Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Racism as anti-racism

Socialist Organiser no. 188, 19 July 1984 · scan p. 9 · Clive Bradley · about 632 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

FROM THE About the Anti-Alien Resolution of the Cardiff Trade Union Congress.

We, the organised Jewish workers of England, taking into consideration the Anti-Alien Kesolution, and the uncomplimentary remarke of certain delegates about the Jewish workers specially, issue this leaflet, wherewith wu hope to convince our English fellow workers of the untruthfulness, unreasonableness, and want of logic contained in the cry against the foreign worker in general, and against the Jewish worker in particular.

It is, and always has been, the policy of the ruling classes to attribute the sufferings and miseries of the masses (which are natural consequencos of class rule and class *ho try against the foreigner is not racere he is tho exploitation) to all sorts of causes except the real ones. England; it is international. Everywhere scapegoat for other's sins. Every class finds in him an enemy. So long as the Anti-Alien sentiment in this country was confined to politicians, wire pullers, and to individual working men, we, the organised aliens, took no heed; but when this ill-founded sentiment has been ofticially expressed by the organised working men of England, then we believe that it is time to lift our voices and argue the matter out.

It has been proved by great political econon:ists that a working man in a country where machinery is greatly developed produces in a lay twice as many commodities as his daily wage enables him to consume./ semitism Tom Mann, SDF trade union militant - and anti-semite look anti-semitic', by Steve Cohen, an antiracist analysis of Left anti-semitism. (Beyond the Pale collective, £2) THIS book should be read and re-read by everyone active on the left. For years, the left - revolutionary or otherwise - has glibly held up its hands in horror at the very idea that it might be anti-semitic. Anti-semitism is rarely mentioned except as an afterthought to ward off criticism from Zionists.

Yet synagogues • are attacked, even bombed; Jews continue to be persecuted in large parts of the world; and the left not only fails to mobilise people against the scourge of anti-semitism, but persists in using 'world conspiracy' arguments in its analyses of the Middle East conflict.

Whilst few men on the left would insist that they are not at all sexist, few white people would deny any anti-black racism whatsoever, and few heterosexuals would deny any trace of homophobia, rare indeed is the left-wing gentile who admits the possibility that s/he might have inherited any of the deep-rooted anti-semitism in Western culture.

Steve Cohen's book confronts all these issues, and exposes the latent (or not so latent) anti-semitism in much of what the left says and does. He analyses in some detail the way in which antisemitism was institutionalised in Britain with the Aliens Act of 1905, and how the labour movement was instrumental in bringing this about.

Guilty Instances of socialists taking a stand against blatantly anti-semitic immigration controls were the exception; well-known leading figures in the early history of British socialism like Tom Mann and Keir Hardie, were particularly guilty. Hyndman, founder of the Social Democratic Federation, was a notorious antisemite.

The widespread idea that the Labour Party has a history of sympathy for the Jews (and its pro-Israeli position follows from that) is utterly false.

Cohen demolishes the antisemitic assumptions behind much of what passes as antiZionist' propaganda. Take the example of 'Newsline' (April 9, 1983) which speaks of a Zionist power "stretching through Downing Street channels right into the White House". As Cohen wryly comments: "Lenin was presumably wrong when he analyses imperialism as being the highest form of capitalism: Zionism is apparently even higher, as it is able to Harrison Ford

----- pull-quotes -----

Pamphlet produced by Jewish workers against TUC anti-

-Lette Clive Bradley reviews "That's funny, you don't

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 188

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →