Who needs the
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-07-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
MANY people say that in any civilised society a police force is necessary in order to control anti-social behaviour and catch common criminals. But this is not true.
In every kind of society there must exist some means for keeping order and regulating people's behaviour; but the police are a particular means which arose with the development of capitals and which will die with the coming of socialism.
The distinguishing feature of the police is that it is a special force separated from the people and standing above society. It possesses special powers allu privileges, it is organsed bureaucratically from the top down; and only in the most restricted ways is it democratically accountable to the people.
The communism which we fight for - unlike the phony version in the Soviet Union - is one in which society will be regulated not by a special force above the people but by the people themselves through their own self-organistation The police have become so vell entrenched that it seems as if this bourgeois institution of social control has always been with us.
Two pamphlets summing up the ideas of Socialist Organiser.
Where We Stand - 20p plus 16p postage. 'How to fight the Tories - 10p plus 16p postage. Or the two together for 45p including postage. From Socialist Organiser, 28 Middle Lane, London N8 The police prove time and again they are not a neutral force: they smash up picket lines, attack black people, and harass youth. But is the police force still necessary for other functions? Bob Fine, joint editor of the book 'Capitalism and the Rule of Law', takes up the arguments.
Historically, however, the police are only one hundred and fifty years old. The police force, as we know it, slowly emerged in the nineteenth century as the brainchild and strongarm of the industrial bourgeoisie.
It was introduced in the teeth of fierce opposition from the great landlords and the merchant capitalists. They opposed the police in the name of freedom' but the freedom they had in mind consisted of their own privileges and personal powers.
They ruled through their direct control of military forces, through the powers allocated to their private servants (e.g. gamekeepers) and through their explicit influence over the courts, the judges and other state institutions. The growth of the police in this context was one aspect of the replacement of the personal power of the lords by a power formally based on the will of the people as a whole.
Repress
In this respect it was a mark of the progressiveness of the liberal bourgeoisie.
The development of the police reflected in part the liberal fear of despotism from above, but it also reflected their fear of the 'mob' below. Its function was not merely to keep order and control crime, but to repress the working class, and it was this class function which made necessary the distinguishing characteristic of the police: its separation as a Socialist ORGANISER How to fight the Tories Thezop Where agi Te we stand In Fight socialist policies ANDREW WIARD (REPORTIPolice protect NF march through Maidstone special force from the people whom it was said to represent.
Although it was an advance that the power to regulate society was transferred from a small class of property owners to the 'public' , the public only came on the stage in formal dress, as an abstraction without flesh and blood.
The consent of the people was from the beginning a formality. The doctrine was put forward that if individuals opposed the police, they were enemies of society as a whole; they also appeared as their own worst enemies, since the police were treated as the embodiment of the rational interests of each individual. The bourgeois mystique was that subordination to the policeman's club was in fact subordination to one's own rational conscience!
To sustain this fiction, a number of mechanisms were instituted which purported to be means of subordinating the police to the people but which were in effect ways of subordinating the people to the police. In different capitalist countries, different methods were employed.
What they all had in common was the purely formal nature of the identification of the police with the people and the highly restrictive democracy they made possible.
The primary "mediation' through which the people could express their will lay in the development of a professional police bureaucracy. Policemen and women were to be salaried out of the public purse in order that they should have no financial interest in putting private profit before the common good They were to be subjected to strict hierarchical discipline in order that their private concerns should be subordinate to the general concerns of the police. They were to be recruited from all strata of society lest any particular stratum should receive privilege. They were to be selected for their high moral fibre and then trained to be even-handed and impartial in their practices.
The general idea was that by this bureaucratic method, the police could be identified with the general interests of society and not the interests of any particular class within society.
In reality the new police were associated with the interests of the 'people' only in the most abstract sense. Real flesh and blood individuals could interfere in the 'public' concerns reserved for the police only at their peril.
The public interest became as it were the private domain of the police. It was they who monopolised the definition of what the public really wanted and needed Their principle was secrecy, the people were not permitted to know what was done in their name:
----- pull-quotes -----
IN STOP PIT CLOSURES PUT PEOPLE FIRST. Back the miners
Socialist be ORGANISER for