The battle continues in the lau
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-07-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
Miners, miners' wives, and Greenham women picket in Port Talbot.
The Tories and the Coal I and courts as allies in thei But their use of the law can Bob Fine reports.
THE legal aspect of the miners' strike is only an adjunct. Nonetheless it vital.
When individual miners put themselves on the line for the union, the the union must do everything possible for them if the law is wielded against them.
So far, over four and a half thousand miners have been brought before the courts.
Taking the fight into the courtroom, to challenge the charade of justice there, is crucial for the morale of the strikers. Victories can be won in that arena too — as well as on the picket line - and the trial provides an occasion for publicity and propaganda which the miners should not miss.
This was the basic message coming out of a joint meeting held in Sheffield between the Haldane Society of Socialist Lawyers and the NUM.
The state is using and abusing the law in its determination to crush the miners. Among the most notorious measures it has taken are the "intercept' policy of the police.
The police set up roadblocks and turn back anyone suspected of being a picket or strike supporter. Four men in a single car have no chance.
On one day in Nottingham, police turned back 1900 miners in 475 cars.
If people refuse they are arrested on charges like threatening to breach the peace or obstructing the police in the course of their duty.
The legality of this operation. Soard are using the police r fight against the miners. and should be challenged.
is, to say the least, dubious. The police turn people back far from the site of any picket line without any reasonable suspicion that they will breach the peace. They invoke the civil law about secondary picketing which is irrelevant.
This abuse of legal powers - which adds up in effect to a denial of freedom of movement or the right to travel to a demonstration - is not only supported by the government, it was instigated by the Home Secretary. So much for their refrain about the rule of law.
We even heard a case of a miner and his wife being stopped and arrested for trying to travel to their holiday home.
This abuse of powers is being challenged in court by the NUM - with the assistance of socialist lawyers -both individual cases in the lower courts and through test cases taken to the higher courts.
The second notorious measure taken by the state is the magistrates' use of bail conditions. When striking miners are remanded on bail highly restrictive conditions are set without regard to the individual in question, the circumstances of his or her arrest, the effect of these conditions on the individual and so forth.
The magistrates simply dole out what are now known as the 'usual conditions' These state that the accused are "not to visit any premises or place for the purpose of picketing or demonstrating in Brent Miners' Solidarity ComPHURNACITE Photo: Martin Shakeshaft (IFL). connection with the current trade dispute between the NUM and the NCB other than peacefully to picket or demonstrate at his usual place of employment."
This imposes on its victims something like what in South Africa is called *a banning order' • The procedure is legally as dubious as the 'operation intercept'.
Magistrates are obliged to grant bail on the basis of discretion with respect to an individual case. One has a fundamental right to bail in law and can only be refused bail or have conditions imposed in definite, legally defined circumstances.
A legal challenge to this STRIKERS is not only of practical value to the miners; it is also a way of ensuring that we do not simply accept the intensification of legal repression as the norm.
As Tony Gifford said, we are witnessing a new kind of policing that the labour movement has not yet got to grips with.
It would seem — not surprisingly — that the NUM was not at first prepared for the legal onslaught against their members. They were thinking mainly in terms of the use of the civil law (through cases brought under the Tory Employment Acts) and not the criminal law. Their solicitors, so it seems, did not sufficiently challenge the abuse of legal powers by the police and the magistrates.
This is now changing. The Haldane Society, for instance, has set up a rota of lawyers to be on hand in Nottingham, with their centre at Ollerton. The meeting as a whole endorsed a resolution calling for more national coordination by the NUM of its legal resources.
There was considerable discussion about the techniques of fighting cases in court: the importance of knowing the names of those arrested, of collecting witnesses, of photographs and so forth. There was also discussion not only of how to defend miners against the law, but also of how to use the law offensively against the police.
Complaints against the police are useless, as are private criminal prosecutions (Bringing charges of riot against the police cavalry?).
But civil actions against the police have a much better success rate. They are easy to initiate, and the civil law provides plenty of grounds — wrongful imprisonment, assault, malicious prosecution, trespass and wrongful interference with goods.
Legal aid should be available and successful cases are rewarded with much needed financial damages.
The law is an instrument for the ruling class, but it also imposes inhibition on the rul Bich they flagrantly violate whenever they are pressed to do so. The law is a weapon against workers, but it also provides uS with resources in the pursuit of our struggles. The important thing is to know how to use these resources well.
One of the difficulties we face is the lack of a collective memory concerning how legal forms of struggle have been used in the past - for example, after the uprisings of 1981. It is important both to draw the legal lessons from this dispute and to retain them for future struggles.
Finally, a clear message came both from the miners and the lawyers that the Labour Party ought to get its finger out at the leadership level and actively campaign around the gross violations of democratic rights that are now taking place on a daily basis.
For example, the clerk of the court dealing with Ollerton cases - and handing out the peremptory bail orders - is a right wing Labour Party member. With friends like that, who needs enemies?