caretaker payments) to any women or men who cannot work because they have to look after children.

I feel that it is about time we addressed ourselves to the reality of most women's lives and stopped trying to find theoretical justifications for nor fighting to give these women the indepen¿ence they need to enable them to take part in the triggle so desermine their IF r own future. Gerry's approach of fighting for more jobs is one side of the fight - but on its own it is not going to have much immediate effect on the millions of women who do not even have the 'luxury' of the same benefits as the unemployed.

I would be interested to know whether Gerry regards housewives as being workers within the capitalist system, or does she see them as being unemployed (housework thus being • separate from the capitalist mode of producttion). The adoption of either stance would appear to require some form of payment.

Personally I feel that neither argument holds up under Marxist analysis, and that domestic labour, whether it is compared with productive or non-productive labour in the market, cannot be treated as work in the same sense. To regard people who look after children as being unemployed lor as constituting a special reserve army of labour) is equally wrong. Such an approach fails to say what domestic labour actually is, and in the main such arguments are functionalist whereby they view capitalism as • I1 some form o body which labour only war, etc.

For me d (which exist italism and ically remi ending of mode of constitutes t stay of Patri It provic for women by men in enables ca produce within the example of sexual divis work. Out basis arises if conspiratorial uses women's • in times of lomestic labour ed before capcould theoretain after the the capitalist production) the major mainarchy. les the basis i's exploitation the home and pitalism to rehis oppression workplace, an this being the sion of labour at of this material i the ideology of not just bourgeois ines) regard women as property, rapes and battering being just examples of the consequences.

Zoe's approach of paying people a caretaker allowance seems to me to be one way of attacking the material basis of women's oppression. It gives women with children (the vast majority of housewives) independence, without it necessarily having to fall into the trap of reinforcing a woman's role in the home. Like demands for maternity paternity benefit, it need not and indeed should not be a payment just for women.

With regard to Gerry's argument about payments to women being used as justifications for the closure of nurseries, I would point out that this need not be the result or even the logical reaction of the state. Witness the fact that day nursenes, practically the only full-time state nursery provision available, accessible mainly to single parents who would otherwise be on social security.

The consequences of the introduction of such payments would be in the hands of the labour movement, which would now have the support of all those women who could previously not have been able to afford to engage themselves in political activity. These momen would be no more content to accept such paymeri as attematives 50 50ri 1 thai's sta: ibe!

tempored ITi E:TI 10=S52

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 44

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →