Iraq: dissent grows
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-07-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
_against West Bank Arabs. Zionist extremists attack the car of Israeli Defence Minister Mosite Arens, demanding increased repression no choice election Inflation is running at 40% in Iran. The war with Iraq consumes an estimated $45 million a day. Unemployment is rampant though partially covered up by the mobilisation of hundreds of thousands for the war.
Six million workers have had their wages frozen. Land seized by peasants after the revolution of 1979 is being transferred back to big landowners. Free trade unionism is non-existent. Strike leaders have been arrested and shot. Women and national minorities are fereciously repressed The left opposition in Iran is fighting, back with considerable courage - but, sadly, ineffective politics and a lack of international solidarity.
The Mojahedin remains the largest opposition movement. It is radical-Islamic, but • becoming more Islamic than radical.
Recent statements by its exiled leader Massoud Rajavi have stressed more and more the notion that the Mojahedin, not Khomeini's supporters are the "true" followers of Islam.
Its previous attempts to promote a radical image have been ditched in favour of attempting to curry favour with Western European industrialists and politicians. Rajavi's agreement with the reactionary Iraqi regime on a peace plan is his latest way of reassuring Western capitalism.
Massoud Rajavi Such recent developments represent an extension of, rather than a break with, the Mojahedin's previous policies. Thus, its 1981 programme for a "transitional government of the democratic Islamic republic of Iran" pledged acceptance of the national bourgeoisie and the bazaar as well as individual private ownership and personal investment" , offered only "internal autonomy" (not full independence) to national minorities and only permitted the right to strike "subject to previous notifiction".
The programme also stressed its adherence to "true" Islam.
After the Mojahedin, the Organisation of Iranian People's Fedaii Guerrillas (OIPFG) is probably still the next largest grouping.
The OIPG claims to be Marxist. But it preaches the Stalinist theory of "two stages of revolution"; first the "People's democratic revolution" creating a "workers' and peasants' democratic dictatorship" , then a socialist revolution at a later stage.
Internationally, the OIPFG declares the Stalinist states to be the "socialist camp" , which, despite "revisionist deviations" since Stalin's death, is an "international ally of Iran's proletariat"
Internally, the OIPFG's Stalinism expresses itself in the treatment of opposition factions. The former minority tendency (now the "Revolutionary Socialist Tendency") was denounced as a "defender of Trotskyism" and OIPFG supporters were warned:
"refrain from intellectually oriented debates and commit yourselves to struggle in a healthy environment ... drive out the faction-seeking opportunists from your ranks" who "inadvertently or not, Will be at the service of the police and the anti-popular regime of the Islamic Republic.
The OIPFG has refused to participate in the Mojahedin-initiated collaborationist popular front.
But the OIPF's own attempt to propose a "common platform for the unionary alogressive forces, progressive forces"
was politically inadequate (based as it was on the "two stages of revolution" theory, and calling for "unity and co-operation with socialist and progressive countries") and only drew support from small groups.
The recently formed Communist Party of Iran (CPI) is essentially a fusion of the Unity of Communist Militants and the Kurdish organisation Komala, plus some remnants of Peykar and Razmandegan.
The CPI claims to be much clearer ideologically than the other groups, but in fact it is often confused.
Over the Iran-Iraq war, they used to sneer at the slogan "turn the reactionary war into a war against reaction" on the grounds that it allegedly "places the Iranian proletariat in the service of the solution of the international disputes of the bourgeoisie" and instead called for "independent struggle against any kind of foreign invasion" whereby "workers (could) defend their revolution against the war of the capitalists"
In Iran, the CPI calls for a Democratic Revolutionary Republic because "the proletariat and its communist party, cannot embark on an immediately socialist revolution." This is merely a variant of the traditional Stalinist position of "Two stages of revolution"
looks at the Iran fighting The CPI describes the Soviet Union as "state capitalist" , but without advancing any theoretical arguments to justify sticking such a label on it. It is even more hostile, and less theoretically coherent, on China: "It belongs to the camp of world imperialist counter-revolution ... alongside American imperialism, the defender of the most naked forms of bourgeois reaction."
The CPI's supporters in Western Europe, argue that the trade unions (the unions themselves, not the bureaucracies) are reactionary, anti-working class organisations. The CPI has denounced the French Trotskyists who called for a vote for the French Socialist Party in 1981 as "equally anti-working class and responsbile for today's massacres conducted by the French government in Chad and Lebanon."
Apart from the Mojahedin, OIPFG and CPI, the biggest opposition group is the now banned Tudeh, or Moscow-oriented "Communist" Party. The Tudeh Party supported the regime and aided it in its attacks on the working class until it was itself attacked.
The Tudeh Party is now in opposition to the regime, but seemed well ahead, but that is only because the regime has tossed it aside. now less clear.
Trotskyist organisations unfortunately have little weight in under Menachem Begin and Iran, and are deeply divided then current leader, Yitzhak among themselves. The avowedly Shamir, has landed Israel in a Trotskyist "United Secretariat of mess. Rampant inflation the Fourth International" has had (now approaching 400%), plus up to three sympathising sections in Iran, divided in particular on the political and human costs the question of the Iran-Iraq war. of the war in, and continued The SWP-USA and its co-thinkers occupation of part of Lebanon, within the USFI support Iran have undermined the governagainst Iraq, while other people ment's popularity. in the USFI oppose the war on both sides.
The bulk of the anti-Khomeini have successfully shifted the opposition is thus split between terms of election propaganda: the Mojahedin, with their bour- Ariel Sharon, the defence geois alliances, and various brands minister forced to quit because of sectarian, dogmatic Stalinism.
of his role in the Sabra and Chatila massacres, has been touring the country with pictures of Yassir Arafat and the legend: "He wants you to vote Labour"
to have proved effective.
Labour is pro-PLO or even that it wants to 'hand over' the occupied territories to be a 'terrorist state' are bizarre.
Labour has a long record of oppressing the Palestinian Arabs, and its policies now are hazy and by no means radical ones: some sort of autonomy deal Saddam Hussein (i.e. well short of even a AS the Gulf War continues there has been a significant growth of opposition in Iraq, especially among the Kurdish nationalists and the students.
The focus for this opposition has been the Ba'ath regime's treatment of army deserters and its attempt to force large numbers of Kurdish youth and students into the Army or the paramilitary outfit, the People's Army.
January and February of this year saw mass executions of Kurdish youth accused of desertion. For example eight young army conscripts were executed on February 22 which is the eve of Nawruz, the Kurdish national In April the government issued decree no. 107 which stipulates that all students must undergo military training with the People's Army and death squads, set up to hunt down army deserters, executed 70 war objectors in Baghdad.
May saw the -beginnings mass opposition to the regime. 5,000 people turned out in the town of Sulamaneyah on May 12 to demonstrate, openly calling for the downfall of the regime. 13 days later, in the same place, 50,000 took to the streets.
Some reports would seem to indicate that this last event culIsrael: a AS Israel moves towards its elections on July 23, it By Clive Bradley becomes increasingly difficult to predict the outcome. Until Palestinian mini-state) with recently, the main opposition King Hussein of Jordan, party, the Labour Alignment, seems to be in the pipeline.
Such a proposal, if Labour wins, might revitalise the The ruling coalition, Likud, so-called peace plan' of Ronald Reagan, issued in 1982 and firmly rejected by the Likud. But that is all.
Whoever wins, it will be a battle for a coalition with one of Israel's highly influential and important small parties.
Most of those - like the Tehiya Party of ex-chief of staff Raphael Eitan, or the However, lately the Likud ultra-orthodox Agudat Israel - are more likely to opt for Likud. Eitan vies with Sharon in anti-Arab chauvinism -for example he recently referred to the West Bank Palestinians as "cockroaches in a bottle"
Likud have also hit back in defence of the occupation of Lebanon: for example a recent This PLO-scare tactic seems election advert involved an account by a small girl from In fact, the claim that North Galilee about how terrifying things used to be before the Lebanese war.
But Labour leader Shimon Peres is still trying to convince the Israeli Jews that he is at least as good as Likud at oppressing the Arabs.
The economy, however, remains a big issue. Labour claims it can reduce inflation to 85% (and to 25% within six minated in the offices of the People's Army being stormed „statues of Saddam Hussein pulled down and barricades set up.
The students have been acting as the motivating force for this outbreak of opposition. In response to decree 107 a total strike of students was declared and students' strike committees have been set up in Kurdistan and Baghdad. This strike has followed mass expulsions from the colleges of those students who refused to comply with the decree.
The Iraqi regime is obviously in trouble. It has been forced to negotiate with the students' strike committees and the demonstrations in Iraqi Kurdistan have been accompanied by the appearance of the partisan armed movement on the streets, indicating a weakening of the regime's control in the area.
However, the major opposition forces in Iraq, united in the Patriotic Democratic Front, cannot be said to offer a working class political alternative to the Ba'athist regime. The PDF has followed, rather than initiated the student revolt. And the Iraqi Communist Party, one of the major components of the PDF has a long history of actually opposing the struggle of the Iraqi working class and the Kurds.
Though it was finally rewarded for this by repression from the Ba'ath.
electio years). Nobody seems years). Nobody seems to believe them.
The Likud had faced big strikes from sections of workers, and the election campaign itself has been interrupted by action by TV workers. There is a wage indexation system, but many real wages have fallen, and over the past few years there have been several struggles to reverse this trend, notably by teachers.
Most Palestinians - those in the territories occupied in 1967 - do not have the vote. Amongst those in the pre-'67 borders, the biggest single block of votes will go to Rakah, the Israeli Communist Party.
That will guarantee only a handful of Arab representatives in the Knesset. Real Arab political organisation is illegal.
Some more vigorously socialist and anti-Zionist candidates are standing. The government tried to ban both the extreme right and left, but was forced to change tack. But anti-Zionists have very. very little influence among the Jewish population.
What is certain is that the development of an independent socialist voice with any roots in the working class is as yet extremely limited. Whoever wins on July 23, it will be a culmination, perhaps with some modification, of the reactionary policies of the Israeli state since its creation.
Scan page 9
Socialist Organiser no. 188. July 19, 1984. Page SPOTLIGHT.
----- pull-quotes -----
National Council of Resistance, rightly denouncing it as a class-