Rail deal: a blow to the struggle
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-05-31Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Keep coal movements vemen stopped Despite the setback on their own issues, it is vital that railworkers keep up the boycott on coal movements. Above: a convoy of coke lorries is escorted by police to British Steel's Scunthorpe plant. JOHN HARRIS (Sheffield City NUR)
THE National Union of Railwaymen has done the Tories a great service.
With a pay claim for a substantial increase, five weeks' holiday, and a 35 hour week without any productivity strings, the joint rail unions (NUR and ASLEF) claim threatened to add greater pressure to the Tories' falling credibility and to boost the fightback for jobs led by the NUM.
The BRB had made "offers" of 4% on the whole wages bill, and then 4% on basic rates, insisting that this must be paid for by getting rid of guards.
The NUR, at least, had declared this unacceptable. Our policy, adopted at the 1983 Annual General Meeting in resolution 69 stated: 'This AGM instructs the NEC ... to withdraw from any further talks on productivity, including One Man Operation of Trains."
Weighell
This had overturned Weighell's last service to the bosses when, after the Special Ceneral Meeting of October 1282 had accepted his resignation in the morning, he went on to plead for acceptance of productivity deals in the afternoon.
He succeeded in getting the SGM to accept productivity experiments with Driver Only Operation and to allow guards to be removed from the Bedford to St. Pancras line.
Nonetheless, after this policy of rejecting present and future productivity deals was adopted in June 1983, it took the NEC six months, to December, to accept it.
Previously, some noted right wingers had been arguing that it only referred to future productivity deals and we should go ahead with present deals.
Solidarity
Now the BRB offers 4.9% and accepts the union side argument that productivity issues should go, as is normal, to the Rail Staff National Council (RSNC).
And the NUR has abandoned its claim and accepted this.
Formally, this means that pay is not linked to job losses. But in truth the union has substantially shifted its ground for the sake of this formality - and accepted that job losses will be progressed through train running experiments without guards.
The inadequate overtime ban and work to rule has, of course, been called off.
Jimmy Knapp writes in justification: " • for the second year running the union has achieved a settlement free of productivity strings because the statement required by the Board of productivity requirements does no more than reiterate productivity initiatives still outstanding from RSNT (decision) 78 which was accepted by the SGM in 1982!"
The Tories can breathe a sigh of relief. This means that the NUM must continue to go it alone, without the aid of another major industrial union taking action alongside it.
It also takes the fire out of the solidarity action we are already taking to help the Guards who face the wrath of management for refusing to take out coal trains, signalmen who refuse to let them through, members who won't cross picket lines into colliery yards will now be asked or will be asking themselves - "If my own union has packed in the fight, why should I stick my neck out for another union to fight for jobs?"
What happened to a "sub. stantial pay increase"? Or the "35 hour week"? Or "five weeks' holiday"? Like all trade union bureaucrats who think it's just about discussion with management, rather than rank and file action, the NUR leaders got frightened by their own success.
As soon as management started backing down, they didn't push ahead, but grabbed at the first crumb offered and then gave up.
The fact that they were able to back down would suggest insufficient rank and file pressure. That now needs to be organised at the coming Railworkers Broad Left conference.
As soon as they feel ready the BRB will push ahead with getting rid of guards, work20/01 PuT
----- pull-quotes -----
ahead union leaders grabber at the crumb