Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Break Links Tories!

Socialist Organiser no. 178, 10 May 1984 · scan p. 9 · about 533 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Subscribe!

for 3 months; £8.50 for 6 months; and £16 Please send me .... months' sub, I enclose £ To: Socialist Organiser, 28, Middle Lane, London N8 8PI TANIA Johnson's polemic against Tony Twine (letters, SO 176) is based on the idea that all Irish politics must rotate around the "national democratic revolution', which is the 'historically necessary first stage in the struggle for the overthrow of capitalism'.

But what is this 'national democratic' - as opposed to socialist - revolution? Marxists generally use the term 'democratic revolution' to refer to events like 1789-99 in France or 1640-9 in england: the overthrow of feudal structures.

Unify

One of the tasks of those revolutions was the creation of a unified nation state, so 1 suppose Tania Johnson's idea is that a 'national democratic revolution' is still necessary in Ireland to unify fect' bourgeois state!

Who will execute this 'first stage' revolution? The working class? But then how and why is it a separate stage from the socialist revolution?

Or the nationalist bourgeoisie? But what makes Tania think that this bourgeoisie, which has lived very comfortably with Partition for 60-odd years, will suddenly rediscover revolutionary zeal? And on what does she base her demand that Protestant workers must side with the nationalist (i.e. Catholic) bourgeoisie?

I can see how we can hope to convince Protestant workers that their common class interests with Catholic workers are more important than communal catch-cries. I can see how we can hope to convince them that. the Northern Ireland state is a blind alley, and that their best hopes lie with conI cannot see how we can ever hope to convince them to sink their identity into green nationalism for the sake of some abstract scheme of the 'national democratie revolution' - or even why we should want to.

To quote sentences written by Marx at a time when there was practically no Irish working class, and hardly any Irish bourgeoisie, A DEMONSTRATION to mark the fifteenth anniversary of British troops being sent on to the streets of the North of Ireland will take place in central London on August 18.

The demonstration will be calling on the British government to implement a policy of political and military withdrawal from Ireland. It is sponsored by the following Labour MPs: Norman Atkinson, Tony Benn, Syd Bidwell. Dennis Canavan, Bob Clay and the chief struggle was between Irish peasants and absentee English landlords, is not very useful. Marxism is about analysing reality, not concealing it with formulae.

FOSTER, Islington Jeremy Corbyn, Joan Maynard, Allan Roberts, Ernie Roberts and Clare Short.

The organisers are also applying for a rally to be held in Trafalgar Square after the demonstration. This means challenging the ban on Irish demonstrations in Trafalgar Square which has operated for over a decade.

August Demonstration Committee, Clerkenwell Close London ECI Get SOCIALIST door by post!

RATES: £5

for a year.

Name Address Memen JOBLESS KEY TO Jebbit My Marry Kent's Steen appeal ORGANISER each week delivered to

----- pull-quotes -----

it. The 'second stage' of direct struggle for socialism cannot start until Ireland is first made a "per-

ciliating the two communities in a broader, all-Ireland framework.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 178

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →