When Wrp Called Gaddafi a Fascist
Socialist Organiser1981 1981-06-27Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
Gold? Yellow, glittering precious gold? Thus much of this will make black, white; foul, fair Wrong, right; base, noble; old, young; coward, val Will lug your priests and servants from your sides; Pluck stout men's pillow from below their heads: Will knit and break religions; bless th'accurst; Make the hoar leprosy adored; place thieves, And give them title, knee and approbation, (Shakespeare, Timon of Athens - much quoted by the meetings that Benn or ... Why this This yellow slave With senators on the bench...
RECENTLY Col Gaddafi, Libya's dictator, French reported by the newspaper Le Monde as saying that Nazism only had such a bad reputation today because Germany lost World War 2.
In Le Monde's quotation, he seemed to be saying that Nazism did not deserve this reputation. In response to comments in the left press, Gaddafi's British fan-magazine Newsline (which misrepresents itself to the British labour movement as working-class newspaper) fulminated that Gaddafi meant nothing of the sort. Le Monde's story and the comments were all part of a CIA (etc.) campaign against Gaddafi, in preparation for the invasion of Libya.
But the publishers of Newsline didn't always think that it was a CIAinspired slander to link Gaddati with fascism.
Their previous daily paper, Workers' Press, said Gaddafi was himself a fascist, indeed a Nazi |'national socialist'].
In an article by Ian Yeats on September 9th, 1971, entitled Gaddati's 'National Socialism' (quotes in original) Workers' Press responded to a speech by Gaddafi.
"The two hour long address must be one of the most complete statements of the canons of fascism since Mussolini or Hitler.
"All the ingredients are there. The appeal to the past, the emphasis on the historic and divine destinyof the Arab race, the hatred of capitalism and equally of ommunism, and the fertile oil of mass poverty anc deprivation..
'Class differences are glossed over by the deliberate veneration of labour just, righteous and productive forces' •The national socialist foundation of Gaddafi's ideas is pointed in his bitter hatred and vigorous conforces' must be tu: red on workers and peasan ts in the fight to survive...
'"The infantry the counter-revolution is massing. Whether it will succeed depends on the emergence and strength of Trotskyist revolutionary leadership"
Workers Press's classification of Gaddafi as a fascist or Nazi is too schematic, in my opinion, defining him by his political ideas alone. Fascism is a product of the class struggle in more or less developed capitalist societies, a mass movement to beat down the working class and labour movement, mobilised on a mish-mash of ideas such as Yeats reports.
Gaddafi is the populist -if eccentric - dictator of an extremely backward Muslim society. Himself rooted in nomad Bedouin tribalism, he is seemingly motivated by naive goodwill for his own people, running a society buoyed up with enormous oil wealth.
To call Gaddafi a fascist is anachronistic and a typical example of the arid political formalism of the Healyites when they were a political movement. (Typical also is the notion that there was a crippling slump in 1971).
The quotations; however, do seem to establish that Gaddafi's sympathetic musings about Nazi Germany don't begin three months ago.
So what changed in Libya?
Libya's fusion with Egypt was long ago aborted. The regime uses a more radical brand of populist rhetoric now. Its techniques of control i include mobilisation of the Libyan people.
But the army dictatorship continues, the Islamic ideas are still dominant, and so are the ideas that Yeats itemises, quite usefully though one-sidedly, above.
The change is in the WRP leadership, who embrace now what they once defined as full-blown faseism.
And not only the comparatively benign Libyan regime gets their support. Newsline publicly justifies the shooting of members of the Iragi Communist Party, in these terms:
"It is true that 21 Communist. Party members were executed early last year for illegally forming cells in the artned forces The purpose of these cells was to fight against government.
« There are no prizes for the answer to what would happen to Ba'athists who set up cells in the soviet army. They would bi uthlessly purged " (2.2.79 'The fact is that [21] CP members were executed according to military codes which the Iraqi CP discussed, approved and agreed to implement. To this day the Iragi CP has not called for the repeal of the military laws which ban the formation of secret cells in the Army.
'It has never contradicted the fact that the arrested officers were guilty of the charges brought against them. This is a case of Moscow trying to set up the cells in the Iraqi armed forces for the purpose of undermining the regime. It must accept the consequences..." (8.3.79).
In fact the Iraqi regime, the rule of a section of the Ba'ath Socialist Party, with a nationalist programme of economic development, through a military dictatorship, is perhaps the most vicious in the Middle East.
When it was a political organisation, the WRP (then SLL) said this about the Ba'athist regime in Iraq: Everything that Marxism Today the CP magazine] says about the Iraqi Ba'athist regime is true. It is stained with the blood of thousands of murdered workers and communists... The Ba'athists killed two delegates to the Iraqi CP congress...
And it denounced the Russian CP for inviting two ''fascist thugs" i.e., Ba'athist officials - to its congress. (18.5.71).
There is good reason to call the Iraqi Ba'athists fascists for what their regime does. So what's changed in Iraq?
A different taction of the Ba'ath party now rules through the army. By all accounts other than those of its propagandists, the present regime is narrower and more terroristic than the Ba'ath regime of 1971 which the Workers' Press denounced At an earlier stage in the degeneration of this tendency, it supported (for about a year, in 1967) the Mao faction of the Chinese bureaucracy during the great devastation known as the 'Cultural Revolution'. Michael Banda, now WRP general secretary and then editor of their paper Newsletter, memorably wrote in self-justification that if necessary his organisation would 'march' even under the portrait of Stalin (which the Maoists carried in abundance).
Now it seems that Mr Banda and hie Ayatollah Mr kealy, heve reconciled themselves to marching che ranks of those they used to call tascists.