[Arguing for ary system resting mainly on conmainly…]
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-07-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Arguing for ary system resting mainly on conmainly on coercion.
It is only a difference of form - but it is an important difference for the working elass, because it is the difference between some (even if restricted) legal possibility of trade union and political organisation, or none at all.
Even the most democratic of capitalist democracies uses violence against the working class. But there is still a difference between that and a full-fledged police state.
(And it's politically dangerous to blur the differences and to say, for example, that Britain today is a police state. Between battering pickets at Orgreave and making all trade ¿ unions illegal there is qualitative difference. And if we say that Britain Is already a police state, then if and when our rulers do: move towards a real police state we will be left like the little boy who cried wolf too, often. mainiy on consent, then can't it LI a parliamentary system rests be changed simply by educating people and eventually voting a socialist majority into Parliament that will steer the state in a different direction?
No - and not only because "socialist' MPs so often cease to be socialists when they become MPs. Even a socialist party with full democratic control over its representatives could not overthrow the power of the top five per cent as easily as that.
As Karl Marx put it, "the working class cannot simply lay hold of the ready-made state machinery, and wield it for its own purposes"
The existing state machine is fashioned as a tool for the rule of a minority over the majority. A completely different structure is required for the self-rule of the majority by the majority.
Marx and Engels identified three key features of working class power, from the example of the Paris Commune of 1871.
The standing army and the police were replaced by a workers militia directly based on the working-class community: And:
rule "In the first place, it filled all [official] posts by election on the basis of universal suffrage of all concerned, subject to the right of recall at any time by the same electors. And, in the second place, all officials, high or low, were paid only the wages received by other workers"
The soviets (workers' councils) in revolutionary Russia, before the Stalinist counter-revolution, were a more developed model of these principles.
So the state machine would need to be completely broken up and estructured. Neither the chiefs of big business, nor the top people of the state machine themselves, would allow that to happen peacefully.
A parliamentary government trying to carry out socialist measures - or even radical reforms far short of socialism - would probably meet the same sort of response as the Allende government in Chile got from the Chilean army.
It is foolish to imagine that Britain is different and it could not happen here. There are probably quite a few miners with sore heads today who thought Orgreave could never happen here.
Lord Carver, former chief of the British army, has revealed that in 1974, "fairly senior officers" were talking about a military coup in Britain.
In 1914 a Liberal government in Britain, trying to introduce not socialism but only Home Rule for Ireland, fáced direct revolt from the officers of the British Army.
The state machine will have to be defeated and broken up in struggle. It's a daunting prospect. should concentrate • On electioneering instead. Now, in combination with Militant they have launched a political attack on us within the support committee and voted me out as convenor.
But we held a successful Socialist Organiser meeting with 30 to 40 miners present, and we've produced Socialist Organiser miners' strike bulletins which have been well received. There is now a small circle of miners around us interested in establishing a rank and file caucus."
Jill Mountford adds: "Women's Fightback in Stoke has been doing a lot of work with the miners' wives' committee, and we've found a. very good response."
Durham Tony Serjeant and Gary Scott report from Durham: •This has been a traditionally moderate area, but the strike is very strong. There is a large number of support groups, each covering a small area, and they have been raising food and money to keep the strike going."
From Scotland Socialist Houston reports:
Organiser had a problem in not having comrades in the mining areas and not having our own transport. Also, inimeeting at the NUM special conference in Sheffield."
Coventry:
¿Jean Lane and Julia Redman report from Coventry: "The work. has been mainly round the Keresley pit, just outside Coventry. There is a strike support committee in Coventry, but Trades Council control has been something of a dead hand on it."
Birmingham Jim Denham from Birmingham reports similar problems with the official trade union structure being a hindrance to solidarity activity. "Nevertheless, there has been a lot of activity in Birmingham right from the start of the strike. The city has been used as a convenient base for picketing in the Midlands by miners from Were South Wales, eranging we ve accommodation and support for them. What we can do here is basically limited only by the small size of the SO group."
Northampton In Northampton, Dave Green reports, "A support committee was set up after the Kent miners came through the town on their march to the Midlands. 'There's been a good attendance, and lots of activity, but we've had political problems with the Communist so few and so isolated t they need a lot of suppr and not much money been coming in to Lek tershire from outside."
Carditt Geoff Williams rep from Cardiff: "The SO grc has put a lot of work into support committtee. problem has been the Wa TUC: they called a day action, but, with all th resources, put less work it it than we did. The crur Issue now is Llanwern: wi be another Orgreave?"
York York, reports Mary Mo son, has no pits very near the nearest is Selby. "And regional day of action wa complete flop here. But th is a miners' support comn tee, and regular collecti nave been started at some 1 tories."
Manchester In Manchester, • Iepc Tony Dale, unlike ma ¡other places; "the Labr Party has had a very pi record on the strike. ] there is a support committ I'he main contacts have bi with Bold, the most milit of the Lancashire pits.
We think there is a pos: ility of a campaign n round the issue of the poli focusing on the role of M chester's Chief Consta James Anderton."