Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Behind the Sikh revolt

Socialist Organiser no. 186, 5 July 1984 · scan p. 9 · Colin Foster · about 2,085 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Colin Foster looks at the conflict in the Punjab.

THE Indian Army is still rounding up Sikhs by the hundred in Punjab, and some 4,000 are being held in detention. About 100 are reported to have been killed in scattered clashes since the seizure by the Army of the Sikhs' holy places in Amritsar on June 6, when over 1000 were killed.

The Army is still occupying the holy places.

Up, to 5,000 Sikhs in the Army have mutinied or deserted, and one Hindu general was killed by his Sikh troops in early June. Meanwhile Sikhs overseas have declared an independent Sikh state' of Khalistan in Punjab.

Communal strife, and conflicts between the central government and local administrations, have been common in India ever since independence. With a population one-and-a-half-times the whole of Europe, and a huge variety of languages and ethnic groups, India would be difficult to keep unified under the best of conditions.

The terrible poverty of the mass of the population and the huge inequalities between rich and poor; the cynical use of communal or religious rallyingcries by capitalist politicians; the bureaucratism and corruption of the Indian state; and the inadequacy of the parties based on the working class, have fuelled the fires of communalism.

Although India is officially a secular state, assertion of Indian national identity is often mixed up with assertion of the Hindu majority religion.

Indira Ghandi. reactionary repression.

Sikhs demonstrating in Punjab The two main partics based in the working class - the Moscow line Communist Party of India and the breakaway Communist Party of India (Marxist) - have generally tailed the capitalist parties, the CPI lining up behind the ruling Congress (1) and the CPI(M) behind the Janata opposition.

The Congress (1) government has tried to blame the Sikh agitation on foreign, specifically Pakistani, agents. All the evidence is, however, that the Sikh communalist agitation had a genuine mass base.

It is not a simple issue of an oppressed minority up against a bureaucratic central government.

There are about 12 million Sikhs in India. Two-thirds of them Live in Punjab, where they are just over half the population. Ihey are distinguished from the Punjabi Hindus not ethnically or by language, but onlyaby their religion, a l6th century breakaway from Hinduism incorporating elements from Islam.

Punjab is the wealthiest (OI least poor) state in the Indian federation, and Sikhs generally are better off than the average in India. Many leading positions in the national life of India are held by Sikhs, and they are between 10% and 15% of the Army (as against only 2% of the general population).

Many of the Sikh communalists' demands are demands for privileges rather than against oppression. For example, they demand that the proportion of Sikhs in the Indian Army - which has been steadily and deliberately reduced from 27% at independence - should be maintained.

The 45 demands of the Sikh communalists - originally formulated in 1973, but heavily campaigned for only over the last two or three years - also include:

* Autonomy for Punjab * Making the city of Chandi garh, at present the common capi tal of Punjab and of Haryana, the capital of Punjab alone.

* A single all-India administration for the Sikh temples. (At present Sikh temples outside Punjab are often controlled by Congress supporters. The revenues of the temples are very large).

* Reallocation of the water supply in the region in favour of Punjab as against other states. .

* A new law of inheritance for Sikhs, so that only the elder son can inherit and land does not get divided up.

* Revision of the clause in the Indian constitution which defines Sikhs as a sub-category of Hindus.

* Radio transmissions of the Sikh sacred texts.

The central government has made concessions on many of these demands. But all of them correspond to the interests of the Sikh propertied classes_rather than the workers and the smallest farmers.

It is difficult to see a socialist. or democratic case for the demand for a separate Sikh state. Given that Punjab combines Sikhs and non-Sikhs in almost equal numbers, the demand would surely mean eithèr Sikh oppression of the Hindus (and Muslims) in Punjab, and/or huge population movements.

According to an article by Harish Puri in the Bombay Economic and Political Weekly, the roots of the problem go back to the last century.

When Indian soldiers mutinied against the British colonial commanders in 1857, the Sikh troops remained loyal. After 1857, the British followed a deliberate policy of fostering a separate Sikh identity, and recruiting their Indian Army mainly from the Sikhs and other so-called 'martial races rather than the population in general.

Sikhs, Hindus, and Muslims ir Punjab. "The foundations of par tition politics were laid precisely in Punjab in the 1920s."

After independence the Indian bourgeoisie continued on the sordid path blazed by the British.

"Hindus of virtually all political hues stoked the fire of communalism... The Congress Party in its game of power politics made unprincipled compromises, and instead of fighting communalism, it in fact strengthened the latent communalism in both communities.

Despite all this, conflicts between Sikhs and Hindus remained slight compared to those between Hindus and Muslims. In 1966 Punjab was separated off, as a state within the Indian tederation, from neighbouring Haryana - but the new Punjabi state was defined on the basis of language and culture, not religion.

When questioned about the demand for a 'Sikh homeland' the leader of the main Sikh party at the time replied: "The demand will die for good. It was a useless demand and has practically fizzled out".

Two factors, however, revived Sikh separatism.

The first was cynical manipulation by the Congress party.

The main Sikh party, the Akali Dal, had "a leadership_ and support based among farmers who were threatened by the Congress policy of land reforms" . During the mid and late 1970s it allied with the anti-Congress opposition on an all-India level. Congress responded by covertly fostering.

and aiding the more extreme Sikh communalists against the Akali Dal.

