The real larzan
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-04-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
red is Red Ken? Frank Higgins reviews the new Tarzan film, 'Greystoke' THIS is the 39th Tarzan film, and it must be one of the best.
Which isn't surprising, maybe, since most of the 39 have been cheap and uninspired B movies. 'Greystoke' was made by the same team that made the much-acclaimed and much-awarded 'Chariots of Fire', and it is very well The B movie formula had villains of different shades and descriptions — from petty crooks to Nazis - coming to the jungle to be sorted out by Tarzan. 'Greystoke' is Edgar Rice Burroughs' original story.
It tells how the infant Tarzan is orphaned in the jungle and adopted and reared as an ape by a female ape whose offspring has just died. He becomes an adult indistinguishable from the other apes in gait, voice or habits — except that he has found and learned to use a knife.
King.
With its help he makes himself 'King of the Apes' (incidentally, nobody refers to him as Tarzan).
Discovered and recognised as heir to the Earl of Greystoke by a Belgian, he is taught to speak and other human things. He goes home to England and the stately mansion of the Greystokes.
I can't judge the depiction of ape society for its authenticity, but the first part of Greystoke was very strikingly done. Moving too. The famous Tarzan cry occurs in 'Greystoke' just once, as an outpouring of pain when his ape mother is killed by savages.
Second half
A series of boy actors through the stages of growing up culminate in Christopher Lambert, excellent as the adult Tarzan.
The film is still likeable in the second half, at the Greystoke mansion, but it goes off a bit. Jane is here Tarzan's American cousin.
'Greystoke' is very "contemporary' — full of environmental message and concern, overfull in fact. Against vivisection, it tilts at what someone seems to label damningly as 'imperial science' This, of course, is an improvement on Edgar Rice Burroughs. The original 'Jungle Book' fantasies of The adult Tarzan The infant Tarzan adopted by the apes the apes Burroughs, the turn-of-thecentury New York cop, were racist, as you would expect from the time, place and subject.
In one of the final episodes Tarzan discovers a male ape who helped rear him locked up in a vivisection lab, and releases him.
=OW THIS WEEK 'Red Ken' Living: stone was elected a vice-chair of the Young Liberals!
According to the Morning Star he had been consulted and agreed to it.
The Young Liberals are, of course, members of the selfsame party that has vied with the Tories in Parliament, and with its SDP partners, to express vicious hostility to the miners and ardent support for the Kun Livingstone supports the miners. But he is a nice guy and perhaps he doesn't like to offend the Young Liberals.
Livingstone also hobnobs closely with Tory critics of Thatcher's local government policy in a sort of Popular Front to defend. the GLC. And why should hobnobbing with the Tories make him blench, when he is having the Queen to open the new Thames Barrier and publicly claims her as one of his fans. [Obviously Red Ken has not quite given up all hope of one day becoming Lord Redken].
And on the other side, so to speak, he works rather closely with that strange and very unpleasant sect, the WRP, without whose help he could not have launched 'Labour Herald'.
A man of parts, you might say, even if it is difficult to fit the
Jungle
Pursued, the grey-haired old ape and his son dressed up as an Edwardian gent climb a tree in the park. The ape is shot dead. Cradling the dead ape, Tarzan shouts at the crowd, "He was my father".
After that Tarzan finally Carvel (Chatto and Windus £2.95) parts together. In fact the perceptive Young Liberals have probably got it right..
For all his verbal adherence to the politics of a mid-1970s identikit lefty, what Ken Livingstone pans out as in practice is a humane local government administrator of the existing system who seriously champions radical liberal causes like gay rights, racial equality, Irish self-determination and so on.
A champion of radical causes is not a bad thing to be, in a labour movement polluted by backwardness on these questions. But it is a lot less than the Red Ken image.
Given his choice to be an administrator of the local state under capitalism who attempts to work the system within the guidelines laid down by the Tory government there isn't much scope left for his socialist politics except as spice for ceremonial and sentimental speeches. So he is a good radical and a fit vice-chair for the Young Liberals.
John Carvel's book explains many of the contradictions in Ken Livingstone. He had Livgoes back to the jungle. (Jane doesn't go).
The problem with the environmentalist messages is that they make an ending like that seem to suggest that the jungle is a better place than society.
But I liked 'Greystoke' quite lot.
ingstone's full collaboration, and it is the 'official biography', so to speak. The author manages to present a sharp outline of Ken Livingstone nonetheless, and the book is very valuable for that reason.
There is a long passage (in the chapter "Trotsky and the Apes') in direct speech from Ken Livingstone which really should be read by people who take their socialism seriously.
In it Ken Livingstone expounds the view that humankind fell from grace 20,000 years ago when we discovered agriculture, and nothing has ever been right since.
You can identify some of his probable sources - Frederick Engels, Bertrand Russell - but as a whole it is Ken Livingstone's own version of 'historical materialism' , and pretty weird!
it could, with a little twist here and there, be the voice of Peter Cook's A L Wisty, the raincoated man on the park bench who is leader and membership of the 'World Domination League'.
Socialist Organiser features strongly in the book - as the non-sectarian hard-left alternative to 'Livingstonism' '. That's only telling it how it is! But some of the things said about Socialist Organiser will be the subject of articles in SO in the next few weeks.
Scan page 10
ARI: Industrial
----- pull-quotes -----
John O'Mahony reviews 'Citizen Ken', by John