How not to fight Militant
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-04-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
REVOLUTION Youth (the youth group linked to Socialist Action) came to conference with a whole new approach to Militant. It was very clever, they thought.
The tactic was to water down criticisms of Militant to little more than objections to Militant not campaigning. At the back of Revo's minds was an attempt to launch a junior 'Briefing'-type activists' paper in the LPYS.
It was doomed to backfire. Presenting themselves as YS activists, and very busy ones, they lost an independent political presence. Mort ridiculously, the lead headline on their final day's conference bulletin was "Build YS summer camp".
Being better YS activists than Militant is not enough to free the YS from Militant's political domination. Proposing campaigns about the Police Bill, for instance, will not defeat Mili. tant.
Obviously the YS can be pushed. It has been over questions like women and CND. From rank hostility the YS has moved to affiliating to CND. Quite likely Militant will change their line on Labour Party black sections, too. They will support them when enough pressure is mobilised. But none of these changes have taken matters out of Militant's control.
Revo deliberately limited themselves to operating below the level of political debate necessary to tackle Militant.
Arguing that the YS should take up solidarity campaigns, Revo refused to criticise the movements that they wanted the YS to support. On Ireland, Revo wanted to delete our criticisms of the IRA. When their amendment was defeated, only half of them still voted for our motion, the only one on offer which supported the Republicans and the Labour Committee on Ireland!
Revo were behind a meeting called to discuss getting up local YS bulletins. Obviously these bulletins are a good idea. Ideally they should be rooted in local working case Jouth culture. Tea reen i Reve insist that they are. Class Fighter sapport. ers were producing them seven years ago.
In the NEC election the Rero candidate, Bernie Wilde. did not come out as a Rero support. er. Instead she just criticised Militant for not campaigning for Greenham and for women's rights. She polled nine votes less than Class Fighter candidate Judith Bonner, who stood as a revolutionary Marxist in opposition to Militant's reformist charter of 'nationalise the top 200 monopolies' as the answer to every question.
The experience of this conference, the numbers going to fringe meetings, showed that, yes, we should challenge Militant on their lack of support for campaigns that they don't control, but we must also challenge them politically - take up their ideas of how to transform society and give an overall alternative to them.
As Clive Bradley pointed out at the meeting called to discuss local bulletins, Militant can appear extremely radical. They talk about nationalisations and socialism, and try to make the opposition seem to talk only about women and Ireland.
The last thing the left opposition in the YS needs is a public face which does not have an abster to the critical question: bor do me transform society?