The backroom plans
Socialist Organiser1981 1981-06-27Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
Labour's big campaigns for democracy, policies for the next Labour government are being prepared — quietly and none too democratically.
Left-wing commitments are being watered down. And vague references in TUC and Labour Party resolutions to planned wages in a future planned economy are being used to try to negate clear TUC and Labour Party policy opposing wage controls in the present unplanned capitalist economy.
The TUC-Labour liaison committee is discussing a document. Inflation: towards «1 Socialist Approach, which claims that wages help cause inflation and some understanding on wage restraint must be reached with the TUC.
Price control. this document says, should limit profit margins. but allow price rises to cover costs. The overall aim would be to freeze the share of wages, taxes and profits in the economy. Wages might be index-linked.
In return for wage controls, the unions would be off agreeme tation boards.
red planning ts and represenon company This wage-control policy is not yet agreed. So far the liaison committee has endorsed eight points:
• Price controls, • Devaluation, • Selective import controls, • Increased public spending, • More State borrowint; planning agreements, an expanded National Enterprise Board, and a National Investment Bank (note: no mention of nationalisation), • A 'National Economic Assessment' • More job training.
So what is taking shape Is a gutted version of the already limited Alternative Economic Strategy. It bears a close resemblance to the failed strategy of the last Labour government, and only the most deluded supporter of the Alternative Economic Strategy could argue that these proposals, clearly intended to operate the existing system, are in any way transitional towards socialism.
Support for incomes policy has come from the APEX and AUEW conferences, which rejected free collective bargaining in favour of "a policy of sensible cooperation with a future Labour government' Sid Weighell (NUR) has called collective bargaining, "the Phugs And Clive Jeig kins has stated that the ASTMS executive will be reviewing the union's support for free collective bargaining.
But the welsh and Scots TUCs have rejected incomes policy, and so has TASS.
should firmly against the whole framework of Inflation: Towards Socialist Approach, or even the adoption of vague formulas by the Liaison Committee.
Of course, inflation is a problem for workers, but it is a different problem for workers than for capitalists. For an employer the problem is rising wages threatening profits, for a worker the problem is rising prices eating into real wages.
A government which attempts to operate the existing system cannot act in workers' interests. Profit is the engine of the system. Profit is what makes everything else work. Giving the falling rate of profit, such a government must try to boost profits at the expense of wages.
This is the logic of the incomes policy argument. During periods of incomes policy, between 1948 and 1976, real wages fell by 2%. During periods without, they rose by more than 45% (family with two children).
The pattern was the same under the last Labour government. It will be the same under the next, if we accept the incomes policy argument.
No socialist would idealise free collective bargaining. It can reinforce sectionalism and disunity in the working class. However, in an unplanned capitalist society it is our most effective means of defence.
It will be desirable in a planned economy, as a corrective to any bureaucratic trends; and it is essential so long as the economy remains unplanned.
But in Inflation:. a Socialist Approach, planning is an empty formula designed to veil the real meaning: "Allow coffers may be filled and we may entice and entreat them to invest."
But what about the proposals on industrial democracy and planning agreements? They are cosmetics - aimed to weaken collective bargaining and strengthen workers' identification with 'their company'. How much use have the worker-directors in British Steel been?
Voluntary planning agreements, relying on persuasion, will be a farce, like the Chrysler planning agreement under the last Labour government. You cannot persuade large-scale capital to act against its fundamental interests. Penalties like nationalisation of recalcitrant companies are not considered. Moreover, they would ignite a major investment strike.
It is impossible to plan investment, production, and prices, if the major companies remain in private hands. Yet the liaison committee retreats even on the conference decision to nationalise 25 major companies. within the unions and the Labour Party for a clear commitment to no wage restraint. Otherwise we shall be in for a re-run of 1979, with the workers once more clashing with a bosses' government.
The Left must take up these arguments and must mobilise against any attempt by the liaison committee to foist. slightly refurbished 1974-9 programme on us. We must fight for a programme which starts from the existence of an unbridgeable conflict between employers and workers and sides with Such a programme would not propose workers on the board and planning agreements. It would propose the immediate introduction of the 35 hour week, the nationalisation under workers' control of bankrupt enterprises,, and government support for workers in disputes with employers. It would raise the share of wages in the economy while extending nationalisation and public works.