Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Militant preaches peace with the police

Socialist Organiser no. 48, 13 August 1981 · scan p. 6 · Jo Thwaites · about 1,249 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Transcribed from the scan of page 6, 19 Nov 2026, replacing the machine reading: the headline was garbled ('eace'), the article ran on into page 7 (Blind women victims of sexual abuse, Partial victory on equal pay and other items) and a 'Jon Lansman' by-line belonged to the Benn piece below. Second deck 'Biggest ever left-wing opposition at LPYS Summer Camp' and by-line 'by Jo Thwaites' as printed. The Class Fighter advert set in the last column is left out.

Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.

Scan page 6

Biggest ever left-wing opposition at LPYS Summer Camp

THE PEACEFUL roads of the Forest of Dean resounded with calls for a peaceful road to socialism from the much feared Militant tendency in the LPYS last week.

LPYS Summer Camp was bigger and better than ever before (as they say every year). But so was the opposition. 600 people attended, among whom were a 50 strong contingent of Class Fighter and Socialist Organiser supporters. Last year there were only 12 Barricade supporters and there was no one from Red Youth (these two youth papers are the ones which came together to form Class Fighter).

Riots

The LPYS is at the moment controlled by the Militant grouping and the Summer Camp is run as a Militant event.

But this year Class Fighter emerged as a major opposition in the YS. We organised four large and successful meetings during the week.

Amazingly, for a youth organisation like the YS, there was no meeting officially organised on the riots, so Class Fighter held one, attended by over 100.

A raging debate all week centred round the role of the police and the army, particularly relevant because of the riots. The Militant have the unique position that the forces of the state – the army and the police – are 'workers in uniform' and all they're doing is just another job.

They want the British police and army to be unionised and become part of the TUC.

We pointed out that in the light of the riots that would mean supporting the police calls for better equipment to beat us over the head with, more pay for doing so and admitting proven scabs (in the dustmen and firemen's strikes) to the organisations that are supposed to represent the interests of the working class.

Certainly socialists should support democratic rights for soldiers and police – the right to free speech, the right to organise politically, the right to elect their officers and the right to form unions.

We oppose the laws that forbid the police to unionise.

Under some conditions these democratic rights can destabilise the state. But they do not turn cops into workers, or make police unions (like in France, for example) genuine workers' unions.

Militant dreams about a future democratic, unionised benevolent police force. But where does it stand now, when the real present-day cops are maiming and murdering working class youth on the streets? On which side?

This argument was closely linked to the argument about how we would achieve socialism. At the beginning of the week, Tony Saunois, the Militant NEC member declared there was a "peaceful road" to socialism. The implication of this was that we were going to get socialism through Parliament.

When this was pointed out by Class Fighter supporters in the debate, Saunois bellowed out from the platform "These people are out of touch with the working class."

But we are very aware of the illusions that many workers have in change through Parliament. We think for this reason it is particularly dangerous to put the emphasis on Parliament instead of the independent activity of the working class.

Peter Taaffe, the editor of Militant put the same emphasis on the peaceful road when he debated with David Ennals from Labour Solidarity.

Class Fighter was not allowed to speak in the debate, but Taaffe obviously thought our arguments were pretty convincing as he challenged us to a debate afterwards – but when they turned the disco on, he mysteriously disappeared!

Yet in the seminar on Chile, when we discussed Popular Unity and the fall of Allende, everyone agreed that the mistake in Chile had been Allende's refusal to arm the working class and his belief that socialism could be won through Parliament.

Why do Militant insist it would be different in Britain?

Class Fighter, following the absence of debate on gay liberation at national YS conference, had asked that the YS National Committee have a seminar on the subject at the Summer Camp.

We collected 250 signatures, 55 of them delegates to conference, asking for this, yet there was no official seminar organised.

Gay rights

So Class Fighter organised its own, attended by over 70 people. For the first time ever a serious discussion on gays at work, how to win gays to the labour movement and on sexuality was held in YS.

Class Fighter supporters urged YS's to affiliate to the Labour Gay Rights Campaign and get the Labour Party NEC discussion document on the Rights of Gay Men and Women brought up and even Jim Newlands, a Militant ex-member of the LPYS NC called for YS's to arrange speakers on gay rights. A major step forward for the YS!

The Class Fighter meeting on Ireland reflected the discussion that had been going on all week. Again the Militant had refused to let Class Fighter comrades speak at their Irish meeting – we got one speaker and Kevin Ramage then had the cheek to say there had been a very good 'discussion'.

Many Militant comrades spoke at our meeting. We argued that socialists in Britain had a duty to support those forces – the republicans fighting British imperialism in the six counties and to fight for British troops out of Ireland.

Women

On women, there had been planned a debate between the Militant and a speaker from NOLS (National Organisation of Labour Students). The NOLS speaker didn't turn up, so Class Fighter offered to debate instead. Eventually they agreed to let us have a long contribution from the floor and no summing up.

It was clear that the work of Women's Fightback had a major impact on the Militant. Much of their contribution was spent attacking the idea of positive discrimination in favour of women.

We argued that in order to attempt to redress the inequalities between men and women in the labour movement it is important to get a recognition of the fact that women are oppressed and that the labour movement has to do something about it – that's what positive discrimination sets out to do.

All Militant could come up with was the same programme as they have for everything else – nationalise the top 200 monopolies, 35 hour week and socialism . . . please!

By the end of the week, Class Fighter had established itself as the only serious opposition in the YS. At the meeting on 'What is the National Left Wing Youth Movement' (which the Militant tried unsuccessfully to wreck), we consolidated the gains we'd made throughout the week, which included a whole YS branch coming up to us asking how to join the NLWYM and many other groups of youth and individuals.

We stated that we are serious about not just remaining in opposition in the YS but we are aiming to take the YS away from the monolithic control of the Militant and turn the YS into a real revolutionary youth movement which relates to and reflects the political needs and concerns of youth.

The NLWYM is holding a conference in London at the end of October to build on the strength of the first conference we held in June and develop our work over the next year.

Details in the next Class Fighter.

It was clear that the Militant got a fright this Summer Camp and were impressed by the youth and vitality of the Class Fighter supporters. We aim to keep them frightened and win working class youth to the LPYS.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 48

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →