Expand our
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-07-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
-Picketing al-Ravenscraig steelworks. Photo: Rick Matthews, IFL.
Tony Benn. (Photo: John Harris)
Continued from p.12 I tell you candidly - if what we did between 1979 and '83 had not been done, David Owen would now be the leader of the Labour Party. Don't make any mistake about it. If we had not made the change in the electoral college, if the Parliamentary Labour Party still elected th Leader David Owen would now be the lead er of a Labour Party that was in effect, the SDP. That's worth saying.
It's worth analysing some of the other arguments against the gloom and doom people. Take the section of the Parliamentary Labour Party that left the Party. It was quite a high percentage. They set themselves the job of destroying the Party. There was, to put it mildly, a division in the PLP leadership about whether the policy of the Conference was right or not.
That made problems for anybody who was going to vote Labour - what were the Parliamentary leadership going to carry out, policy or anything else? And of course during the Falklands war the Party - the leadership, at any rate - got itself behind the Task Force, and I think that contributed to our defeat.
But the real damage was not the defeat but the defeatWomen Dalkeith, c/o Dalkeith Miners' Welfare, Dalkeith, Lothian.
Fish Cross, c/o Fish Cross Miners' Welfare, Fish Cross, Clackmanan.
shire.
Durham, c/o Heather Wood, 18 Hallfield Drive, Easington Village, Peterlee, Co: Durham.
Kent, Kay. Sutcliffe, c/o Aylesham Miners' Welfare, Aylesham, Kent.
Thurnscoe: Sheila Jow, 105, Lidget Lane, Thurnscoe, Near Rotherham.
Blidworth. Doreen Humber, 50, Thorney Abbey Road, Blidworth, Mansfield, Notts.
Edlington: Veronica Baiderson, ism. You had this whole Hobsbawm analysis that somehow we were on an irreversible decline and that we better get a Popular Front.
" People were totally misreading Thatcherism as fascism. They're not the same. Fascism is a different political animal. Fascist ideas are current in our society, but if it were really fascism i then the argument for the Popular Front, which my predecessor in Bristol Stafford Cripps worked for before the wat, might have some relevance.
But if you build a movement on an anti-Thatcher policy - then, first of all, you're guilty of the offence of building up Thatcherism. Secondly you're building a movement for an alliance on a negative, not a positive, basis. And, thirdly, you forget that most of the people Hobsbawm seems to want to bring in may be anti-Thatcher but they are more anti-socialist than they are anti-Tory.
These ideas have led to something I recognise - the revisionism that appeared in the Party after 1959, when you had the Gaitskell attempt to change Clause 4. Some people are now suggesting this should be back on the against pit 62, Blowhall Cres., Edlington, Doncaster.
Maesteg: Teresa rarry, 13 Charles Row, Maesteg, West Glamorgan. (Tel: 738825).
Birch Coppice wives' group, Wendy Coxson, Tamworth 896069 Barnsley. Ann Hunter, 5 Packhorse Gn, Silkstone, near Barnsley phone 791187.
Maerdy Wives Support Committee, c/o Maerdy Strike Centre, Ferndale 755 301.
Oakdale, Gwent: 82 Markham Cres., Oakdale, Blackwood, Gwent. 0495 220158.
Celyen North, Gwent. c/o agenda - incredibly. You can just about understand why after 'you've never had it so good' you drop socialism, but why you drop socialism when 'you've never had it so bad' I've never been able to fully understand.
That was '83. Now in '84 you find the whole situation transformed.
Anybody who has seen or who has been on a picket line knows that it is something a little more than a few missiles on the miners' side and riot police on the other. It is something on a scale involving numbers, cavalry, and infantry that must have occurred in a number of Civil War battles in the middle of the 17th century.
In London Ken Livingstone is treated as somebody beyond the pale because he said he thought Ireland should be independent.
We had very good results in the European elections. And the SDP has appeared increasingly as Tory splinter. Indeed, if British politics ever moved sharply to the right, it would be David Owen who would be Prime Minister.
David Owen is well to the right of Mrs Thatcher in my losures Dorothy Phillips, 13 Thorn Ave.,1 Newbridge, Gwent. 0495 245000. 1 Rugoley, Staffs: Mrs Jackson, 91 Woodlands, Handsacre, Rugeley!
Staffs. Mrs Southwell, Rugeley 6179.
Littleton, Staffs: 6 Tower Road, High Green, Hednesford.. Linda Platen, Hednesford 76614.
Merton, Durham. Hetton-le-Hail 267641. Sheffield Women Against Pit| Closures. Kath Mackey, Sheffield 381594 or 454163.
North Staffs wives' committee:
Brenda Proctor, 153 Broadway, Meir, Stoke on Trent. 0782 332151. analysis. Mrs Thatcher is a Manchester school liberal using the police to sustain the monetarist system; but the 'consensus' in its modern manifestation is authoritarian to a degree. What Mussolini did in Italy in the 1920s is something which a whole school of thought, including part of the Establishment, would like to see now.
They wouldn't hesitate to nationalise the banks, just as Mussolini nationalised them. If the banks collapsed, it would be the Tories that nationalised them and then made the workers pay the price for keeping the system going.
As far as the Labour Party is concerned, there has also been a transformation. We have a new leadership which we elected by the electoral college. And, as I said earlier, we avoided David Owen. We've got a leadership that was elected at annual conference, and they should be sustained and supported.
We have 'Labour's Programme for Britain, which, although very modest compared to the standards that would be required of us if we came back to power, is still basically the right Party policy. And we have an improved constitution, which goes some way to see that we don't have an SDP problem in the future.
In that connection I would say that to raise the reselection issue again now as if it would be in our interest to (photo. John Harris)
break the link with the trade unions when it comes. to selecting candidates would be, to put it mildly, very foolish indeed. Because if the ballots are coming in the unions, and the issue is to be, is it worth reaffiliating to the Labour Party?, then it would be strange to shift over to a reselection process that would exclude affiliated members from having any role.
Now I want to move on to look in two ways at what is happening.
First, the battle; second, the war.
The most important thing is that the Labour Party should give one hundred per cent support to those who are engaged in struggle - that is to say, the miners, the Liverpool councillors, the London and metropolitan counties, and a whole group of Labour councillors who are not going to pay the bills for the police.
You can't say that we are a campaigning party and then not deploy the full power of the Parliamentary Labour Party, the National Executive Committee, the regional offices, the agents, on the issues which are at the centre of the current conflict. And that is why it is so important that over the last few months - there's been a struggle, but we've succeeded - we've got Margaret Thatcher the National Executive first of all to support the miners; next to ask for the levy; and thirdly to agree that there would be discussion between Eric Heffer, Jim Mortimer, Arthur Scargill and Peter Heathfield on a national campaign in support of the And this relates also to the argument about extra-parliamentary activity which led to Peter Tatchell's dismissal because he suggested they set up a camp around the House of Commons.
I think that was related to when Hoover was President of the USA. Didn't the poor in Washington set. up a Hooverville to show their poverty, and get chased off by the 1 District of Columbia police? But' we've come to realise that our whole history has been a history of extraparliamentary activity.
There's a local government conference. in Sheffield this weekend, and I would be very: surprised if George Lansbury [the leader of Poplar Labour Council's defiance of central government in the 1920s] was not the moving spirit of that conference - because events have shown that's what you have to do.
And let's be quite clear. There is an overriding legal obligation to obey the law, but there is no moral obligation to obey the law. So if people say, ought you obey the law?, the answer is -legally you should, but morally you use your judgment.
And provided we differentiate between the legal requirement to obey the law and the moral requirement to judge the law according to whether it's good or bad, we won't go far wrong.
Now from there we have to move into this area of extended industrial action. The Campaign group of MPs wrote round to all union executives and local Parties say+ 29 •Socialist Organiser no. 187 12 1984 July Page
Scan page 5
KILNHURST NUM 'IN