The second and more fundamental was economic development.

Punjab after 1966 was the centre of the 'Green Revolution' in India - a rapid increase in agricultural productivity. This made quite a few people rich -but many more stayed poor.

"The ratio of landless workeIS in the total agricultural workforce rose from -17.3% in 1961 to 32.1% in 1971 ... 24% of the small farmers and 31% of the marginal farmers lived according to a recent study below the poverty line"

In the absence of an adequate working class party, communaiism became the way in which the tensions arising from this economic turmoil were expressed One "clash of economic interests" is "spelled out in terms of a clash between Hindu trader and Sikh farmer"

Also: "In the urban areas the trading castes among Sikhs operate at a lower level as compared with Hindu traders... The Sikh trading castes... find in religious symbols the only way of defending their own trade interests... The (moderate Sikh) leadership appeared to them to be a champion of the cause of the agricultural castes which was little bothered about the urban Sikh's plight".

For both Sikh propertied classes, farmers and traders, communalism was also a way of diverting the growing Sikh proletariat from class politics.

But India today has an industrial working class 18 million strong. Dockers, jute workers, and textile workers have recently had huge strikes.

Class politics show the only way out. Given the tradition of relatively harmonious relations, it seems likely that a programme of limited religious rights - without supporting demands for Sikh privilege or a separate Sikh state - could be a basis for reconciling Sikh and Hindu workers and peasants within a common class struggle.

But opposition to Sikh communalism' cannot mean support for the current repression by the central government. The Congress (I) has a large part in the responsibility for the rise of communal divisions, and the repression is very likely to make those divisions deeper and more embittered. -Afghanistan THE USSR offensive which began in late April against Afghan rebel forces in the Panjshir valley, in north-east Afghanistan, seems to have been no great success.

The USSR forces are occupying about one third of the Panjshir valley area, but there was never any doubt about their ability to do that.

Reports indicate that the USSR offensive did not succeed in crushing the rebel forces based in the area - which retreated without offering battle. Their chances of maintaining control of the area for any length of time are therefore small. An occupying force in such terrain is extremely vulnerable to guerilla harassment.

An interview published last month in the Paris daily Le Monde gives some picture of conditions in the USSR army of occupation.

Five deserters and one prisoner from the USSR army, aged between 19 and 21, spoke to a journalist from a Us government financed radio station. The source of the interview makes it possible that it has been painted up, but the substance of it is in line with independent reports.

It is quite common, the soldiers said, for conscripts to ask to be sent to Afghanistan. The newspapers in the USSR describe the occupying army as building houses, nurseries and schools, and occasionally helping the Afghan army put down "bandits' 'So why not? They think that maybe they will bring back some medals, and be able to buy stuff that they can't get at home"

The reality is different. Casualties are heavy, And.

"You are not very well fed in Afghanistan... The veterans take all the butter and bread from the rookies, and besides it's very bad quality bread.

The soldiers live 30 or 40 to a tent. You don't have any underwear, the bedding is never changed, and it is practically impossible to get a wash. The young soldiers are constantly dirty and hungry.

Their pay is confiscated by the veterans, too.

As for the officers, they live in cottages, three or four to a room. They are better fed, with their own special canteen. They also have their own baths"

Divisions between nationalities are consciously manipulated by the military hierarchy.

"For example, the commander first take some Russians, and USSR soldier în Afghanistan then in the next contingent some Turcomans. The Kussian veterans rule the roost and the Turcomans are their victims.

Une year later, the Kussians are demobbed and the commander chooses a new company of Russians. The new recruits become the victims of the Turcomans who are now veterans and who have been 'educated' by the treatment they received from the previous draft...

That way, there is no cohesion among the soldiers, it is everyone Collective demands o prote are no As for the officers, the soldiers hate them all, with only rare exceptions"

To improve their miserable conditions, the soldiers steal both food from the Afghan people and equipment and arms from the army - which they sell for food or for hashish and cocaine.

Tie brutality of the USSR army towards the Afghan people also sickened these soldiers. Vladimir Naumov describes an Afghan prisoner being strapped over a cannon mouth and blown to bits, in a repetition of what the British Army did to captured rebels in the Indian Mutiny of 1857.

Igor Rykov says: "We don't take any prisoners of war. Generally the prisoners are killed on the spot...

One day we arrived in a village where there were only women, old men; and children... [The officer gave the order to put them in one room and throw grenades at them"

Vladimir Naumov again: "Everyone knows the "scorched earth' tactic. That's what we use in Afghanistan, with the aid of technology.

Our principal, weapon is air force, especially the MI-8 MI-24 helicopters...

Napalm is used a lot in Afghanistan. The artillery shells are mainly of the fragmentation type. Aerial bombs, each of which contains 30 or 40 little bombs, are also used a lot. That sort of bomb kills everyone within a radius of one kilometre"

Much of the story is horribly familiar. The casual brutality towards the local population, the acute demoralisation in the ranks, the blundering, ponderous way in which everything is done, all recall the US in Vietnam.

And, all qualifications granted,: there is a real parallel. A modern, high-technology war machine is venting its destructive force on an oppressed people - and learning that technology alone is not enough to win a war.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 186

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →