Fight for a general strike!
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-05-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
urged them to accept a deal with the government for wage rises and end the general strike. Posters from May-June 1968: below, 'The boss needs you, you don't need him', bottom left, 'The vote changes nothing, the struggle continues', bottom right, 'Return to normal'. THE call for a general strike not a slogan that should be used lightly.
What perspectives does it open up? What does working class history have to teach us about general strikes?
the 19th century, the general strike was the anarchists' slogan, and the Marxists were sceptical. Engels wrote:
'In the Bakuninist [anarchist] programme, a general strike is the lever for unleashing social revolution. One fine morning, the workers in all the industries of a country, even the whole world, stop work and, in four weeks at the maxımum, oblige the ruling classes to surrender."
But how would the working class reach the tremendous level of organisation necessary for such an act? And if they did get anywhere near it, could they not achieve their aims by other means In the early 20th century, Rosa Luxemburg, basing herself on the experience of the Russian Revolution of 1905 and also the Belgian general strikes for voting rights, argued that the real development of the mass strike movements had outstripped both the anarchists' conceptions and Engels' objections.
"In a word the mass strike, as shown to us by the Russian Revolution, is not a crafty method discovered by subtle reasoning for the purpose of making the proletarian struggle more ettective, bul the method of motion of the proletarian mass, the phenomenal form of the proletarian struggle in the revolution."
Instead of the general strike being the product of an utopian all-at-once working-class rejection of capitalism, it could be the ineans by which working class consciousness developed from limited aims according to the laws and logic of the class struggle.
A general strike, even starting +rom limited demands, rapidly raises the question of yury workers taking control of law and 1alses order, essential supplies and services, etc. It paralyses the state.
It poses in a practical manner the question of who is boss in society.
It also poses an answer: the workers must take power and operate the means of production under collective control.
So we must be able to fight for the use of the general strike at relevant times as a weapon for immediate limited demands; and at the same time equip ourselves to fight for workers' victory in a general strike, once started.
That is the basis on which it makes sense now to argue for organising for a general strike in connection with such issues as supporting the miners, stopping -he cuts and closures, and crapping the anti-union laws.
What are the objections to this Perspective?
Some comrades argue (see zil that we should instead call •3: a general strike to kick the Icies out' Bi: this slogan is attractive SEE: because it is ambiguous.
4e: Mariss need precision.
stike to kick " that we -.mes : does not LE VOTE NE EWANTE The last thing that will happen in a general strike is a government simply resigning (unless perhaps it hands over to a 'national unity' coalition or a military administration). It has to be replaced.
How and by what? Through an election, by a Labour government? That is what most people will understand when they hear the slogan 'General strike to kick the Tories out' at present.
A Labour government is the only labour movement alternative to the Tories, at present, and replacing the Tories even by a Kinnock-Hattersley administration would be a major achievement, at present.
But a general strike is not a weapon for winning elections! An actual general strike will start around an immediate limited issue or group of issues. The job of socialists is then to fight to develop the movement through workers' self-organisation, workers' councils, working class administration of essential services, and a workers' government.
Escape
'General strike for a general election' would mean developing the movement to the point where it threatens the government - and endorsing in advance the government's best escape route, the one used by the French government in 1968.
A government which called an election would retain control of the situation - and might very well win the subsequent election. The labour movement which had rallied millions of workers to the heights of a general strike, and then sent the movement dribbling down into a ballot-box exercise would lose the confidence of many workers and middle class people. That is what happened in France in 1968.
But the comrades who call for 'General strike to kick the Tories out' explain that they themselves would prefer the Tories to be replaced by a workers' government, through an armed uprising.
The idea is that they. would switch the actual meaning of the Slogan as the movement developed This is trying to solve a real problem by forms of words.
There is a real gap between the limited issues which would spark a general strike and the revolutionary perspectives which it would open up once under way.
That gap cannot be bridged by finding a set of words - 'General strike to kick the Tories out' which is vague enough to cover both.
The function of Marxist slogans should be to enlighten, to clarity, to make more precise. As Leon Trotsky put in in 1935.
'But is the general strike pos sible in the immediate future? To a question of this sort there is no a priori answer possible, that is to say. none ready made. To obtain an answer it is necessary to know how to question. Whom? The masses. How question them? By means of agitation.
"Agitation is not only the means of communicating to the masses this or that slogan, calling the masses to action etc. For a party agitation is also a means of lending an ear to the masses of sounding out their moods and thoughts and reaching this or another decision in accordance with the results.
----- pull-quotes -----
is winning more and more support in the labour move- ment. But 'general strike' is
RIEN LA LUTTE CONTINUE