Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The left against Kinnock

Socialist Organiser no. 181, 31 May 1984 · scan p. 8 · about 1,387 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

John Mellroy sizes up the Labour leadership Yellow rain The 'happy family' stunt that didn't quite come off. As Neil Kinnock was elected Labour leader at the 1983 ionference, he put on a victory celebration complete with wife and flowers. But the applause was more Gays against fascism LAST WEEK, I wrote about Neil Kinnock's failure to support working class struggles.

But there's another thing for about Neil Kinnock. The man is quite clearly a sexist - a horrible sexist. Socialism Most men are to one degree For another. But this man is blatant. And for somebody who takes such terrible pains JOHN HARRIS 22. embarrassed than enthusiastic.

Get Become a supporter of the Socialist Organiser Alliance -. groups are established in most large towns. We ask £1.50 a month minimum (20p unwaged) contriwith his image, i hard to stomach.

Last autumn, City Limits asked Neil Kinnock if he did any housework. "Honestly, I don't," he conceded. 'Well no. I tell you what I do -things like clean the fridge, maybe in the holidays"

And what abeut Gienys? She works full-time as a teacher. So she has to do two jobs while Neil reaps the benefit.

But Neil Kinnock is very considerate. "I've spent years and years trying to persuade her to get somebody to help her (you know what women are like, knowing wink) and for the last year we've had a smashing woman come in four hours a week.

"It's a great help ... but it took me years to persuade her.

'"Glenys is aware of the vestiges of sexism in my vocabulary. She doesn't think I'm sexist, but she says I misrepresent myself if I'm not aware of the need not to use certain words like 'bird" for instance."

Good for you, Glenys.

In fact, on my limited observation you appear generally to be altogether cleverer, pleasanter, and more acute than Neil, 'a man of hidden shallows' City Limits obviously thought along similar lines. "Has he ever discussed the possibility of her rather than him going into politics?"

No. Not really, he hadn't. And that's that. What a lazy, pompous fellow he sounds, doesn't he?

Hattersley

There is also Neil Kinnock's partnership with Roy Hattersley. Hattersley is a supporter of incomes policy, an opponent of unilateralism, a man who believes not in socialism, but in benign capitalism.

Only 18 months ago he was calling for expulsions and stating we must return to the values of the Callaghan years.

He is not calling for expulsions now - but that's because the Kinnock-Hattersley coalition has marginalised the left.

If we do start moving again, you'll soon see Hattersley's true colours.

What can and should we do about it all?

We have to accept that Neil Kinnock came in as leader with tremendous support. We have to accept that the conin combatting the fascist in combatting the fascist element in these clubs. element in these clubs.

Another decision was not to accept members from the six counties of Northern Ireland. The main reason was that to accept them would mean that we were accepting a partitioned Ireland, though some people dissented, feeling that this would be isolating these In discussion of a document which included a section on the right of children and young people to have control over their choice of their sexuality, objections were raised to the use of the word children, and it was felt that we could not wholly accept the views of paedophilia. It was eventually agreed to have a thorough discassion on this subject. stituencies, albeit through war-weariness, gave him 91.5% of the vote.

Even Roy Hattersley got 51%. The left's candidate, Eric Heffer, was nowhere. The union barons' block vote was even more monolithic: not one union voted for Eric Heffer.

The irritations of 1974-9 were in the past. Anything was better than the Tories. The left was a liability that hadn't delivered the goods. That was the mood.

Initiatives

The hard left is in 1 no shape for major initiatives. I 'he openings of four years ago no longer exist. There is some demoralisation. We need to rethink and regroup.

We, of course, unlike those who prate endlessly about it have always been 'turned outwards' to direct class struggle, and we will continue that.

Challenging the KinnockTHE "yellow rain" story took a new turn last week with Professor Aubin Heyndrickx of Ghent University arguing his claim that Iraq has used mycotoxins against Iran to a conference of the world's leading toxicologists, biochemists and experts in chemical warfare.

These allegations have been widely publicised with, for example, the Wall Street Journal using them to claim that the Soviet Union is now "peddling like candy" the agents of chemical warfare it is alleged to have perfected in South East Asia and Afghanistan.

But Heyndrickx's evidence is less than impressive. Firstly, he claimed that symptoms of Iranian gas victims (skin peeling off, body turning black, blood and pus from the nose and mouth) could not be explained by mustard gas. However, these are exactly the symptoms described in First World War mustard gas victims.

Secondly, he claimed to find mycotoxins (fungal poisons) in blood and urine from Iranlan solidiers in hospital in Europe, using the technique of Gas Chromatography (GC). But GC is not foolproof and needs confirming with the more exact technique of Mass Spectrometry (MS).

Correlation Suspiciously, Heyndrickx found no correlation between blood and urine samples from the same victim, i.e.where the blood contained mycotoxins, the urine didn't, and vice versa. This points to poor experimental practice, with the GC machine being contaminated with the mycotoxins used to standardise the results.

When Heyndrickx repeated his measurements a few weeks later using MS, he found mycotoxins. He said this was because they had decayed, Hattersley leadership is difficult at the moment. But they should not be allowed to think that they are there for years to come. Their politics will lead best a re-run of 1974-9.

We shall continue to urge the safeguarding and the use of the limited gains such as reselection. We shall oppose all witch-hunts whether in Wythenshawe, in Stoke, or in Birmingham.

We shall continue to explore how we can go beyond Labour's inadequate existing programme, how we can expand public ownership and develop workers' management, how we can take over the banks and finance houses, how we can withdraw from Ireland and give up nuclear weapons.

Above all we shall stand with our class — the NGA. the NUM. Liverpool City Council, in their struggles.

We shall, through doing all this, fraternally and constructively, eventually destabilise the hold the centre-right now have over the Labour Party and win it for socialism.

v rain though other researchers have found no such decay.

Also, researchers in Sweden have failed to support Heyndrickx's findings.

On the separate question of yellow rain in S.E. Asia, US scientists at this conference repeated their assertions that Russia had used mycotoxins for chemical warfare.

Leading critic of this view, Matthew Meselson; caused uproar by presenting his explanation that yellow rain was in fact bee turds on which the Fusarium fungus had grown.

Fusarium produces the virulent poison trichothecene and, contrary to American assertions, is found throughout S.E. Asia, growing on all sorts of rotting plant matter.

Fungi At times of food shortage, peasants are forced to eat food spoilt by fungi, and trichothecene poisoning may be naturally quite common, even without the intervention of the SE Asia bee.

Being social animals living in a small space, bees do not toul their own nests, but save it all up for a few weeks. By this time, up to 40% of the bee's weight may be faeces.

Then, all the bees in the hive go for a mass "defecation flight", peppering thousands of square metres with miniature turds. This is not as bad as it sounds, as the faeces are mainly pollen.

The US government has claimed that the Russians are actually using pollen to deliver mycotoxins to their opponents but there is no evidence to support this.

Fusarium thrives on stale bee faeces, but whether it actually produces trichothecene poisons on them has yet to be proved. If it does, the American warmongers will be left with bee faeces on their faces. Info: New Scientist

----- pull-quotes -----

- SCIEI Ye..o

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 181

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →