Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Socialism and war

Socialist Organiser no. 182, 7 June 1984 · scan pp. 10–11 · Clive Bradley · about 876 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

WARS don't happen simply because political leaders are vicious people. Historically, wars have occured for different reasons, depending upon the kind of society.

A system based upon the ownership and produce of land. for example, generated wars between rival landlords, competing for land.

Under capitalism, too. wars are rooted in competition -but a competition based on profit.

The driving force of capitalism is the accumulation of profit. In their search for profit, the capitalists need to grab sources of raw materials, markets for their goods, and new areas to invest in. For. the most developed capitalist countries, their own internal markets are nowhere near big enough.

The First and Second World Wars were fundamentally about the big capitalist powers competing with each other to grab colonies and areas for economic domination.

Since World War 2, with the US super-dominant, conflicts between the big capitalist powers have been muted. And most colonies have won independence. But capitalism continues to generate war.

Some 300 wars have been fought since 1945. Big capitalist powers like the US, UK and France have been involved in many of them. Britain has been at war somewhere or other in the world every year since 1945.

None of those wars have been anything to do with a threat to the ordinary people of the US, UK or France.

Capitalism's drive for profit not only explains the rivalry between the capitalist countries, but also their fundamental hostility to the so-called "communist' countries. Because the capitalists are largely excluded from the massive markets of Russia, China, Eastern Europe, etc., the world they can plunder has shrunk.

They talk about defending the 'free world' against attack by the USSR. But such people's love of freedom goes as far as their love of profit. Where a profit can be made, they don't care what regime rules. South Africa, the Shah's iran, South Korea, Chile, El Salvador - all are or were acceptable.

The so-called 'communist' states are totalitarian police states (apart from Cuba, which has a milder. but still far from democratic system). But that is not the reason for the capitalist powers' hostility to them. The hostility is based on the fact that those states are not capitalist. They rest on a different economic system.

The ruling bureaucrats are every bit as vicious as the Western capitalist classes. They do seek to expand their power. their prestige. and their revenues. But what the capitalists defend is not freedom. but profit-making.

We believe the nationalised property relations and planned economy in the USSR and similar states should be defended against imperialism. But we do not believe people should be trapped by a choice between the two power blocs. There is a link between the struggle of the workers in the West against the ruling class here, and the battles of the workers in the East trying to rid themselves of their bureaucratic overlords.

Capitalist wars are nearly always waged for reactionary ends. and socialists need to resolutely oppose them. But, in the past - and sometimes still today in countries that are denied national independence by other. stronger, countries - wars can be for progressive, liberating ends.

Genuine anti-colental wars. even it led be capitals or would-be capitalists, can and should be supported by socialists. because: potentially. they add to the cause of human

If 'our' ruling class is

oppressing another people we have to fight against 'our' ruling class and for the armies of the oppressed, if their cause is just. That's why socialists should support Irish republicans against British imperialism, and the FMLN against the US-backed regime in El Salvador.

Socialism - genuine working class socialism, not the caricature created by the bureaucrats of the USSR -can abolish war.

Aggression may at some level be a constant element in human nature, or it may not be. Scientists can argue about that. But for sure social conditions determine whether that aggression is expressed in individual scuffles or in world wars killing millions.

All wars have been fundamentally motivated by the drive for gain of ruling classes or groups. Abolish ruling classes, create a society of cooperation, and ensure a decent living for all, and you like away the fundamental "ilse t nell but war cannot be abolished ita! hr wishing for that.

Wi have to lake and

defeat the ruling class. And

the military power that they possess will not just lie down and die if the bosses' system is seriously threatened by the working class.

To overthrow capitalism. we may well have to fight a civil war' - the working class, to defeat the capitalists and their state, will need to be armed and prepared to fight.

LABOUR MOVEMENT CONFERENCE ON TURKEY Saturday September 22, from 10.30 at NUR headquarters, Unity House, Euston Rd, London NW1.

Called by Clare Short MP, Richard Caborn MP, Chris Smith MP, Jeremy Corbyn MP, Ernie Roberts MIP, Bi Michie MP, and Roland Boyes MP.

Five delegates per labour movement body: credentials f2 (50p unwaged) from 'Turkey conference', 129 Seven Sisters Rd, London N7.

Scan page 11

Socialist Organiser No. 184 June 7 1984 Page 11 The regimes the US props up: the ruling classes in Saudi Arabia, above, and NO CRUISE NO NATO )

----- pull-quotes -----

Arguing for Socialism

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 182

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →