May 26 action
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-06-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
come out in favour of a programme of European conventional rearmament as LIVERPOOL muity is dra £2 from Andy Pink, Central Support ›ool City Council, Dale St, Liverpool Sue Arnall reports from Rochdale MAY 24 was International Women's Day for Peace and the women's peace groups in the Rochdale area decided to mark it by a symbolic sit-in at the Army Recruitment Office in the centre of Rochdale.
It was to be a low-key affair at lunch-time to fit in with job commitments.
We wanted to draw attention to the army's constant presence in our midst and militarism, as well as protest against nuclear weapons.
We had prepared a statement explaining this. We baked a cake in the shape of a woman-sign and took song sheets and guitar along. There were 19 of us with about four toddlers in push chairs.
We walked into the recruiting office at 12.30 pm, and one of us read our prepared statement explaining our purpose and that we would leave at 1 pm. The soldier at the desk looked embarrassed and surprised. but we seemed fairly harmless as we began to sing peace songs, weave a web, and share out our cake.
We had got to about the third song when two policemen came They called reinforcements and then began carrying us out onto the pavement.
My little one started to cry, but otherwise no voice was raised as one by one we left or were dragged. We carried on giving out leafiets on the pavement but the police began to get heavy.
We were told to move on, and those who resisted were thrown into the waiting transit van. Seven women in all were arrested, and one small child.
The rest of us were threatened with arrest if we didn't disperse, and we were given no indication of the charges or time to take details of our sisters who'd been arrested. Nearly four hours later they were released, charged with obstruction, to appear in court on Friday June 1.
This heavy response to what was clearly i symbolic. unthreatening event is quite surprising. In the past. Greenham support actions have been met in Rochdale by i cool, tolerant police presence. Certainly my four year old learne i telline lesson about the nature of the British Bobby!
Scan page 10
Socialist Organiser No.182 June 7 1984 Page 10 -Interview with Peter Tatchelli defence! PT: The Labour Party has to come up with credible radical alternatives which act as some thing positive to put in place of the existing system. That applies in defence just as much as to the health service, education or industry.
It's very easy to be negative ind oppositionist, simply to ppose nuclear weapons and •ppose NATO - but to win those debates you have to coine up with a radical practical alternative.
I think the basic reason we haven't won the unilateral argument is that man! people, rightly or wrongly, fcar that without the Bomb we'd be left defenceless and vulnerable.
JB: What should we be defending and against what?
PT: We would be defending the right of British people to determine their own future, the right of self-determination which all nations and all peoples have.
It isn't a nationalistic argument. It's saying that all peoples and all countries ought to be free in determine their future free from foreign or internal dictat. IB: Would a citizen's army be separated from the State? "1: No, we need a radical reform : aristing military institutions, i the same way as the Swedish, »i iss and Yugoslav labour movements have achieved.
IB: But that's still within the framework of capitzlism. Surely the fight against tascism, evell during World War 2, must include a fight against our own bourgeoisie? Fascism is not something separate from capitalism. Can you develop a citizen's army which is based on the self-organisation of workers, women, the black community, and the defence of their demands, within the present state structures?
PT: Yes, I believe you can. Peter Tatchell is currently 1 defence. He talked to Judit Sweden, Switzerland and Yugoslavia have similar social structures to our own, but through the historic structures of the labour movement they have won a radical democratisation of military power. It's not perfect but they now have achieved a system of defence which is basically nonprovocative and non-threatening. It is not dependent on nuclear weapons, and it does not rely upon power alliances or foreign bases on their soil.
JB: I don't think you can compare those countries to Britain -a major imperialist power. PT: They are actually practical examples of West European countries where the labour movement has made a conscious decision to oppose foreign military alliances and bases and nuclear weapons.
Those countries made a conscious choice. They could easily have ended up as part of NATO, having nuclear weapons. But they chose, and won the majority of people to their side by posing a radical alternative based on territorial defence by a citizen's army.
There's no reason why such a system could not be applied in Britain if we persuade enough people that it is necessary? JB: Whom are you trying to persuade? Do you believe that the Generals and the military would peacefully allow it? Remember, •Kitson has developed counter-insurgency tactics. PT: Some very high people in the British Defence Establishment, much as they hanker after the glorious days of Empire, see that dependence on the US and reliance on nuclear weapons is suicidal. Like Lord Carver. I don't riting a book on non-nuclear • Bonner from SO. agree with 90% of what he advocates, but he recognises now that our nuclear policy is mad.
That aspect of his arguments is progressive.
JB: Yes, nuclear weapons are the most abhorrent system of warfare to be developed, but the generals who are opposing the use of nuclear weapons are still in favour of crushing the El Salvadorean liberation struggle, napalming in Vietnam, bombing out the PLO and supporting British troops in Ireland. They want to defend their social system against the liberation struggles or socialists.
I think it is dangerous to side with those people.
PT: I'm not siding with them. It's a fact that more people in the military establishment are recognising the dangers of nuciear war and are looking at alternatives.
That's a concrete effect of the efforts of the peace movement and we have to push them further.
JB: But who will actually prevent nuclear war? Who will stop the production of nuclear weaponry? Who will stop that military machinery?
PT: It's possible at certain points in history radical ideas can come from the military. Look at the Portuguese revolution in 1974 and the British army in World War II.
JB: But in Portugal rank and file soldiers turned bayonets on their officers.
PT: There were officers involved.
JB: Due to the rank and file soldiers' pressure. That leads on to your points about extension of liberties and democratisation the armed forces.
Two demands are not present in your examples of citizens' armies: the right to strike and the right to disobey.
PT: I don't hold those up as ideal examples. I'm showing there are examples where quite radical democratic reforms have been achieved and they are happening in societies similar to our own. By citing these examples I'm showing that my idea is not a pie-in-thesky alternative but has some prospect of being achievable.
In fact, in Sweden, they have the right to strike and co-determination between officers and men. Officers have to consult with lower ranks before implementing policy and decisions. It doesn't apply in battle.
JB: By defence we mean defence of working class lives and interests. The military mean defending the bosses - their countries and their interests. How do we get from defence as defence of "the country" to them defending themselves as the working class against attacks not just by fascists or anti-gay bigots, but by the bosses too.
PT: This strategy is trying to move in that direction. Ordinary people, as opposed to a standing army, ought to have the right to defend themselves and their com• munities and their interests.
But we have to transform the existing military apparatus to the way we want it, not set up a parallel or rival.
I want a self-reliant, non imperialist defence strategy which is non-provocative and non-threat ening to other states - whicl does not rely upon the US o upon nuclear weapons.
We ought to reconstruct inter national relations on the basis o: equality and partnership, not or an imperialist basis of subjuga tion and exploitation. JB: You would not be protecting the interests of the British state and bosses?
PT: Look at Sweden. It is not in its international relations such a rapacious exploiter of countries as it once was.
JB: But exploitation exists. Sweden has big foreign investments. It's just that they can rely on the US to keep them safe. PT: But that's a separate question. I'm arguing for a democratisation of one area of the state, the military apparatus. Some people say we should not be trying to reform a militaristic capitalist state.
Yet the labour movement tries to reform other aspects of the state. The left supports all types of reforms. A workers' militia: Russia 1917 JB: You are divorcing the military from the state. "Reforming" the •state must mean challenging the existing structures by struggling for alternatives.
Take policing for example. Why is it that workers, the black community "policing" to defend women throw up their own themselves? The working class have very opposed sets of answers to the police about what needs defending. Your citizens' army idea doesn't take these up. PT: Look at what has been achieved in the Netherlands, Sweden, the Leninist left said none of this would be achieved. The capitalist state would never allow it. But on the contrary, by the labour movement winning majority support, these changes have occurred.
----- pull-quotes -----
NO CRUISE NO NATO