Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Does move il leaps?

Socialist Organiser no. 177, 3 May 1984 · scan pp. 9–10 · Martin Thomas · about 1,845 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Les I WANT to share with readers the pleasure I got from a book I read on holiday recently - 'Ever Since Darwin'*, a book of essays on natural history by American palaeontologist Stephen Jay Gould.

Gould is that rare creature, a socialist scientist, in a discipline where too frequently practitioners allow their political and social outlook to pass for scientific insight. But this book is not a political tract. It is a fascinating collection of glimpses at evolution, as a selection of, topics shows.

For instance, why does one species of bamboo flower once every 120 years and then die?

Why do cicada larvae live underground for 17 (or 13) years before emerging as adults, mating, laying eggs, and dying within a few weeks?

Why does on species of fly develop as a larva inside its mother, eating her body away, to emerge from the empty shell with her own daughter already eating her?

Why are human babies so helpless at birth? Gould believes human babies aie still embryos at birth. By comparison with our closest relatives, we would expect birth after some 18 months gestation. Gould points out that this would be physically impossible without a drastic redesign of the female pelvis.

A useful consequence is that more of the development of the human brain takes place outside, increasing the possibility of learning in what is essentially a learning species.

Engels

•What was the decisive step in human evolution - the development of a large brain or of upright posture?

With Engels, whom he quotes approvingly, Gould believes that upright posture freed the hands for the sort of manipulative labour that distinguishes human societies from all others. Those who claim that a large brain was of prime importance are merely reflecting the 'anti-labour' prejudices of our society.

Gould also suggests that the course of evolution may not always be gradual, but may be marked by (revolutionary) periods where new species are rapidly formed. For this some have accused Gould and co-thinkers of 'Marxism'.

True or not, Gould also takes a long look at the interaction of science and politics, particularly in the debate over race and IQ and 'human nature'.

This is a thoroughly readable. enjoyable and worthwhile book.

* Penguin £1.95. Martin Thomas reviews "The Poverty Brokers: the IMF and Latin America', by Martin Honeywell and others. Latin America Bureau £3.25. 'IN TWO squatter settlements... 88 per cent of those who had drunk milk regularly in 1972 no longer did so by 1978. Evaporated milk, once the mainstay for weaning small children, had become a luxury and instead mothers resorted to weak tea.

"By 1978, Nicovita, a chicken feed containing a number of toxic substances but costing less than 9p a kilo, was being eaten by squatter dwellers and peasants alike...

'Under-employment rose to include 50 per cent of the economically active population. The number of street hawkers swelled in the city centre, jamming the pavements...

'On the main highways in the city, the number of small children selling magazines and sweets, and cleaning car windscreens in the few seconds before the traffic lights changed, rose alarmingly. Petty crime escalated...

That was Peru after two years of treatment from the IMF. The same suffering is being spread throughout Latin America now, in the wake of the general debt crisis that opened with Mexico's default in August 1982g.

Imports to the seven largest borrowing countries in Latin America last year were 42% below their 1981 level. That means industry cut back, unemployment rising, food prices increased. Welfare services (such as they are) have also been decimated.

The IMF is the police officer for the international banks. Since the 1960s - and especially since the early 1970s, with the vast international flows of funds arising from the oil price increases - Latin American states have become more and more dependent on borrowing from commercial banks.

In 1965, 12% of Latin America's debt was owed to commercial banks. By 1980 56% of a vastly increased total debt was to the banks.

With the world recession after 1979, Latin America fell more and more into borrowing to pay off old debts, rather than for expansion. Then in 1982 credit dried up.

In 1983 the outward flow of interest and capital repayments from Latin America exceeded the new loans coming in by about $30 billion.

One after another, the states of Latin America have been forced to seek special arrangements with the banks.

The banks have agreed — on two conditions. First, overthe-odds interest rates. Second, IMF-supervised government austerity plans.

The IMF's plans are resolutely Thatcherite, using the cold winds of free-market economics to chastise the over indulgent borrowers. Or, more precisely — not so much to chastise the capitalists who borrowed the money in the first place, as the workers and peasants of the borrowing countries.

John "What is history but a tale agreed upon?" asked Napoleon Bonaparte.

And that's exactly what much popular 'history' in fact is.

The 'history' of Black Africa has for centuries been a tale agreed upon by those who robbed, despoiled, pillaged, exploited and enslaved the black people of Africa.

They treated black people as sub-human cattle, so they developed a powerful interest in believing that the blacks of Africa were by nature sub-human cattle, not too far above the beasts of the jungle.

The widespread description of blacks as 'jungle bunnies' isn't just a piece of casual recent British working class racist language. It is the distilled essence of the attitude to blacks and their history developed by bourgeois civilisation since the Renaissance.

The German philosopher Friedrich Hegel talked of the blacks as 'childish' and as not having reached the level of human self-awareness. Africa, he said, was no historical part of the world - it had contributed nothing to the great flood-stream of • The relatively enlightened Victorian explorer and translator Sir Richard Burton said that the African negroes were not just savages. Savages could be civilised; civilised people had been savages. The Negro, by contrast, was a degenerate, incapable of rising above the level of permanent childishness. Another Victorian explorer said that the black African was HUNGRY !

The Brandt Commission has proposed that the IMF be more flexible and generous about lending. There would be good capitalist reasons for such a policy: easier credit gives trade better possibilities of expansion.

Martin Honeywell points out that reforms of this sort "could lead to some growth in the LDCs (Less Developed Countries) in the context of a growing world economy. However, such growth would be bought at the cost of further maladministration of the countries" resources in the hands of a small elite"

Also, it would ease the smaller crises - but probably at the cost of even more dramatic crises later. The present 'human nature in state' In his eight-part Channel 4 TV series 'Africa' , the Marxist writer Basil Davidson sets out to clean away the encrusted lies and myths generated by the post-Renaissance slave trader's-eye view of Black Africa and its people.

In place of the popularly believed myth that all Africans were "still up in the trees".

The is presenting an account based on archeological and other scientific evidence of African civilisations over 4000 or more years.

And it is often a startling story that he tells: rock-paintings made by negroes seven or eight thousand years ago in the then verdant Sahara; ancient Egypt; the black kingdom of Meroe, 1000 miles south of the Egyptian frontier: a medieval Christian kingdom in what is now the southern Sudan (it was overrun by Saladin's Muslims during the Crusades).

Basil Davidson demonstrates that African blacks were very much a part of what we consider the mainstream of history.

Using Egyptian tomb-paintings of black Pharaohs, a medieval statue of the black crusading knight Saint Maurice, and early Renaissance paintings, he shows that the equality of the different STC?

TALKINi POLITIES' debt crisis is, after all, the sequel to a period of extremely easy credit from the international banks in the '70s.

Winston James's chapter on Jamaica also argues that the real villain is not just the IMF, but the system that it expresses and administers.

• The social and economic crises of contemporary Jamaica cannot be simply 'blamed' on the IMF as many have tended to do... Unviable economic measures were prescribed by the IMF, but were not executed by it. The measures were put into effect by the indigenous Jamaican ruling class, albeit not under circumstances totally within its control" its crudest 72407d races was taken ::: #27: 20 Europe, after the :.:] = tury, started to :? 4e It "warren for the daeze " ITIing of black skins". a Ne.MEi put it.

Black people we: it e inferior and sub-ture :# when the opening-up 0: 1570 made black slavery one :::te most profitable actres 3E open to unscrupulous mitte and to states like that s: Estland's Queen Elizabeth I Soon even the meme= African civilisation was fie over. Where a Saint Maurice soc not be erased as a name from Pantheon of the Church. be azs erased as a black man and came 1o be regarded as white (though ite statue in Magdeburg cathedral is plainly that of a negro).

When 19th century explorers came upon impressive ruins im Black Africa, they explained bes with fantasies about refugee from higher civilisations. The blacks could not have had zurthing to do with it, they insisted Even the famous Dr Albert Schweitzer, who spent much of his life doing Christian good works in African jungles, could talk in the middle of the 20th century of the African being his brother in Christ, but his 'younger brother'.

Davidson's series is opening up the history of an entire segment of humanity long hidden by our self-complacent ignorance and by the encrusted prejudices secreted and petrified by our civilisation over four centuries. Don't miss the rest of it.

The Manley government in Jamaica had declared that it would defy the IMF. But eventually the logic of capitalist economics pushed it to the IMF regardless. 'Capitalism in one country' is not a real alternative to IMF imperialism.

The IMF and the system it epresents need to be fought ›oth from within the richer capitalist states and from within the Third World.

Here, we need to fight to replace the power of the bankers and bosses by working-class control over the economy, and to substitute massive aid and reparations to the Third World for the banks' blood-squeezing usury. And the working class in Latin America and the Third World needs to fight to oust their local capitalists, to break down the borders which divide them into small, weak country units, and to create a power which can face down the banks.

Labour Movement • Conference on Palestine Saturday May 19. County Hall, London SEI.

Speakers include Moshe Machover, Uri Davis, Jeremy Corbyn MP, Colin Talbot (POEU), PLO repr sentative, and Peter Tatchell.

Two delegates per labour movement organisation:

credentials £2 from Andrew Hornung, 28 Carlton Mansions, Holmleigh Rd, London N16.

Scan page 10

пo.177

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 177

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →