Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The truth about the manifesto

Socialist Organiser no. 44, 27 June 1981 · scan p. 12 · about 543 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

CHIEF WHIP Michael Cocks' arguments against Benn on the question of the Manifesto are irrelevant point-scoring — with the points being divided pretty evenly between Benn and Cocks.

Benn's statement that the introduction of a wealth tax was ruled out is substantially true. There was a mention of it in the Manifesto, this left out any reterence to either the Joint Statement of December 1977 or to the TUC-Labour Party liaison committee. Without these references the commitment was a meaningless mockery of Party policy.

Benn was right to claim that there was no commitment to "substantial cuts in arms expenditure" The Manifesto spoke only of a reduction in the proportion of expenditure used for arms. And even this was not firm, being phrased as: "continue with our plans to reduce etc."

This is the wretched language of political escapologists. It is what all the arguments on the Manifesto are about: whether the Party will commit itself to doing something, or merely "aim towards', 'plan to conditions for rindso the ensure' the Moreover, since the election it has been revealed that the Callaghan cabinet in-crew were actually planning just the opposite. If we had a Labour government now, it would be buying Trident and accepting Cruise missiles.

On 'reflation of public sector spending', Benn seems to have been wrong, strictly speaking. But the Institute . for Workers' Control, in a briefing to delegates at last year's conference, made clear what the inclusion of 'reflation' in the Manifesto actually meant.

The Labour Government had publicly indicated its reenarive strategy (reflation, import controls, a much stronger NEB, etc); and we therefore knew that the words in the Manifesto meant completely different things to Ministers"

Cocks, of course, sideSilkin Healey steps the very thing that Benn's speech was about. It was about the method of drawing up the Manifesto.

Benn said: There were no elected members of the Parliamentary Labour Party apart from the Leader and Deputy Leader on the committee drawing up the Manifesto. No backbencher even saw the draft before it went to the committee. The same went for the unions.

Also, the document is always drawn up so late that the Party can only campaign on it in the three weeks prior to an election.

can veto items: el ders the example of the exclusion from the Manifesto of the clear policy of abolishing the House of Lords, passed by six and a half million to a derisory 91,000.

Benn is calling for the right of the NEC "after consultation with the Leader of the Party and the Parliamentary Committee of the PLP' to decide on what goes in the Manifesto. The 'joint responsibility' of the Parliamentary Committee (Shadow Cabinet) and the NEC works against accountability and means in practice Cabinet or Shadow-Cabinet rule.

Of course, Benn's proposal — and the similar but clearer one drawn up by the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy for the coming Conference - still would not stop some familiar larks of the Leader like threatening to resign just before the election if he doesn't get his way.

But it goes a long way to asserting the principle that Conference is king, and between conferences, the body elected by Conference, the NEC, has responsibility for Party policy.

Benn

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 44

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →