Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Ian MacGregor is

Socialist Organiser no. 176, 26 April 1984 · scan p. 6 · about 1,021 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

went back to work now, the you, he's only doing demoralisation would be such job. The people who Ian MacGregor is, I'm afraid, a bully. Like all bullies he panics when he senses defeat. That is the simple explanation behind his bad-tempered attacks last weekend on Arthur Scargill.

According to MacGregor, Scargill spent the last six weeks avoiding a ballot and juggling the rules of the NUM. McGregor is somewhat mistaken.

Arthur Scargill has not once deviated from the rules of the NUM. Under Rule 41 and with the complete support of his executive, and as recently as last week at the national delegate conference, he has sanctioned area strikes against closures, supporting the clear policy of successive NUM conferences.

According to the NUM rules there is no need at all for a national ballot. Certainly given the changes wrought by six years of area productivity schemes, it needs the most patient consideration according to the rules of the NUM, and according to the law of the land. For it was in 1977 when the NUM executive decided to ignore the result of a national ballot to a deafening silence from the NCB and the government that Mr Justice Watkins turned down flat a suit brought by the left wing areas against Lord Gormley "the result of a ballot nationally conducted is not binding on the national executive committee in using its power between conferences" said the noble judge.

Indeed, it has not great force or significance"

I am sure lan MacGregor will have no further hesitation in deferring to Her Majesty's Judges on these matters.

But Arthur is not yet off the hook. He has, according to MacGregor, also been indulging in politics and utilising the miners for his own personal ends.

This dispute has, of course, nothing whatsoever to do with politics.

That's why the Financial Times states: 'The phony war is over. The real struggle, the most profound and serious labour challenge to have faced the Thatcher government has begun."

That's why The Times claims: "Mrs Margaret Thatcher is willing to spend any amount of time to ensure the government is not defeated by the miners."

That's why the whole of the Cabinet has spent the last six weeks denouncing Arthur Scargill.

Take a collection workplace.

Send cheques and postal anders to Sarcar y Func St BES: 10SE: me Stret T2357O number 30000009, bank sorting code 08-90-75.

It's strange, isn't it that Scargill should be accused by the National Coal Board of using his members for his own personal ends. They never, never said that about Lord Gormley.

Perish the thought: In his capacity as a director of the British Investment Trust, with a holding in De Beers Consolidated Goldfields, and the Anglo-American Corporation, Lord Gormley, I can say without fear of contradiction, always acted without the slightest desire for personal gain, in the interests only of members and their brothers toiling in South African mines.

When Lord Gormley was a director of the British Investment Trust and of Vancouver Wharves Ltd and leading the miners at the same time, nobody accused him of being involved in a conflict of interest. Nor did they suggest that his behaviour in the NUM just might be coloured the teeny-weeniest bit by the share-holding capitalist system he carried in his back pocket.

Intimidating

That rascal Scargill is a different kettle of fish altogether. And MacGregor hasn't had his full say yet. Scargill, he assures us, has actually been intimidating his members. MacGregor should know about intimithreatening 20,000 miners with the loss of their livelihood. He's the one who showed the level of petty intimidation to which the bosses can sink, by having to be persuaded from sacking the miners who demonstrated against him at Ellerington Colliery before the dispute began. He has threatend the loss of a further 25,000 jobs if the strike goes on and he's been wildly enthusiastic about police physically intimidating miners, vicars and Mr Je Average out for a drive with the wife and kids.

I'm afraid, as I write this on the top of a Clapham Omnibus, that it is with the greatest reluctance, of course, Ian MacGregor and not Arthur Scargill that I find guilty of intimidation.

Liar

MacGregor's final charge is, however, a truly devastating one.

Arthur Scargill, he claims, (the man is nothing if not blunt). is a liar. Well, from what you're read up till now. MacGregor is not exactly George Washington reincarnated. And it 15 Arthur Scargill who kept telling us. despite denial after denial from the NCB. that there was a tit is: and that there would be wholesale closures.

I: strikes me. as your average person r the pub. ice: zie MarGrego: is "33:

=- : = 0000 :333=santies. inat ine suatior may look a little bit different once those 20,000 jobs have go e, and the union is that muc 1 weaker.

It strices me that if the miners took his advice and JOHN HARRIS Thatcher MVALAWA ------as to allow the man who axed 70,000 jobs in steel to go through the remaining opposition like so much margarine.

The Economist has, for example, recently claimed that with the new technology available to the NCB, 60,000 miners could do the work 190,000 miners do now. And of course the coalfield most conducive LU LUVMINIVSY ne. tal techninov 15 Nottingham.

Arthur Scargill, I conclude, is telling the truth. It is Ian MacGregor who is being less than frank. Mind JOHN HARRIS This really spoiling my pint are Sid Weighell "never in a thousand years would this happen under Joe Arthur is using the miners as his cannon fodder" and Frank Chapple "miners, transport workers and any other groups Scargill can muster and hoodwink are his expendable cannon fodder. Only the intimidation of the flying pickets keeps him on course. wUN.

Is it possible that these two creatures have really sunk so low that they've taken to employing Ian Mac. Gregor as a speech writer?

----- pull-quotes -----

credit to Miners Solidar. ity Fund, Co-op Bank, Sheffield branch, account

dation, shouldn't he. After all, he's the joker who's

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 176

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →