Imagine there's no strikers
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-05-31Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Mick Ackersley looks at Labour's latest TV broadcast battered picket gets arrested at the Orgreave line. He's campaigning for what does picket line. He's campaigning for Labour - but what does Neil Kinnock have Everybody's heard of 'fiddling while Rome burns' -the mad Emperor Nero is supposed to have done that. But how about "cooing sweet nothings on telly while the miners fight their prolonged bitter and uneven battle for the life of their industry"? Neil Kinnock and those who steer the Labour Party did that last Tuesday evening in a Labour Party political broadcast on TV.
The programme's theme was set by John Lennon's 1971 song "Imagine" , (which is hymnal, JOHN HARRIS offer him? pleasant and vapid), sung in this programme by a group Sheffield schoolchildren.
Cut to a scene of missiles flying through the air. Cut to three unemployed youth talking about what they think of Britain today. One of them delivers the message that we must puli together to put Britain back on its feet and make it great again.
NATO
Prunella Scales, the actress best known for her role as Sybil in Fawlty Towers, said what she imagined - peace. But, she said, "I'm not talking about pulling out of NATO tomorrow, or instant disarmament next week. I'm just imagining a defence policy in which, to begin with, we shall refuse to add any further nuclear weapons to the arms Cut to OAP's waltzing to "Imagine" and then to half dozen babies splashing about in water...
So you don't particularly like "Jerusalem?? You will after you've listened carefully to Kinnock's new "Jerusalem"
"Imagine there's no countries, it isn't hard to do, nobody to kill or die for, and no religion too"
Tell that to the miners forced to fight massed? "ranks of police thugs in riot gear to stop the Coal Board and Margaret Thatcher smashing up their communities. Of course, poor, well-meaning John Lennon isn't to blame for the fact this his dreamy pacifist yearnings are used as a theme song by a Labour Party leadership trying to pretend that the class struggle isn't raging all around us.
That struggle can give meaning and resonance to John Lennon's dream. But the dream comes out of the mouths of the Labour Party leaders as an alternative to class struggle.
Even the Daily Mirror the following morning had a front page showing a lone Arthur Scargill confronting a wall of police with riot shields and batons, and a big headline: 'England, 1984' What world do the Labour Party leaders responsible for putting out this sort of television bumpf live in?
Like Ramsey MacDonaid, the first Labour prime minister, who went over to the Tories in 1931, Kinnock recognises the class struggle as a fact of life - but not as something to take sides and fight in. Not as something the Labour Party is part of.
But the Labour Party is part of that struggle. All over the country constituencies are collecting money, making their facilities available to the miners, and throwing themselves into the miners' fight. The Labour Party National Executive decided unanimously to levy each Party member 50p per week for the miners.
Such television programmes are an insult and an outrage against the members of the Labour Party and against the labour movement - one of whose pillars, the NUM, is scheduled for demolition by the Tories and the Coal Board.
The smart lads and lasses re181% bland and soft-focused. On that sponsible obviously think it is good for the vote count to be level they may even be right -though to this viewer it seemed awfully bad even by the standards it was aiming for.
Image
They probably know the adman's business very well. The Tories and the SDP think they do know their business. They have expressed alarm that Labour is playing their own game - imagemaking - better than them. David Owen said of the broadcast. "The act they are putting on is to give the impression that their policies have changed when they are exactly the same"
Which will ring in the years of Labour's PR people like praise indeed.
Owen knows about "projecting an image. And he knows how to lie: the idea that Labour's new leadership secretly has a barbed Imagine there's no heav It's easy if you try.
No Hell below us Above us only sky.
Imagine all the people Living for today.
Imagine there's no count It isn't hard to do Nothing to kill or die for And no religion too.
Imagine all the people Living life in peace.
You may say I'm a dream But fon not the only one I hope some day you'll jo And all the world will be Imagine no possessions.
I wonder if you can No greed or hunger A brotherhood of man.
Imagine all the people Sharing all the world You may say I'm a dreamer But I'm not the only one I hope some day you'll join us And all the world will live as one.
hard-left programme hidden in the cotton-wool is a deliberate Owen lie. Unfortunately.
Nevertheless we do not live in the world of John Lennon's make believe. Votes are important, but the class stroggle is absolutely central.
It is scandalous for the Labour leadership to respond to Thatcher's aggressive knuckle-duster Toryism with whinings and vague yearnings for a different world. They express a yearning for a Britain that is 'one nation' and for social peace instead of aggressively lining up on our side of the class war, and that is unforgiveable. The miners on the television news with blood streaming down their faces live in the real Tory Britain of 1984.
Labour needs to get its PR right - and the leaders responsible for it into line with the feelings and interests of the rank and file. It needs to get its feet back on the ground.
Politics isn't act, Neil.