Police out of the coalfields
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-06-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
The job of organising the strike from within Notts ice Committees have criticised the police operation.
George Moores, chair of the South Yorkshire Police Committee has said: "There is no doubt that the police can be blamed for a lot of the violence that occurred on the picket line" , and added: "If I had to sum up what was most worrying, I would say that it was the concept of national policies that are carried out by police officers, without any legal standing whatsoever. Here we have state repression against peopothers did not resist.
While two policemen held him, another pulled his hair, then punched him in the face, held his head in an arm lock, and forced his nead up so that the photograph could be taken.
Arrested miners have also been subjected to political and personal questioning: girl friend's names, any debts they have, political affiliations, what they think of Arthur Scargill, which way they voted in union and in national elections. etc.
Post Office Engineering Union officials have said that many members of the NUM are having their phones tapped.
LAW No.4: Any miner attending a large demonstration and picket, and. known to be a militant, is liable to be arrested.
When we pointed this out This is done by trained 'snatch squads'. . As Miller and Walker report, "the men who are arrested by this strategy are picked out not because they are suspected of any offence but because they are a civil matter over which the prominent union officers or police had no jurisdiction, he activists or because they have had some personal confrontation with a police officer at occasions to allow the miners some other time during the strike...
Eventually, having been [In one case] it could be seen cleariy [on TV film] how [plain-clothes police among the pickets] pushed a cial pickets' (a term he never miner from within the picket defined) through the line but only after each of them had to the front so that other officers could arrest him" had their names and creden tials thoroughly checked an Although the police operarecorded, and only on condi tion against the miners' strike tion that they made no is unprecedented as a whole, attempt actually to speak to many parts of it do have prean LAW No.3 to my " miner cedents, and the whole thing has been carefully prepared arrested is photographed and foI.
Roadblocks preventing According to Miller and free movement were, for exWalker "There are no laws ample, used around Greenle who are on the whole most moderate in their attitudes"
South Yorkshire has made a decision that extra policing costs arising from the strike should be found from the existing budget. A similar decision has been taken on Merseyside, and the result is that these police forces have had to cut down on building programmes, new equipment, etc.
These protests are useful, but not adequate to the situation.
As Miller and Walker point out, "The power of Police ing picket tactic by miners and building workers that According to Miller and Walker, "A Times report of March 19 1984 suggests that the Centre has been activated on at least three occasions since 1972, including the 1981 riots in oxteth and Brixton"
The Special Patrol Groups and other special police units were initiated in 1965 .under a Labour government, like the 1968 incident.
They developed most rapidly under the 1970-4 Tory government. But there was no move to disband them under the 1974-9 Labour government. On the contrary New units were established..
At the end of Labour's term of office, just before the 1979 general election, Special Patrol Group men killed antifascist demonstrator Blair Peach in Southall The new police methods also borrow her ly from Northern Ireland experience. Kenneth Newman, currently chief of the Metropolitan Police and thus Britain's top policeman, was previousiy chief of the Royal Ulster Constabulary: A miner who has served with the British Army in Northern Ireland told Socialist Organiser two weeks ago:
"I was thrown against the fence, army style. I know how it's done because I've done it myself in Ireland -put the arms up, legs kicked apart, searched and questioned... The police here now are using the same methods that we trained the B Special police in Northern Ireland for"
And that was under our government, too. Committees... is limited. However, there can be little doubt thai the Chief Constables... could have been called on publicly to account for their actions during this dispute.
The Committees do have the power to sack their Chief Constables, even if this is subject to the agreement of the Home Secretary. Such an action would, at least, have drawn attention to the lack of public accountability with which Chief Constables operate generally...
Police committees in every area could also call on their Chief Constables to withdraw from the National Recording Centre operation.
•Such demands have been raised by Labour Party campaigners, but the councillors on the police committees still remain very reluctant to speak out. There was a similar experience in Merseyside over the Toxteth riots: the police committee expressed concern about police operations, but shied away from any suggestion of no confidence in Chief Constable Kenneth Oxford.
The policy of collaboration with the police hierarchy, both by Labour councils and by Labour governments, has allowed the creation behind the scenes of a National Riot Police. It is high time that the collaboration was broken.
Labour should commit itself to:
* Disbandment of special forces like the Special Patrol Groups, Instant Response Units, Special Branch, MIS ete, Putting all police forces under the control of elected local councils, which should have power to hire, fire and instruct police chiefs.
* Effectively using such powers.
The police hierarchy -soaked in authoritarian and Tory ideology - will not submit quietly to such accountability. A determined drive by the labour movement to stop the police being used as antipicket shock troops would probably lead to open defiance by the police hierarchy, and compel Labour to look to the radical alternative of disbanding the existing police structure to replace it by organised labour movement/ community patrols.