[The problem of leade.ship can be traced back…]
Socialist Organiser1981 1981-06-27Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
The problem of leade.ship can be traced back to one root cause - the complete failure of the Council of Civil Service Unions (COCSU) to achieve even a minimal political understanding of their Tory opponents.
This was apparent right from the outset, when the scrapping of the Pay Research Unit was presentstand the nature of the Tory government was the fundamental failing from which sprang a series of tactical mistakes both before and after the campaign began on March 9th.
The decision by the leadership to stick by the PRU and ignore the fact that it was a corpse was one such blunder. They were able to hold onto this position in the CPSA only by the narrowreplace trust interest in the Labour by account- Party among trade unionRachel Lever, a member of the Benn Campaign committee, replies to the New Statesman's articles calling for an abstention in the Labour Deputy Leader contest
Scan page 11
THE WEEK Tony Benn went into hospital, the editorial staff of the New ¡Statesman were engaged on putting together five pages of pompous, incon(sequential attacks on him.
Some members of the ¡Editorial Board did sugglest that the journal should come out and support (Denis Healey. They might as well have done so, for in the editorial it is sugglested that members of the ¡PLP should abstain in the (Electoral College which would have the effect of weighting the votes ¡for Healey.
The only pertinent and understanding comments fin the whole issue of the New Statesman are made parody of Lewis Carroll's 'The Hunting of the Snark' No prizes for guessing who today's Snark (or Zark, "a zealous creature said to guard the Ark of the Conference") is:
•They hunted till darkiness came on but they found/ Not a button, or feather or mark;/ And they knew from the rumble that grew underground,/ They would have to kill more than 'the Zark".
The august editors of (parliamentary shoulderrubbing, are quite incapable of hearing "the rumble that grew underground' • They are capable, it seems, of writing "personalities apart, there is nothing to prevent a committed left-winger from treating by John Mcliroy BEHIND THE scenes of Denis Healey with respect, substantial Parliamentary periormer, and a vote-winner on the hustings" (Just like Shirley Williams?)
Bruce Page and Peter Kellner devote a breathlessly admiring page to these "committed left-wingers" and their attempts to field a "Stop Benn" candidate once they had failed to forestall him in the Tribune group.
Finally, they describe the braggart Silkin as "coyly backing into the ring"
Under the cover of the "intensely felt" reaction against Benn of all these "committed left-wingers" Page and Kellner go on to dissect Benn's record.
They excuse their lack of interest in the record of the respected Healey or the coy Silkin on the grounds that they "excite no interest at all": which, if the truth be told, actually means that whereas Benn is by no means above criticism, Silkin and Healey are both so abysmal as to be beneath criticism.
In much the same vein, many women I have spoken to say they have doubts about Benn because he came off so badly in the interview Spare Rib did with him; but can anyone for a second imagine Spare Rib even interviewing Healey?
The thought of it is so absurd that it says more than all the policy statements can about the gulf that exists between Benn on the one hand and any of the likely candidates that may stand against him.
But whereas the attitude of these women is unconsciously very flattering to Benn, the New Statesman is not so naive.
Far from subjecting Benn's record, writings and speeches to scrutiny because they think he is worth it, they are doing so to undermine his campaign and muffle 'the rumble that grew underground"
That much is clear both in their recommendation to abstain, their glorification of the Silkin camp, Bob Cryer MP resigned from the last Labour government over its lack of support for the KME cooperative. One of the New Statesman's arguments against Benn is his record on KME. Cryer told us:
"It was a nit-picking article which failed to recognise that the money was given to KME against the wishes of the civil servants, against the wishes of other Labour ministers and against a minute issued by the permanent secretary of the department opposing the expenditure.
"It's difficult to understand why the New Statesman should have joined the pro-Healey bandwagon, which is the effect of their article.
"And Bruce Page's promising attitude of two years ago is now declining into plaintive whining against the democratic changes that are taking place in the Labour Party and which are symbolised by the arguments in the Deputy Leadership campaign." and their contradictory attacks on the Benn campaign for over-reliance on "the classic devices of the smoke-filled room" on the one hand, and, on the other, for going too fast in "encouraging a new kind of democracy to ferment"
Nor is the New Statesman the first to discover that the Namibian Rossing mine contract delivered under Benn as Energy Minister is nothing to boast about, or that Benn's expansive optimism and his talk of workers' self-reliance sit uneasily with his years as a minister under Wilson and Callaghan.
Many of those campaigning for Benn (including a wide political cross-section of the RFMC Deputy Leadership Campaign) are well aware of these things. That's why they say the campaign isn't about personalities so much as about policies. Or, to take the point further, it is about changing the whole system and relationships between personalities and policies.
It we can and virtue ability, and personal integrity by freedom of information and rank and file control, that will be far more significant than finding an unstained candidate.
Meanwhile Tony Benn, warts and all, is the standard-bearer of that accountability. If he fails in this year's election, many good things happening in the Labour Party (not least a 25% increase individual membership, a rapid growth of new women's sections, and a mushrooming of your wages to be cut in order that the capitalists' ists) will be set back.
And if he wins, those developments will be accelerated and the lett strengthened, so that it may go on to formulate better policies and find better candidates than Benn himself.
"The New Statesman is now showing its true colours. Far from being a committed, radical, socialist newspaper, it has been exposed 8s supporting the rightwing and fake left tendencies which represent the worst face of the PLP.
«Their two-faced att¡tude to politics will be understood by the socialist readership of the paper. And they might start reading a paper which puts a clearly left-wing perspective."
Most importantly, we must take up the struggle
----- pull-quotes -----
the NS, immersed in the clubby atmosphere of
MAY&I LIVERPOOL-LONFON rg
Reg Racesn* old us