Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Irish Forum flops

Socialist Organiser no. 177, 3 May 1984 · scan p. 8 · Patrick Murphy · about 1,032 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

BY Wednesday May 2 the report of the New Ireland Forum will have been published and Ireland's "constitutional' nationalist parties both sides of the border will be looking • to Britain for a positive response to their proposals.

The reputations of all the major parties in Southern Ireland are at stake but most importantly, the future of the constitutional Northern Ireland Catholic party, the Social and Democratic Labour Party depends on the success of the Forum.

As early as 1978 the SDLP suggested that the serious and moderate Irish parties get together and back some common initiatives on the national question.

Events in the North between 1978 and 1982 forced these political parties into a position where they had to develop some coherent strategy. The British government had continually failed to erode the Unionists' intransigence, offered no reforms even within the Northern Ireland state and had launched yet another Assembly to pacify public opinion in Britain.

But, more significantly, the fight for political status in the six county prisons had launched Sinn Fein on the road to electoral success. Sinn Fein are seen by the nationalist community to have a positive alternative to the bankruptcy and stagnation of the Northern Ireland state: the abolition of that state and a united Ireland. The SDLP desperately needed to find an equally positive response if they are to stem the growing tide of support for the republican movement.

For these reasons the SDLP refused to take their seats in the Northern Ireland Assembly in 1981.

Instead they set up the New Ireland Forum in 1982 with the three major Souther. parties, Fianna Fail, Fine Gael and the The support of Fine Gael and Labour, who are in coalition in the government of the Irish republic, give the Forum considerable status in Anglo-Irish politics. It was hoped that other moderate Northern parties would participate but the Official Unionists were never interested and even the middle class Alliance Party refused to make any submissions to the Forum. Like the Unionists, the Alliance Party sees the Forum as a platform for Irish nationalists which will refuse to challenge any of the traditional nationalist attitudes to the status of Northern Ireland.

Sinn Fein was deliberately excluded from participation, just as they are excluded from access to the Southern television station RTE. The fear of the Irish government at the rise of Sinn Fein is so great that government ministers and officials are refusing to meet any delegation of local councillors which includes Sinn Fein councillors.

The participants in the Forum hope that Sinn Fein will be outflanked by the unity of constitutional nationalism, that moderate opinion in the North will respond favourably and that the British government will begin talks on the future of Northern Ireland based ont he Forum report.

None of these hopes are well-founded. British government policy on the future of Northern Ireland is without a local political dimension but is still bound hand and foot to the will of the Unionist population in the North. The Unionists are wholeheartedly opposed to the very idea of the Forum. They are outraged that Southern Irish politicians should presume to demand tor request anything of Northern Ireland. They will forcefully oppose whatever the Forum proposes and the present British government will do little to challenge that opposition.

Even worst, so-calied moderate nationalism has changed very little over the last fifteen years, to judge by the Forum's discussions. In a lengthy submission by the Catholic bishops the main church refused to even consider any loosening of their hold on the social conscience of the state.

Divorce, contraception, abortion and pre-marital sex are all to remain illegal and sinful. There can be no concessions to Protestant religious teaching.

Apart from a few individual 'progressive' Unionists, like the Belfast solicitor Robert MeCartney, the Forum has just been a platform for the traditional bourgeois nationalists in What will they have to offer? It is likely that they will accept partition as the future of Ireland for the time being. It seems that they will suggest some form of joint sovereignty over Northern Ireland involving both the London and Dublin governments with guaranteed safeguards and rights for both Catholic and Protestant communities. The British government will unreservedly refuse an concessions on sovereignty but will offer talks on better Anglo-Irish relations. The form this is most likely to take is an Anglo-Irish parliamentary tier, involving politicians from both governments. This suggestion was made in 1981 at a summit between Dr Garret Fitzgerald, the Irish Prime Minister, and Mrs Thatcher.

If the British government are to make these concessions, take the political risks and the loyalist flak, then they will have demands to make of the nationalists. They will want more cross-border cooperation in economics and trade, but the crunch will probably be their desire for more cooperation on security and the campaign against 'terrorism' • Given the coalition Irish government's tough stance on republican resistance this should present no problems.

The point is that for the Northern Republicans and their supporters in the South the New Ireland Forum will mean increased repression and tighter border security.

The most important immediate aim held by both Irish and British governments and the SDLP is the defeat of the campaign of resistance by the Republican movement to the rule of Britain and Unionism in the North.

The report of the New Ireland Forum should represent finally the abandonment of the Northern Catholics by the SDLP in favour of international politics and diplomacy.

The struggle against the Northern Ireland state will continue and, indeed, the demise of the SDLP may clarify the situation. If there is a danger in any of this to Sinn Fein it is that they will see themselves as the rightful heirs of the nationalism that the SDLP and Fianna Fail leave behind rather than a more radical, non-sectarian working class force in Irish polities. The events of recent years mark the failure of capitalism, British and Irish, to offer any solutions to the Northern Irish war.

The onus will increasingly fall on republicans and socialists to develop a strategy that can defeat the forces of reaction in Ireland, British, Irish and Unionist.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 177

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →