Carousel: how the TGWU failed were responsible"
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-05-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
ORGANISED! time and would be at the picket lines at seven in the morning every day. By the end, though, when someone suggested we carry on for another three weeks, we couldn't do it for aven five hours a day. • The TGWU just didn't want to know us. There were different things they were doing to us to isolate us. That's how we ended up demoralised, because of what they did.
The blacking of the flour and boxes was done by ourselves, and these were the main supplies to Carousel. But a lot of other things needed blacking as well. The TGWU could have been getting them blacked.
And the TGWU stopped organising mass pickets. We ended up doing that ourselves. All we had was a wee bit of paper about a picket, but people wanted to see paper with the TGWU heading on it.
When the Socialist Workers Party (SWP) used to come down to the pickets they would tell us of people who had phoned up the TGWU and been told that no Second national meeting for Labour Party workplace branches «WORKPLACE BRANCH. ES AND THE UNIONS" Saturday May 12, Meeting Room, St Pancras Library (Shaw Theatre), Euston Road, London NWI. Open to Labour Party members in workplace branches or who want to find out more about setting them up Details from Nik Barstow, 165 Liverpool Road, London N1, or Geoff Dixon, 1 Pelham Court, 44 Hatherley Road, Sideup, Kent to Socialist Organiser.
mass pickets were on when they were.
The East End Support Committee [the local support committee for the strike was fantastic. We wouldn't have gone on so long if it wasn't for them.
Do you think it would have made a difference if the EESC had called a support conference?
It might have been possible before the miners' strike, but not now, because there's too many things on as a result of the miners' strike. And it would have been terrible to have the conference and then give up. But the TGWU were not having it anyway and didn't want to have anything to do with a conference.
Cut If the EESC had called one, then the TGWU, would have had the strength to put people off coming.
After Stark [Glasgow TGWU full-timer] spoke at one TGWU branch meeting, attacking a broadsheet history of the dispute we had produced, a member there came down and questioned us about what Stark had said. He knew us and believed us, so he could go back and argue our case to his members. But in all the branches where no-one knows us, then the TGWU would have cut off support.
We did get support from a lot of people. The Baillieston Labour Party branch gave us a lot of support. But you couldn't pin down support to just one or two, there were just so many.
That's what I don't understand - there was all that support there, but the TGWU didn't know how. to use it. A lot of people wanted to see us win and came into the shop we had once as a strike centre and helped with. leafleting and fly-posting.
The EESC organised those people. If Stark had been as determined as the EESC, then he could have got the people who were really into the strike and organised them.
If Stark had sent notices about the strike out to all branches, then we could have had a lot of people handing out leaflets at shops which took Carousel wafers. We tried to get round the shops ourselves but couldn't manage it. We never got the right publicity from the TGWU.
I'll keep on going to the TGWU youth meetings now and try to get the rest to go. But some may hate it so much. Although they've seen peg he im the thing on the TGWU in terms of the full-timers.
What do you think are the main lessons to be drawn from the dispute?
I've not really been thinking of it that much, it makes you depressed thinking about all the things that have I think that the TGWU thought that because we were young we would not last long on strike. But we got determination from working in the place. We wanted to get our back on Saccomando [the owner].
But the TGWU were not prepared to step over the line. When the anti-union laws came in, Stark said so many brilliant things, but when it boiled down to it, the TGWU wasn't prepared to act against the laws.
I can't understand Stark taking us to all those meetings and getting us the support at the start. I don't think he knew how to use it. Maybe later on I'll be abie to understand it more.
Stan Crooke THE Carousel workers joined the TGWU in early 1983.
Take-home pay at the factory was just £37 a week, and only £32 a week for those aged less than 18. Working conditions were disgusting, with birds flying round inside the building, fungus growing on the walls, and buckets and bottles of Dettol being distributed during wintertime when the toilets froze up.
It was so bad that the MSC even withdrew YOP trainees from Carousel.
In July the TGWU members demanded union recognition and better pay and working conditions. Saccomando, the factory's owner, refused both demands, saying that he would rather see his factory burnt down than allow a union in it. The TGWU members went on strike. And Saccomando sacked them straight away.
The TGWU is Britain's largest union. Saccomando is a sweatshop employer, running an even smaller scale operation than George Ward of the Grunwick dispute of the mid-'70s. But it was Saccomando who came out on top.
The outcome of the dispute was first and foremost a reflection of the failures of the local TGWU bureaucracy, heavily staffed by Communist Party (CP) members and feliow travellers like TGWU Scottish Secretary Hugh Wyper or Scottish Regional Officer Willie Queen.
The TGWU made the strike official and paid out strike pay from the outset. That apart, there is little positive to say about the role of the TGWU officials.
Picketing was never organised with any degree of enthusiasm by TGWU full-timers. When the strikers themselves tried to hold weekly mass pickets, there was little, if any, back-up from the full-timers.
The TGWU officials even failed on the basic issue of financial support for the dispute. Though the number of strikers never reached double figures, the TGWU soon began complaining of the unacceptable costs of the dispute, even going so far as to close down - in the looks at the factors behind middle of winter - the vacant shop which had been hired for the strikers as a headquarters.
Being the largest union in thei country, the TGWU would hardly have gone bankrupt paving strike pay to seven strikers for as long as was necessary to win the dispute.
After seven months on strike, the strikers found themselves not only isolated on the picket lines but also having to fight a constant rearguard action against their own union officials.
The dispute showed that those CP members who have secured a niche in the trade union bureaucracy are like other bureaucrats - a quiet life is more important than the class struggle.
It also showed up the limitations of other sections of the CP.
A number of local CP members who were not prepared to stand idly by as fellow members of their party allowed the strike to go down to defeat were active in the East End Support Committee (EESC).
The EESC did a lot of good work. But it had fatal political Get Name the defeat ¡ limitations. The EESC was pre. pared to confront the TGWU bureaucracy, but only to a cer. tain extent and within certain limits.
The EESC encouraged TGWI branches to call on the TGWU to convene a West of Scotland shop stewards' conference to 'help build support for the strike. Not surprisingly, the TGWT full-timers were not prepared to call such a conference. But then instead of convening such a conference itself, the EESC effee. tively dropped the whole idea of such a conference.
Broadsheet When the EESC produced : broadsheet history of the dis pute, it allowed only a limiter circulation to prominent indiv iduals in the labour and tradi union movement.
The basic weakness of thi EESC was that it was not reall prepared to take the dispute ant the scabby record of the TGWT full-timers out into the open ant into the broader labour an trade union movement. Instead its approach was often along thi lines of discreet pressure or selected individuals.
Become a supporter of the Socialist Organiser Alliance - . groups are established in most large towns. We ask £1.50 a month minimum (20p unwaged) contri. bution from supporters.
ation.
Address Send to Socialist Organiser, 28 Middle Lane, London N8 8PL.
Scan page 12
£5 for
----- pull-quotes -----
I want to become a Socialist Organ- iser supporter/ I want more inform-