Is Neil Kinnock a socialist?
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-05-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
Neil Kinnock did say this week that in a hung parlia= SDP-Liberal Alliance. But he immediately offset that regional TUCs calling strikes in support of the miners.
WE ARE still accused of being unfair to Neil Kinnock. Look at the jump Labour has made in the opinion polls, we are reminded.
OK, but let's look a bit further.
My view is that the clearest sign of Kinnock's opposition to socialist policies was his abstention - let's not mince words — his vote against Benn as deputy leader in the 1981 election.
Kinnock has never been a man of the left. He went along with the left a bit until it was time to get back to the business of getting into government - getting into government on any tells.
Kinnock is not even a Michael Foot style compromiser. The Party should be moved rightwards, he bèlieves.
"We have given the impression", he was saying after the election, "that we are simply not attuned to the reshuffled class system since the '50s, to things like home ownership and taxation. We must convince the British people that we are in favour of success."
Kinnock has given coherent and sustained support to the witch-hunt against Militant and against Tariq Ali. He urged the NEC to abandon a clear cut committment to unilateralism. He has also pressed for changes in policy on council house sales and the EEC (and Kinnock's move was a right-wing one even if you think that the old policy on the EEC, of British withdrawal, was no good).
He has also made it clear that he favours incomes policy.
To reconstruct the old Labour Party in a new guise, Kinnock was also busy behind the scenes letting it be known that he preferred Hattersley to Meacher as his deputy, and letting it be known that Joan Lestor or Phillip Whitehead Neil Kinnock did say this ment, Labour would not SDP-Liberal Alliance. But by backing up Len M regional TUCs calling strik Is Neil Kinnock really a discusses the issues. were vastly preferabie to Tony Benn in Chesterfield.
What Neil Kinnock wants, and has got so far, is a centre-right coalition in which he will satisfy the left with left talking and no action.
Kinnock makes as few concrete commitments as possible. He won't go to great lengths to revise the existing programme. It is autonomy from programme, freedom for the leadership to do as it will, that he desires.
Doesn't Neil Kinnock have an understanding of how to appeal to ordinary people? Yes but it's a wrong one.
People don't vote for the nice Joe. They are not that silly. Look at the big percentages in the opinion polls of people who can't stomach Thatcher but will vote for her. They know there is trouble and they want hard answers.
Neil Kinnock would like to see himself as a replica of Harold Wilson in 1964. But in 1964 a lot of us poor suckers really believed in 'the white heat of the technological revolution"
Today is not 1964 or even 1974. The situation Kinnock will inherit will be more like Ramsay McDonald faced in 1929.
But the parallels with Wilson and McDonald are good ones. Like them, Neil Kinnock does not believe in a serious commitment to dismantling the capitalist system. Like them he just wants to civilise it a little.
Like them, he is not a socialist in our sense of the word. Like them, if he gets into week that in a hung parlia= form a coalition with the he immediately offset that urray's condemnation of es in support of the miners. left-winger? John Mcllroy office he will end up attacking those who put him there.
Alas, like them at similar stages in their careers, he has a lot of support. People get tired of continuous battles which appear to have no easy resolution. Those with good instincts but not a very developed political philosophy particularly get weary.
I don't say this in a patronsing tay ising way but there are many like that in the Constituency Labour Parties. In the early '60s, it was the same. People were looking for some way out of the apparently endless confrontation between the left and the Gaitskellites. Wilson seemed to be the answer.
There is the same desire to unify behind a bright young leader today.
This kind of unity is a fake urity. It avoids all the nasty acrimonious arguments about nationalisation, about democratising the Party, about the mechanics of the Alternative Economic Strategy, about Ireland, and so on — because it stops us addressing the real problems, it stops us getting anywhere near halfway right answers.
It is not simply that Kinnock will abandon Labour's programme. June 9 1983 showed up many of the inadequacies of that programme.
If, as we believe and many of the electorate believed, the AES is a dangerous fairy tale, how do we replace it by a socialist policy? If we are to pursue unilateral nuclear disarmament, then what about withdrawal from INATO? What about an alternative for