Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Organising socialist youth

Socialist Organiser no. 180, 24 May 1984 · scan p. 8 · about 1,987 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

The "Bennite youth current" in YS barely exists : criticise the Sandinistas! READING the before and after reports of YS Conference in Socialist Action (nos. 54 and 55) it rather seems that they haven't learnt any. thing at all from the conference itself.

Beforehand, Grant Keir promised that "Revo will be linking up with (the independents not affiliated to any political bloc in the YS) and proposing a new newspaper for the YS."

And after the conference (SA 55), Redmond O'Neil says the "growing voice to the left of Militant is the expression of movements like CND and the rise of the Bennite left through the YS itself. The weakness of this force is that it is not yet organised around a coherent project for replacing the Militant leadership with one committed to campaigning in alliance with tre Bennite left' • And 'this type of bulletin or newspaper is now possible and necessary to organise these branches who want to build the YS through campaigning action."

Weakness

At the YS conference there vere 69 non-Militant YS delegates. 21 supported Class Fighter, 16 supported the Labour Co-ordinating Committee and 18 supported Revolution Youth with one supporting Workers Power.

That leaves 13 independent delegates. 13 YS branchęs do not constitute the 'Bennite current" you think exists. The "weakness of this force" is that it barely exists!

The Labour Party is a broad, comparatively open party. But the YS is different. It is very, very closed. A YS branch is likely to be dominated by supporters of Militant. Unless new members have previously worked out different ideas, they are likely to become Militant supporters. Militart does appear to the newcomer to be a very active revolutionary group. Working in the YS rationally is more like inter•ening in another political :endency than working in the aroad labour movement.

The YS appears to be far more radical than the Bennites. And, in a sense, it șessibly is. The YS has a *ategy for transforming ener which its adherents -siese to be a revolutionary ==disgy it talks about the i ting class running society The •Bennites • while certainly more progressive on ssues like women, lesbian and gay liberation, and some -ational liberation struggles, present themselves as conscious reformists.

It is not surprising that big reformist current has not grown up in the YS.

So even while the facts tell you the idea is doomed, Revo still goes on pushing for a YS independent activists' paper. Even though the fringe meeting called to discuss it and regional bulletins only attracted three or four independent YS branches and Revo didn't even raise their idea for the paper.

Given that there are not hordes of youth in the YS ready and waiting to be organised. who is going to make up this broad current? What will Labour's youth movement is politically dominated by the Militant tendency, which combines Marxist rhetoric with a mechanical strategy expecting the labour movement to progress more or less automatically to socialism through the parliamentary nationalisation of the top monopolies. How, and on what political basis, can Militant be challenged? Jane Ashworth and Clive Bradley take up a debate with Socialist Action and its youth group, Revo.

be the political basis of it? Revo haven't said yet, but we can guess.

Yes, there are lots of youth who can be won to revolutionary politics who are not in the YS. But if these people are your target, you've got to explain why a broad paper would be better for reaching them than your own.

In fact the work of a YS will not be changed by being part of a broad current. It doesn't make a touch uf difference whether a YS organises its recruitment activity on the politics of a broad current or Revo's.

A weak-as-water programme tailored to be acceptable to a non-existent broadleft youth current will not help YS branches one bit in making contact with new working class youth.

Going into an alliance (against the YS leadership) with organised reformists for specific actions is one thing. Attempting to organise a broader group on a general political programme is something else completely. _It won't work to defeat Militant. And it can't work as a longterm perspective for transforming the YS. It would be a very fragile alliance.

Of course we need to organise youth into campaigning LETTER Don't JANE Ashworth's report on the LPYS Conference at Easter (SO 176) contains some important omissions, and is combined with distortions concerning the intervention of 'Revolution" supporters at the Conference.

Astonishingly, in her report comrade Ashworth omits to mention the two most important developments at the LPYS Conference. First was the solid arity given by the whole of the Conference to the Sandinistas, symbolised by the standing ovation given to the Sandinista youth. This marked a clear shift from the previous LPYS sectarianism towards the FSLN.

Second, the LPYS agreed to go all-out to build the June 9 anti-Reagan demonstration — again a sharp break from previous LPYS practice. This welcome change of direction for the LPYS is one which supporters of "Revolution' fought for and seek to extend.

At the same time it is not the case that Revo's tactic at Conference was 'to water down criticisms of Militant to little more than objections to Militant not campaigning" activity. But we also need to win them to revolutionary politics. The whole idea of an alliance with just about everybody cuts across doing that.

Even with a massive influx of independent activists into the YS, actively winning a majority in the YS requires a head-on political fight with Militant. We have to prepare and begin that fight now at the same time as building campaigns.

We also have to give a perspective to new youth who are repelled by Militant that goes beyond simply 'getting together'. That means winning those youth to an overall revolutionary approach to politics. Setting up regional bulletins, and 'building YS summer camp' are desirable — but they are hardly a perspective for changing the YS politically.

Already we've seen Revo responding to some of the correct criticisms Militant may have by denying their validity. This is especially true on international questions.

Critical

Revo attack us for being critical of the movements of the oppressed that we support. Dominic says "of course Revo refuses to criticise revolutionary leaderships (Sinn Fein and the Sandinistas) ..." Class Fighter's resolution on Ireland is attacked for including "a reactionary tirade against Sinn Fein and Gerry Adams" because while we called on the YS to support their struggle, we described Sinn Fein as representing "petty bourgeois Republican nationalism"; and Class Fighter is attacked for lining up with Militant on a composite on Nicaragua critical of the Sandinistas.

Dominic is quite right to say that the first responsibility of British socialists is to build solidarity movements criticise although a central critique we make of Militant is their reluctance or refusal to participate in broad-based progressive movements which they do not control, e.g. CND, around Greenham, solidarity campaigns.

No; we had, and have, a dual approach: First, a political and ideological struggle against Militant's wrong positions, e.g. their view of the socialist : transformation/ revolution, and their refusal to give unconditional support to movements of the oppressed and oppressed nationalities.

Carried out

(The reason we were unable on Conference floor to develop this is due to the fact that we were almost entirely carved out of the debates by Militantcontrolled Standing Orders Committee and the Militant chairpersons).

Combined with this we support a joint campaigning approach on those questions where Militant have made some steps forward. In this latter category we put the June 9 demonstration and the new-found support for the Sandinwith these struggles. We agree - and that is what we said in the debates and in resolutions.

But it is not our only responsibility. We also need to maintain our ideological independence: we have a programme for international direct working class power, and we do not believe that there is a substitute for the building of independent revolutionary workers' parties.

Avoiding that question plays istas already referred to.

We make no apologies for believing that this approach can best be taken forward by the launching of a new activists' paper in the LPYS for all who share this aim (a project derided by Socialist Organiser). It is clear that neither Class Fighter nor Revolution on their own can posture as an alternative LPYS leadership at present.

Our task is to organise the hundreds of new activists who, while joining the LPYS, are repelled by Militant's sectarianism, but who are also not yet convinced of the need for a full revolutionary Marxist programme.

More serious are the distortions on international solidarity. The article states: 'Revo refused to criticise the movements that they wanted the LPYS to support. On Ireland, Revo wanted to delete our criticisms of the IRA." In fact the resolution referred to didn't mention the IRA.

What we did attempt to delete was a reactionary tirade against Sinn Fein and Gerry Adams as representing "Republican petty bourgeois right into the hands of Militant. They say you are accommodating to an alien class ideology — and, in the interests of appealing to "broad layers', you are.

And there are grounds for criticism of Sinn Fein and the Sandinistas. Sinn Fein are not working class socialists: they are, politically, radical petty bourgeois nationalists. They do not have a programme for working class power, and they are, still, committed to a nationalism", in a situation where the main job of socialists in Britain must be to solidarise with Sinn Fein and develop the dialogue between Sinn Fein and the Labour Left.

What your readers may also be unaware of is that Class Fighter supporters lined up with Militant on Nicaragua. Despite cheering the Sandinista Youth to the echo, Militant and Class Fighter then voted through a resolution which said the FSLN were attempting to "compromise with imperialism" and "following a potentially disastrous course for the Nicaraguan revolution"

What hypocrisy! Of course Revo refuses to criticise revolutionary leaderships in this way, particularly at a time when the FSLN have mobilised the entire country under arms to confront imperialism.

I suggest that if your readers want a more objective review of the LPYS conference, they should read the report in Socialist Action DC MINIC JOHNSON, Oxford I ast LPYS delegate. ism that is not adequate to deal with Partition and British oppression, let alone the fact that imperialism is not just British troops.

The Sandinistas have attempted to establish an alliance with Nicaraguan capital; and they are part of the bourgeois Central American Contadora Group. They are, certainly, mobilised to defend Nicaragua from forcible US intervention. So were the Cubans in 1961 -and their victory was enormously important. But their victory did not lead to the establishment of a workers' democracy, and the programme of workers' power still needs to be fought for. That the Sandinistas are exceptionally militant and radical does not mean that they share our politics and programme. So we do need to criticise them.

Campaigns

Campaigns are not enough. Militantaredifferent from other left social democrats in that they see the need for a tightly organised group. Organising an alliance of campaign activists doesn't take on Militant. It must have a perspective for socialism. It must train its supporters to deal with Militant's politics. If it doesn' then you are playing right into Militant's hands. Militart immunise their supporters against us by branding us as nothing more than libera campaigners. Offering up == alliance which is that would be disastrous.

A tendency which is going :: take the YS from Militant must be built around revolutiera: politics. It must have answers to questions like the poterta power of a Labour gover.. ment. SA's project rules i= out.

----- pull-quotes -----

JOHN SMITH (IFL) posite 'physical force' Republican-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 180

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →