The left press on the miners' strike
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-04-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Unsigned. Transcribed from the scan of page 4, 19 Nov 2026, replacing the machine reading (title cut short; text from the photo's banners and page 5 mixed in). Two passages are badly faded on the scan and are read from the letters still visible; one word, 'The [illegible] of socialism', cannot be read.
Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.
Scan page 4
Everyone agrees on one thing about the miners' strike: that it is a major political confrontation.
But on that level the response of most of the left press to the dispute has been pretty inadequate.
All the left papers have done useful work in publicising the miners' case and putting the basic arguments for solidarity. But many have done little more than that.
The Morning Star has political answers of a sort. An article by Communist Party chair and Scottish miners' vice-president George Bolton on April 10 put it like this:
"It is in the interest of the British people to have an independent energy policy. Any policy based on the import of coal – since supplies of North Sea oil and gas have peaked – will seriously undermine and weaken Britain's ability to reindustrialise and develop industries as it sees fit, free from outside influences."
This sort of "socialism in one country" – or, "people's industry in one country"! – argument does nothing to strengthen the case for defending jobs.
No industrial economy, least of all Britain's, is or can be "free of outside influences". To attempt to make it so would be to try to turn the clock back 200 years or more.
The [illegible] of socialism is to build on and transform the international integration created by capitalism, not to try to reverse it. Nation-against-nation divisions in the working class can only weaken us, just as area-against-area divisions damage the miners.
Militant presents a more radical answer. "The political implications are clear: there is no road out for workers on the basis of the present system. Capitalism is itself creating all the conditions for class conflict and social upheaval" (editorial, March 23).
But there is a vast gap in Militant's politics between this maximum perspective and the minimum immediate proposals it makes for developing the struggle. The only proposal that seems to have any relation to bridging this gap is Militant's call for a 24 hour general strike. It sometimes seems as if Militant thinks that this 24 hour action backed by the ineluctable processes of History will be sufficient by itself for the social revolution.
Socialist Action has also portrayed the miners' strike as a symptom of great world-historic processes (in a characteristic article by John Ross, April 6). Again, however, the immediate proposals do not quite match up to the sweeping scenarios.
Socialist Action has advocated support committees (and carried a lot of useful reports of local activity), stressed the importance of financial support through collections and levies, and called for the TUC to organise a day of action.
Oddly, Socialist Action leaves its call at the vague term "day of action", rather than specifying a one-day general strike. And none of the weekly left papers other than Socialist Organiser has proposed organising for an all-out general strike (though on the ground, in the coalfields, this call has met a very good response).
From Socialist Worker this is not surprising. In recent years it has swung round from its ultra-optimism of the mid-'70s (when it argued that straight industrial militancy would quickly produce a revolutionary challenge to the Labour government), to a depressed pessimism. This is not a time for bold political perspectives, it says, but for painstaking detail work in the rank and file.
It has stressed organising collections for the miners, and carried interesting coverage of problems in organising picketing. Socialist Worker argues that the NUM area leaderships are dragging their feet and makes the call for elected rank and file strike committees central to what it says about the struggle.
Apart from the call for a general strike, some other political demands raised by Socialist Organiser have been avoided or neglected by the rest of the left press: the slogan 'Police out of the coalfields', for example, and the call for a detailed socialist programme to save jobs (work-sharing without loss of pay; a workers' plan for the energy industry; open the books, nationalise banks and supply companies without compensation).