Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

States in the Third World

Socialist Organiser no. 180, 24 May 1984 · scan p. 6 · Martin Thomas · about 608 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

NO TO BOTHA! NO TO APARTHEID!

Assemble 11.45am at Speakers Corner for march Martin Thomas reviews 'Politics and Dependency in the Third World: The Case of Latin America', by Ronaldo Munck. £8.95, Zed Press, 57 Caledonian Road, London N1 9DN.

Ronaldo Munck is an Argentine Marxist currently living in Ireland. The core of this book is a brief comparative history of the labour movements and of the political regimes in Brazil and Argentina.

The most interesting theoretical idea in the book is thrown in, in an off-hand way, in the last chapter. Capitalist development in Latin America, Munck suggests, has moved through three main types of state form.

From the second half of the 19th century up to around 1930 the typical regime was the "liberal-oligarchic state" where the ruling class was a landed oligarchy drawing its main wealth from exports of primary products. Generally it rested on a variety of pre-capitalist relations of production.

After the Great Crash of 1929 the old primary-product export business collapsed, and the "liberal oligarchic state" was typically replaced by a "nationalist-populist state"

This "nationalist-populist state" had a high degree of autonomy from the ruling class, but its essential business was to foster the rise of an industrial bourgeoisie, which in the course of time came to be the dominant section of a single, integrated ruling class together with the landed interests. "Certainly since the 1970s it has been an absolute anachronism to refer to a feudal or even semi-feudal oligarchy...

Military

The "nationalist-populist state" broke down, says Munck, chiefly from inability to deal with rising working class militancy, and was replaced, through a series of coups in the 1960s, by "modern military dictatorships"

Those military regimes have drastically increased inequalities of income and ruthlessly attacked working class organisations. But the results have been very different in Brazil - a tremendous expansion of industry, led by the state - and in Argentina - a virtual de-industrialisation after 1976. Munck explains this difference fundamentally from the higher level of organisation and combativity of the Argentine working class.

Munck sees the 'nationalistnobulist state" land also, per-:

BARBE haps, the "modern military dictatorship" - it is not quite clear) as having accomplished, essentially, 'bourgeois revolution from above" , on the model of Germany or Italy in the second half of the 19th century. Mexico is a major exception here: it had 'the only truly popular democratic revolution in Latin America.' Munck is emphatic that 'the capital-wage labour relation has become the axis of bourgeois society in Latin America"; and he takes note of the major Marxist criticisms of the most influential radical theory of Latin American economy and society, 'dependency theory'.

According to the various versions of this theory, the capitalist world system is fundamentally divided into a 'centre' and a 'periphery' , and development in the 'centre' (US, Western Europe) creates and goes together with 'underdevelopment' or at best pseudo-development, 'lumpen-development' in 'peripheral' areas like Latin America.

Nation/class

Sellattheory, says reticack, theoretically between a national and a class approach. When taking the Third World nation as the appropriate unit of analysis there is an inevitable tendency to reduce the importance of the class struggle." And the theory has 'the assumption that there is an ideal, unrealised but potentially achievable state of autonomous 'nondependent' development. It is very easy to slip into the idea that breaking the links with the world market will automatically allow for development, it these are seen as the basic cause' 01 backwardness' 'The Mexican or Brazilian bourgeoisie has a degree of power comparable more to its counterparts in Spain or Italy than to those in Tanzania or

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 180

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →