Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[the workers was increasing and a whole new…]

Socialist Organiser no. 187, 12 July 1984 · scan pp. 7–8 · Martin Thomas · about 2,135 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

the workers was increasing and a whole new wave, including the engineers, had started to move into action.

The miners were betrayed. Victory had been possible. But the TUC ran away and left the miners to fight alone for six months. Defeated, they were forced back to work with their wages cut, hours lengthened and national agreements scrapped.

Thus the ruling class was able to inflict a decisive defeat on the working class.

This included the Trades Disputes Act of 1927 which contained many of the ideas of present day Toryism including bans on mass picketing, sympathetic and political strikes and an attack on the political levy designed to weaken the links between the unions and the Labour Party by introducing the practice of ''contracting in". This was soon followed by the mass unemployment of the "Great Depression" . And it took more than a generation for the labour movement to recover from the defeat.

In the absence of serious militant leadership, the class was defeated and demoralised not so much by the preparaA collection of articles on the history and theory of the general strike.

Available from PO

Box 135, London N1 ODD, price 20p plus postage. Labour election poster, The short-sighted TUC leaders who refuse to mobilise the strength of the labour movement to help the miners win, do the same work today that their predecessors did in 1926. We cannot rely on any of these people. Unfortunately there is only one Arthur Scargill at the top of the trade union movement. The rank and file of the unions must Right now the main thing is to support the miners financially and on the picket lines. In the longer term we must organise the rank and file to transform the labour movement from top to bottom. The fact tht the miners have been left to fight alone for over four months is the latest proof that this transformation is long overdue.

isement

Scan page 8

No working class anywhere, bankers chosen for the task helps to cement its cohesion mass is big enough. This jued that the state is Martin Thomas looks at ever, has come near the should be... Hill Samuel." ral, but is tied to the the British ruling class. Despite all this, some the economic power and exhibited by the British reproduces itself to a large writers have argued that the privilege of the capitalists, not shares. They also own all the capitalist class in its almost- extent, through inherited capitalist class is withering a weakening! dred different defini- 'family firms' except the unanimous support for the wealth and privilege.

Of people who died leaving Three main facts are cited to individual capitalist does • Socialist Organiser no. 187 1984 IN 1HE last two articies last two articles have arowed that the ctate not neutral, but is tied to the interests of the ruling class. of the ruling class. What is the ruling class? is the ruling class?

A hundred different definitions could be given of the top ld be given of the 'top tiniest. people' by different aspects of their privilege and power, but underlying all those aspects is their wealth.

Money, as Shakespeare put it, "will make black white, foul fair, Wrong right, base noble, old young, coward valiant... Will knit and break religions, bless the accursed; Make the hoar leprosy adored, place thieves And give them title, knee and approbation With senators on the bench."

Ot as Marx put it, money is the "god. among commodities." Those who own money are therefore gods among Inequality Although the inequality of wealth in Britain has decreased somewhat this century, the top 1% of the population still own 23% of all private wealth, and the top 59, 45%. At the other end of the scale, 75% of the population owns only 16% of the wealth.

These figures, however, understate the real inequalities between classes. The top 5% have not only more wealth than the bottom 75%, but a different sort of wealth.

The top 5% account for 96% of all personally-owned Martin Thomas looks at the British ruling class.

shares. They also own all the 'family firms' except the tiniest.

Now compare 1000 people who each own, say, a house, some household equipment, and a car, totalling £30,000 each; and on the other hand ten people each with a wealth of £1 million. The ten people - the top 1% - own "only" 25% of the total wealth: but they own all of the sort of wealth that gives power and access to further wealth.

The top 5% monopolise the means of production.

The division between the bottom 75% and the top 5% is not just a division between less wealthy and more wealthy. It is a division between those who live by selling their labour power, and those who live off their ownership of the means of production. It is a division between the worker and the boss.

Now among this wealthy class, as Marx put it, 'there is little love lost in competition among themselves", but they "form a veritable freemason society vis-a-vis the whole working class". They are, in short, a class, not merely a collection of individuals.

They have a common interest, first, in the maintenance of the existing order of society and the stability and power of the state; and, second, in raising the general level of profit. Capitalists' incomes depend partly on their individual business wits but also on the general level of wages and productivity. The class, as a class, has a common interest in keeping down wages and pushing up productivity.

On the basis of this common interest, each national capitalist class develops a more-or-less common system of ideas, and common institutions political parties. universities, clubs, business associations of various sorts, newspapers, and of course the state degree . of class solidarity Tory party.

The central core of the capitalist class is very small indeed. One author has estimated that the people running the 1,000 largest companies — that is, by far the biggest chunk of the economy together with their immediate families, are less than 0.1% of the population (one in a thousand). And within that 0.1%, a smaller group of maybe 300 people has supremacy.

The interconnections within the core of the capitalist class are well illustrated by the journalist Anthony Sampson:

"Governments have never known quite where to look for their chairmen (of nationalised industries) ... but when in doubt they turn to bankers ....

'The most pervasive influence, was that of the Hill Samuel bank, the merger created by Sir Kenneth Keith in 1970 ... when Lord Melchett, the head of the Samuel half of the merger, lost out to Keith he was given British Steel as a consolation prize.

"Keith himself assembled a board of industrialists and excivil servants with close links to the Department of Trade, whose permanent secretary, Sir Peter Thornton, soon became a director of Hill Samuel. Keith was on the board of British Airways, and was later followed • by his friend Frank McFadzean, the joint head of Shell who became chairman of British Airways, which he ran for two days a week from the Shell building...

"At the same time Sir Charles Villiers, from Lord Kissin's bank Guinness Peat, was taking over British Steel in 1976 from Melchett. Sir Kenneth Keith in the meantime had taken on another nationalised industry, Rolls Royce, which he ran for eight years until 1980 when he was succeeded by ... McFadzean.

*When the Conservative bankers chosen for the should be... Hill Samuel.

The capitalist class also The capitalist class also reproduces itself to a large extent, through inherited wealth and privilege.

Of people who died leaving £100,000 or more between 1956 and 1973, 49% had had fathers who died leaving £100,000 or more. (And many of the rest, of course, may have inherited wealth from more distant relatives).

Something like 1% of the population goes to Oxford or Cambridge university, and something like ½% to the top public schools. Yet this tiny minority dominates not only in the state machine — as we have seen - but in the top circles of the economy.

In 1982, all five chairmen of the big banks had been to one or another of two schools — Eton and Winchester.

Out of the 18 chairmen of top merchant banks, 13 had been to top public schools (8 to Eton alone) and/or Oxbridge. 9 out of 12 insurance company. chairmen came from that sort of background.

When Lord Poole, boss of the merchant bank Lazards, was asked how he had avoided getting caught in the financial crashes of 1974, he replied: "Quite simple: I only lent money to people who had been at Eton."

The chiefs of industry are drawn from a wider range of backgrounds than those of finance: but one-half of the directors of the largest industrial companies in 1970 had been to public schools, and one-sixth to Eton alone. 39% of those directors were from 'a propertied or wealthy background' and a further 25% from well-off professional families.

The capitalist class is not the same as a feudal elite defined primarily by inheritance; and other capitalist classes — for example in the US — are much more open than the British to new blood, without that openness making them one whit less capitalist. Trinity College May Ball: the young upper class helps to cement its and sense of identity. and sense of identity.

Despite all this, some writers have argued that the capitalist class is withering away or has withered away. away or has withered away. Three main facts are cited to support this argument.

1. Ownership has been separated from control. Practically all big companies today are owned by a multitude of shareholders, who have little control over company affairs, and controlled by managers who do not own the companies.

2. Moreover, a large proportion of shares are owned not by individuals but by institutions. By the end of 1978, 38% of UK company shares were owned by pension funds or insurance companies.

« MacGregor 3. Many of the biggest companies are state-owned. lan MacGregor, after all, does not own the coal mines.

All these facts add up to the decline of the individual capitalist — but not of the capitalist class!

In class terms ownership and control have not been separated. Top managers receive incomes far over the top of any salary scale. lan MacGregor, for example, gets between £200,000 and £350,000 a year, and many private industry managers get more. They all own large amounts of wealth - very often in the form of shares in the companies they manage.

When companies are nationalised under the present system, the same class continues to run them. They switch from private capitalism to state capitalism. Usually nationalised concerns aré run at a loss — so that the workers in those concerns are effectively producing profits, not for their own employers, but for other businesses. that benefit from juicy contracts, cheap supplies, or streams of interest payments.

Insurance companies and pension funds give capitalists the possibility of bringing together the small savings of thousands into one mass. Each small nest-egg is not big THE C mass is big enough. This represents a strengthening of represents a strengthening of the economic power and privilege of the capitalists, not a weakening!

But the decline of the But the decline of the individual capitalist does prove something. The 19th century factory owner combined the functions of owner of wealth and organiser of production in one person. Modern, capitalism has separated those functions. The organisation of production in a modern capitalist enterprise is not done by the owners of the enterprise, nor even by the top managers, but by salaried employees.

The whole process of production is highly integrated, socialised, tied up with the state, and bureaucratised: but it is given its chaotic, wasteful, specifically capitalist character by the fact that it is all carried on for the benefit cf the top 5% of wealth-owners.

This economic structure is more than ripe for socialism -for the working class to impose common ownership of the means of production and replace bureaucratic management by democratic workers' management.

In the days of early capitalism, when thousands of small capitalists ran individual businesses, it was not at all clear that welding the economy intó a single unit, to be run by the working class according to a common plan, was a feasible replacement for the regulation of the economy by the laws of the free market. Today even the capitalists themselves recognise the need for social planning of production. Only under the rule of the working class can that planning be made rational and

----- pull-quotes -----

MAY WE Central Strike n whose interest?

Arguing for

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 187

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →