Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Their lau and ours

Socialist Organiser no. 184, 21 June 1984 · scan p. 6 · about 515 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

IN THEIR operation against the miners' strike, the police have effectively been making up their own laws and imposing them by sheer force.

What is the answer to this? Who polices the police? Who can stop 'the law' breaking the law?

Laws never fall from the sky. They are generated by the structure and the ruling interests of the society they exist in. Law is class law.

In feudal society law was based on and mixed up with a social hierarchy. Feudal ownership of a particular arez of land went together with legal authority over the peasants on that land.

Bourgeois law' - the law of capitalist society - is, in contrast, based on the axiom of laws before which all individual citizens are formally equal, just as they are formal. ly equal in the marketplace.

But bourgeois law, too, is ruling-class law. Formally, the law guarantees the right of everyone to make millions by exploiting the labour of others. In practice it protects the right of a small wealthy minority to do so.

Besides their property laws, that small wealthy minority makes many other laws to protect their position -laws against strikes, pickets, protests, demonstrations.

How many such laws they have, and how strictly they are enforced, is a matter of the balance of class forces.

Between 1799 and 1824 trade unions were illegal in Britain. Between 1901 and 1906 any union calling strike action could be sued for crippling damages.

A law passed in 1927 severely restricted trade unionism until 1946. During World War 2 and until 1951 most strikes were illegal.

Sea 'Justice' never had anything to do with it. The working class has always had what rights it could win and defend by struggle - and no more. - It does make a difference for the labour movement Whether new laws are introduced by parliament or by police decree. The parliamentary method offers wider scope for pressure by the working class.

But as far as the ruling class is concerned the two methods are two sides of the same coin.

A parliamentary government has been planning, directing, and defending the police's 'law by decree' operation against the miners. And that government is currently promoting a Police and Criminal Evidence Bill which will transform some of that law by police decree into law by parliamentary vote.

First the police establish the law by sheer force. Then parliament ratifies it.

But that process can be reversed - as when working class action made the Tory Industrial Relations Act unusable, and the Labour government then followed up by repealing it in parliament.

This miners' strike could lead to a whole new series of laws being imposed to hamstring the trade union movement - by police decree and/ or by parliamentary vote.

Or it could lead to the Tories' present anti-union laws being wiped off the statute books.

It all depends on the strength, scope, vigour and determination of the working class resporise. Even 8000 riot police are no match for millions of trade unionists -if the movement mobilises them.

Brent Miners' Solidarity Com

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 184

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →