A Dublin-London deal?
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-05-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
The Forum report is presented in Dublin. John Hume is on the right, Garret Fitzgerald first on his left, Haughey and Irish Labour Party leader Dick Spring fourth and fifth.
Irish constitutional nationalist politicians have made a new attempt to push Britain into fresh initiatives, with their New Ireland Forum report. John O'Mahony looks at the prospects.
January 1974: the last major political initiative, the power-sharing executive. It was brought down by the Protestant general strike of May 1974. THE BOSS class nationalist parties of Ireland have spent the last year trying to work out a set of agreed proposals for solving the Northern Ireland problem, which they could offer to l Britain as the basis for a new joint BritishIrish "initiative' to end the war in Northern Ireland.
On May 2 their New Ireland Forum reported.
The two main bourgeois constitutional nationalist parties, Fianna Fail and Fine Gael, Northern Ireland's middle class constitutional nationalists of the SDLP, and the Irish Labour Party, Fine Gael's coalition partner, all put their heads together to seek a way to end violence, restore stability - and stop the growth of support for Provisional Sinn Fein.
They excluded Sinn Fein, which got 100,000 votes - 42% of the Catholic poll - in last June's election, because its nationalism is violent. They had the collaboration of a few maverick Northern Ireland Unionists, though the Unionist parties could not he persuaded to take part.
And what have they come up with?
The report declares the present situation untenable; and rightly notes that it is likely to get worse unless something is done about it. "Constitutional politics are on trial, and unless there is action soon to create a framework in which constitutional politics can work, the drift into more extensive civil conflict is in danger of becoming irreversible, with further loss of life and increasing human suffering"
The solution, they think, is a deal between the Green Tories, North and South of Border, and the British Tories.
Alternatives
The report lists suggested alternatives to the present Six/26 Counties partition which has led to a complete breakdown of the old Protestant state in Northern Ireland and its replacement by brutal direct military rule by Britain.
Its favoured option is a unitary state for all Ireland. The "political unity which the Forum would wish to see established is a unitary state achieved by agreement and consent, embracing the whole island of Ireland and providing irrevocable guarantees for the Protestants and preservation of both the Unionist and Nationalist identities"
It is admitted that this implies a new non-denominational const¡tution for all Ireland. It would be formulated at a constitutional conference jointly convened by Dublin and London.
The report's other listed options are (a) a confederal linkage of the two Irish states and (b) joint London-Dublin rule over The Forum's 'chosen option' is the highest common denominator of the bourgeois green nationalists. Much importance was attached to keeping Charles J Haughey from breaking the green nationalist front, and that gave Haughey and Fianna Fail - those least inclined to conciliate the Northern Ireland Protestants much clout in deciding what the report said.
An appeal by Fine Gael and Labour Party coalition leaders for the Forum to endorse Fine Gael's "constitutional crusade' to liberalise and partly de-Catholicise the 26 Counties was rejected by the Forum.
Fianna Fail pressure and the common nationalist goals and aspirations of all the participants determined the Forum's first option'. . The sense that this was unrealistic and the search for a new way forward was expressed in the other options.
On that level the inclusion of the idea of joint Irish-British rule was a radical departure for the constitutional nationalists, particularly for Fianna Fail But within a short time of the Forum's report being published, its authors had begun to differ about what their agreed text meant. The Southern prime minister, Garret Fitzgerald, followed his own bent and began exploring the more realistic of the listed options.
Non-starter
That meant jettisoning the favoured option of a unitary state as a non-starter: only military coercion by Britain and/or the 26 Counties on a much bigger scale than has been known in the 6 Counties for the last 14 years could achieve a unitary state against the will of the Protestants.
So Fitzgerald tried to get the British government to discuss the other options.
Haughey denounced Fitzgerald for "walking away" from the agreed "first option"
Similar divisions emerged within the SDLP, with deputy leader Seamus Mallon parallelling Haughey against the more pragmatic and flexible party leader John Hume.
On the British response depended whether the Forum report had any possibility of influencing events - and which of the options if any would become the subject of serious discussion and negotlation"
Thatcher called the report 'over-simple' and said she rejected its attempt to blame Britain. But she also said that something had to be done because the war in Northern Ireland 'can't go on forever'.
Examination
Britain's Northern Ireland gauleiter Jim Prior immediately ruled out the unitary state and contederal states options, but. did not rule out joint British/26 County rule in Northern Ireland. He welcomed the Forum's commitment to 'freely negotiated and agreed unity', as distinct from unity by coercion.
It now looks like the joint rule option is to be the subject of detailed examination and perhaps negotiations in the autumn.
According to the Irish Times (May 9) the following topics, the bones of the 'joint rule' option, will be discussed by Dublin and London later in the year.
* The setting up of an 'executive joint authority' on the basis of a binding 26 County/ British treaty to be registered at the United Nations.
The Forum report defined an 'executive joint authority' as "the equal sharing of responsibility and authority for all aspects of the government of Northern Ireland by the governments of Great Britain and Ireland". It would include the * Joint policy.
* The RUC *A nev justice.
Joint two prime ministers. control of security replacement of the system of criminal Irish/British citizenship.
* Equal status in Northern Ireland for the Union Jack and the Irish tricolour.
The 'executive joint authority' could either be a system of straight direct rule, or it could include an element of local self-government - on a basis of agreed Catholic/Protestant power-sharing a big element, the forum says.
This would, of course, presuppose British government repeal of the legislation which enshrines the Protestant veto.
Prior's seeming willingness to discuss joint British/26 County rule has alarmed Protestant politicians. Any erosion of the present guaranteed constitutional position, and especially such joint rule, is, they say, part of a gradual drift to a united Ireland.
Paisley
lan Paisley declared: "The Protestants of Uister will settle it and if need be meet this Dublin dictator in a hand to hand confrontation". Even the moderate Unionists of 'Alliance' say that any attempt to change the constitution will trigger a big Protestant paramilitary backlash.
The Provisionals say that the Forum has been a failure, and will not achieve what it was set up to do - strengthen the Six Counties constitutional nationalists against the electoral challenge of the Provisionals.
But the signs are that the Forum will stimulate serious talks between Dublin and London about some form of powersharing. There is massive pressure on Dublin and London to reach some form of agreement. As Thatcher says: they can't let things go on as they are indefinitely.
Any further electoral advance by the Provisionals, even if they fell short of eliminating the SDLP, would narrow and maybe close the options for new constitutional experiments by the ruling classes in London and Dublin. It is now or maybe never.
The Forum itself has created an added pressure on Britain and Dublin to act now. If the Forum report produces no constitutional movement then it will strengthen the IRA and make their military approach seem the only possible one.
Zig-zags
Haughey and Fianna Fail, both Seamus Mallon and John Hume in the SDLP, and, in a different way, Fitzgerald's Fine Gael, all want what the Provos want, a united Ireland. Some -or all - of them will compromise and settle for less, but if even their sort of compromise proves impossible, then the Northern Ireland Catholic pendulum will swing powerfully towards the IRA.
The net result of the Forum - an idea suggested by John Hume to revive the SDLP - will be to speed up the consolidation London and Dublin must know it. So they may indeed try some form of joint rule.
From the British point of view it could, minimally, increase the level of British and Irish bourgeois cooperation in repressing the IRA. It would be one way of "solving' the hopeless task of recreating a political superstructure in Northern Ireland.
But they would have a long way to go from talking about it to doing it. Fianna Fail support might not be forthcoming , for joint rule. It would, after all, be a partial restoration of the. Act of Union dissolved in 1921.
In the North, Protestant reaction would probably be fierce -in the same way as, ten years ago, the Protestant general strike scuttled the last large-scale London/ Dublin attempt at remodelling the Irish state system.
What should be the attitude of working class socialists? For us it is a basic principle that Britain never had and never can have any rights in Ireland. But Irish socialists should not simply throw their weight behind military and populist versions of nationalism as against constitutional versions.
They need instead a socialist and democratic programme which could be a basis for beginning to unite the Irish working class, North and South, Catholic and Protestant. This programme, in my opinion, should include regional autonomy for mainlyProtestant areas within a united