Do we need a new Popular Front?
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-04-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
John TWO SPELLS of reformist government without reforms have paved the way for the most right wing government in Britain since the war. And• until recently, anyway — that government' hold looked pretty strong.
So much so, that 'the country's most distinguished Communist intellectual' (as the Financial Times refers to Eric Hobsbawm) tells us that Labour must at least seriously consider some pact or coalition with the SDP-Liberal Alliance.
"Some way", Hobsbawm insists, "of uniting the majority of the British people which is opposed to Thatcherism must be found. If at the next election Thatcherism is everywhere opposed by two or more candidates competing for each other's votes, the Tories can look forward to being in power into the 1990s"
This government is so terrible, he says (and the exaggeration of what Thatcherism represents is functional to Hobsbawm's conclusions), that there can be no doubt about it. "The issue of electoral unity will have to be faced"
Why does Hobsbawm think that the SDP is so much better than the Tories? It is not made quite clear.
He tells us that the SDP's leaders should never have left Labour. Their loss he blames on the "sectarian radicals" who fought the battles to democratise Labour and turn it left.
But what do the SDP leaders represent? Why were they a loss to Labour?
We are simply not told -just given the vague impression that they are very civilised people, rather like Tony Crosland, who enjoy their wine and the welfare state just as much as the rest of us but are perhaps a trifle more hard-headed and less romantic. Down to earth, but decent. Not mean of spirit like Thatcher or Tebbit.
The fact that these decent middle-class people want to go further than Thatcher union-bashing; that they want to ban free collective bargaining; that they swear by the cold war; and that they are still moving rightwards (witness Owen's 'social market' speech last autumn) — all this simply lead Hobsbawm to speculate that perhaps Owen is 'a Thatcherite element"
''The country's most distinguished Marxist intellectual' may know a thing or two about the development of the labour aristocracy in the 19th century. His researches have not, apparently, taught him to start with a class evaluation of political parties.
Arguing
SC At timés he describes Labour as "a socialist workers' party" , at other times as "reformist", "labourist" , to suit his argument. There is, of course, a difference.
But back to the SDP. Roy Jenkins, Shirley Williams, and the rest could enlighten Eric Hobsbawm about the class nature of their party. They are all 'Thatcherite elements'.
Behind the lounge lizards and the claret bibbers, as behind any potentially successful capitalist politicians, stand a queue of backers representing ICI, ICL, Rothschilds, etc.
The SDP, as a capitalist party, is a means of countering the impact of Bennism in the Labour Party, and of attempting to ensure that it would not reach government even if it controlled the Labour Party.
The electoral success of the Alliance has already made it Become a supporter of the Socialist Organiser Alliance - groups are established in most large towns. We ask £1.50 a Eric Hobsbawm difficult for Labour to form a majority government without relying on it in some fashion. If the Tories' legal changes on the political levy work satisfactorily for them, then they will provide the possibility of strengthening the Alliance further by detaching at least some unions from Labour and moving them towards the The Alliance's 'Thatcherism with a human face' is a means to ensure that if Thatcherism is defeated then there will be a second capitalist party, at best able to take over, at worst able to supervise Labour and draw its sting.
So what should be our response? Bob Rowthorn, a Communist Party member like Eric Hobsbawm, agrees with Hobsbawm that we need a broad anti-Thatcher alliance. However, he goes even further.
"It would help", , he assures us, "to prevent the Alliance from drifting (!) in a Thatcherite direction and strengthen the hand of the more progressive elements within the But however much Rowthorn may cajole them to turn left, class interests put the Alliance solidly on Thatcher's side. They are not waverers, or men and women in the middle of the class war. They are aware and died-in-thewool champions of Capital and enemies of the working class.
Any agreement between Labour and the Alliance would mean taking any pretence of and capitalist parties have been called Popular Fronts. In the past they have been justified to the working class in terms of defending democracy against fascism in the '30s.
But every time the arrangement meant that the working class parties accepted the hegemony of the capitalists, acted to discipline and demoralise their own working class base, and thus paved the way for the fascist threat that they sought to combat. A workers' movement fighting for socialism could have brought about a completely different outcome.
Yet the historian Hobsbawm refuses to learn the undeniable lessons of history. His ideas, he proudly asserts, are "an up-to-date version of the Popular Front"
The only difference is that the fascist movements of the '30s did represent something seriously different from the traditional bourgeois parties, whereas the differences between the Tories and the Alliance are very minor.
The basic problem is the same: in the harsh world in which we live today, political parties have to help capitalism run smoothly - which means attacking the workers with whatever force is necessary to sustain the system — or they have to move to replace capitaiism with socialism, and that means attacking the capitalists. You cannot stand around in the middle of the road.
Eric Heffer hit the nail on the head when he said, "unfortunately some Euro-communists have moved to a right wing social-democratic position"
Eric Hobsbawm deserted socialism long ago. He thought socialism was what existed in the USSR, and no wonder he deserted it.
He is that walking tragedy, a reformist in a world without reforms. He is a sad figure.
The good old British middle class decency which he seeks to defend jointly with the Alliance never really existed. Nor did the idealised Coronation Street good old working class whose death Hobsbawm also laments.
If we followed his advice the Labour Party wouldn't be around very much longer either. on: S in: Li Open ment Let them Humans have the most varied diet of any species (or can have), and are classitied as omnivores. As such, we have about ten metres of guts, with different regions specialised to digest different types of food.
Now, a long stretch of gut, the large intestine, has seemed to have little nutritional importance up to now.
To be sure, it is important to our general health in that if we don't eat enough fibre or "roughage" , we tend to develop such unpleasant complaints as haemorrhoids ("piles") or bowel cancer, both common in the West.
But does the large intestine exist mostly to punish us for our "refined" habits?
What does it do with all that fibre, anyway? Conventional wisdom has been that the bacteria that exist in billions in the large intestine can break down fibre into compounds that could nourish us, it we could only absorb them, but that very little can actually be absorbed by the body. Now it seems this may be wrong and a significant amount of dietary fibre can be digested.
The average UK intake of 20g of fibre a day would only give about 40 calories of energy, but a rural African's intake of 100g per day would yield some 200 calories -about 10% of daily energy needs.
Gathering and hunting societies (closer to original human life-styles) would probably eat still more fibre than this, and the fibre would make the difference between life and death.
sturday June 23 (provisional date) indon (venue to be confirmed) to: delegates from women's and organisations and individuals.
By Alex Simpson THE intense publicity given both to the Shuttle's mission to repair the striken Solar Maximum satellite and the Soviets' hosting of an Indian cosmonaut aboard the orbiting Salyut space station highlights once again the intense rivalry and the refusal to enter in to mutually beneficial collaboration in the field of space exploration.
The USSR, still smarting at the 1969 American moon landing, may intend to use the operational experience derived from the Salyut programme to pave the way for vengeance against the US by being the first to make a manned landing on Mars before the year 2000.
Many analysts working for the American space agency, NASA, are of the opinion that Russia has nearly all the technological and personnel prerequisites for an attempt.
Increasing numbers of Soviet cosmonauts have experience of a state of prolonged weightlessness by missions of up to a year in the orbiting Salyut space station.
The outward journey to Mars would be of almost the same duration and it is believed a sophisticated life support system is under development capable of sustaining a crew of cosmonauts in space for a projected round trip lasting a little over two years.
The only great difficulty or controversy Soviet scientists might run into is the possible construction and use of nuclear powered booster engines. A nuclear engine would be twice as efficient as any existing chemically fuelled rocket motor. It is considered that atomic power is the only way • to overcome the constraints caused by limits to size of the eventual payload within presently existing technology The United States hopes that its present mission will put the shuttle on course for a commercial viability in the satellite repair and retrieval business.
The Shuttle is also involved in another ludicrous twist of the space race as it tries to steal customers from the European space agency by proving itself a more reliable satellite launcher than the ESA's Ariane rocket.
The United States may decide to enter the race for Mars and the adoption of such a policy might be signified by moving forward plans for a permanently manned space station presently set for 1992. Though Alex has not entered into arguments for or against space exploration, guarded approval for certain aspects has been expressed within the. Science Column. If comrades have views on this or related subjects, the Science Column would be very pleased to receive (and publish) them LES HEARN WOMEN'S FIGHTBACK be holding a national conference WOMEN: FIGHTING LOCAL GOVERNMENT CUTS!
Once or Fightphone
----- pull-quotes -----
for cial