Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

John Fernandes story

Socialist Organiser no. 185, 28 June 1984 · scan p. 9 · about 987 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Arcii-Digot Ian l'aisley got 36% of tie Protestant fust preference vote Police in Southall. Although investigations after the killing of Blair Peach showed that police were keeping 'unofficial' deadly weapons in their lockers, no-one was ever prosecuted. Photo: John Sturrock Report Interna tional-' Colin Waugh looks at a new pamphlet, 'Police Racism and Union Collusion: the John Fernandes Case, from the National Convention of Black Teac ers (fI), and at the issues behind this case of a lecturer sacked for exposing racism among police cadets HENDON Police School stands in the Tory-controlled outer London borough of Barnet. However, the nearest ordinary further education college is part of Kilburn Polytechnic, which comes under Brent.

Until recently, nearly 30 lecturers from the Poly were permanently based at the Police School, servicing (among other things) a course for cadets.

After the uprisings of 1981, and in line with a recommendation in the Scarman Report, a "multi-cultural' unit was introduced onto this course, and the staff involved, reprecontine shant nna third of Brent's employees on the site, elected John Fernandes, a black teacher with eight years' experience at the Police School site, to coordinate it.

From the start, they were agreed that their aim in designing and running this 'multicultural' element should in fact be to counteract racism which they knew to be widespread among the cadets.

In the summer of 1982, the head of the Police School, Commander Richard Wells, who has since become Deputy Assistant Commissioner of the Metropolitan Police, intervened to exclude the multicultural unit from the course and replace it with a unit on 'decision-making' to be taught by police instructors rather than by civilian staff from Kilburn.

John and his colleagues on the multicultural unit fought hard to prevent this. In the course of doing so, they tried to convince Wells of the necessity for anti-racist teaching by OLET - 8608 The Kurdish people exist as minorities drawing to his attention essays written by cadets which included such comments as "can a 12-bore shotgun blast a black man into tiny pieces at 12 yards?" and "do black people burn better with oil or petrol on them?"

• However, Wells was unwill. ing for such evidence to be discussed, so that by the midautumn of 1982 John felt that the only thing left was to release the essays to the media. They were eventually publicised on the Channel Four programme Eastern Eye.

Despite the fact that no cadets' names were given, and despite the fact that the programme gave Wells ample opportunity to have his say, his next action was to give John two hours to get off the premises.

More surprisingly, his employer, the London borough of Brent, which at that time was Labour-controlled, ordered its staff at the Police School not to go into work there until he was reinstated.

In other words, the struggle looked winnable, especially since editorials favourable to John began to appear in the Guardian.

However, this would be to reckon without the role of NATHE's leadership, both at a local level in Brent and nationally in terms both of officials and of lay members of the National Executive. It was not long before the union's machinery was brought into action — against John Fernandes. Fawzi Ibrahim, the Regional Secretary, who, like John, was also on the Brent Liaison Committee, managed to discover a short break in John's contributions.

The Regional Official, Geoff Brass, arranged for a new course to be set up purely within the Police School, on the basis of a 'questionnaire' conducted without the existing branch's knowledge, and with the obvious effect of isolating John from his support in the existing branch as a whole.

Instead of the issue being treated as one of principle, John was offered casework.

Meanwhile, rather than forming an alliance with the Labour council against the Police School management, NATFHE's leadership entered into talks with that management themselves, while simultaneously going to the media to accuse John of 'gross professional misjudgment' They attempted to justify this behaviour by claiming that the whole episode was smokescreen behind which Brent was manoeuvring to make staff redundant. In other words, a 'trade union issue' was wheeled in to hide their unwillingness to support a black member over the issue of anti-racism • and academic There then followed a period of struggle within NATFHE at the level of Outer London Regional Council and at the National Conference. This struggle is still going on, though it may show how the Left has been weakened by the Socialist Workers Party's withdrawal from College Rank and File.

At the local level, the result of the leadership's behaviour has basically been that those who supported John have been relocated to other work in Brent, while those who went in to work against Brent's instructions have been transferred to the employ of Barnet, along with all civilian servicing of the Police School.

More recently, one of these lecturers has brought a complaint against the officers of Kilburn branch under NATFHE's Rule 8 ("bringing the union into disrepute"), and the national leadership has allowed this to go forward to a tribunal. However, a vigorous campaign by anti-racists was rewarded when the tribunal decided that there was no case to answer.

This pamphlet was written before this most recent turn of events. It gives an account of events trom 1982 in some RRY IDE 40020 detail, quoting many relevant documents, and also tries to place the whole affair in a theoretical context.

It argues that the whole concept of 'multicultural' (as opposed to anti-racist) teaching, along with the increasingly fashionable courses in 'racism awareness', is itself racist, because it fails to treat racism as a power relationship in which whites seek to oppress Since there are many teachers, including on the Left, who still see multicultural studies as at least potentially progressive, it would be well worth getting hold of this book.

an

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 185

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →