State of Irish solidarity: 2 Writeback
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-04-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
and letters to socinnet Urganie * Middle Lane, Londen N8. N longer than 100 words please: longer fetters are tiable to be cut.
IN HIS highly inaccurate and misleading report on a public meeting recently held by Southampton Irish Solidarity Committee ('The State of Irish Solidarity', SO 169), Tony Twine asserts that "SISC implicitly counterposed IRA-style militarism to revolutionary self activity of the Irish working class"
He went on to claim that "the silence was deafening" when he raised the allegedly "none-too-popular" question that "a fight for unity with the Protestant working class must surely be intrinsic in any struggle for Irish self-determination"
Obviously unity with the Protestant working class in "any" struggle for Irish self-determination is only possible insofar as Protestant workers break with the racist, neofascist and class-collaborationist position of Unionism and the Orange Order, abandoning their increasingly marginal privileges over their class brothers in favour of a united working class struggle for a socialist republic of Ireland, Sinn Fein's declared aim.
As Tony Twine well knows, SISC's position, as explained at the public meeting, a position which is indeed "justified by copious quotations taken from Marx and Lenin" is that the question of the natYOUR report of the Broad Left Organising Committee conference on March 24 was correct factually but rather weak on analysis.
I suspect most activists present were well aware that BLOC is a Militant 'front' organisation enjoying the same relationship. as the SWP with Rank and File. Your question 'conference or rally?' was unnecessary.
We were quite clearly at & Militant-inspired rally, with debate on the motion in hand kept very loose, as was the 'voting' (if you'd blinked you'd have missed it!)
The question activists sbould apply themselves to is not so much, 'do the Mili tant dominate BLOC?, but how we should react to it. The intended BLOC plan Ireland, in common with the progressive classes of all oppressed nations.
The defeat of British imperialism in Ireland is the vital, essential prerequisite for the revolutionary struggle for socialism in Ireland, and in Britain. It was, of course, Karl Marx who concluded • that, "The English working class will never accomplish anything until it has got rid of Ireland (Marx's emphasis).
Marx defended the right of the Irish republicans to take up arms against their British oppressors and campaigned for a political amnesty for Fenian prisoners in British jails. Lenin criticised those on the 'Left' , such as Trotsky, who denigrated the 1916 Easter uprising as taking place "under an archaic banner" , remarking that "whoever expects a 'pure' social revolution will never live to see one"
SISC is not, as Tony Twine tion of Marxism-Leninism, which holds that the revolutionary struggle for national liberation cannot be spurned "for the sake of" the socialist revolution, but is a historically necessary stage of the world revolutionary process. The Irish national democratic revolution is the first stage in the struggle for the overthrow of capitalism in Ireland, just as it is the "lever" , as Marx put it, of the socialist revolution in Britain itself.
The national democratic revolution in Ireland will doubtless take place amid mass defections of the formerly privileged upper layers of the working class (the Protestants, in Tony Twinese) from for regional conferences as a follow-up seems merely to be an additional layer of bureaucracy.
If the Broad Lefts are to be of any use they should be looking down, to the bottom of the union structure, and not upwards to create committees and conferences which mean little in reality.
The old CP-dominated Broad Lefts quickly became election machines unconcerned with the day-to-day aspects of trade union activities. This will be a major problem for the new wave as well.
To avoid this BLOC should make it quite clear that organisation should be at a grass roots level, based on workplaces or local trade groups. Regular meetings should be held, not to disconnection with the continuing and rapid progressive political development of the Irish republican movement in the direction of scientific socialism. It is our task here in Britain, Marx believed, "everywhere to put the conflict between England and Ireland in the foreground, and everywhere to side openly with We recognise the mass, defensive character of the armed struggle led by the republican movement against the British army occupation of the Six Counties and its local collaborators following the crushing of the 1969 uprising.
Perhaps Tony Twine might care to give "scientific" substantiation to his characterisation of "IRA-style militarism" by extending to denigrate "PLO-style militarism" "ANC-style militarism" , and "FMLN-style militarism'? And what, indeed, is "militarism'? Is it like "terrorism"?
We would be most interested to observe such a theoretical exploit à la Militant, although we very much doubt whether it will assist the creative development of Marxism, that is, scientific socialism.
Tony Twine's inability to comprehend the principled class position on the Irish national question is further reflected in the concessions he makes — we trust unconsciously — to the spurious "religious war" theory by his repeated references to the nationalist people as the "Catholic community" and to the Unionist guarantee as the "Protestant veto"
TANIA JOHNSON, for SISC.
cuss the machinations of union committees and subcommittees, but how we can best develop the aware ness of the wider membership.
To achieve this the Militant will have to abandon their sectarian attitude of old and be prepared to allow an 'open' organis ation.
To this end the Sheffield conference represents a step in the right direction. BLOC's confident outlook contrast remarkably with the sectarian, bleating misery of the SWP. Let us hope it does indeed develop into a rank and file based activists' movement.
IRSF member, West Midlands. [Name and address supplied].
----- pull-quotes -----
alleges, an "ultra-left sect': we stand firmly in the tradi-