Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[AVAiL.. UFIANCE.. GUEUR.. FFORT... Raymond Barre beams at…]

Socialist Organiser no. 189, 26 July 1984 · scan p. 7 · about 634 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

AVAiL.. UFIANCE.. GUEUR.. FFORT...

Raymond Barre beams at Left 'Work, trust, rigour, effort.

was neither a programme el for running capitalism. culties as it tried to tinker Is, inflation, speculation d by trying to make the adually and painfully its apsed. ged off onto the world econism is in crisis are socialists AOM-KONGE Right: Talbot Poissy - the fight against job cuts. Immigrant workers have been in the forefront of the struggle. IN THE EEC elections last month the French CP got 11% - its lowest share of the since 1932.

From 1945 through to 1979, it consistently got over 20% of the The experience of the Mitterrand government has been a disaster for the CP. Now, by withdrawing from the government and probably adopting a more militant tone, it hopes to regain ground. It is not certain that it can do it.

The Communist Party has one asset that the SP lacks - a core of dedicated working class LONS French nuclear weapuns. It has said it will accept NATO. It preaches bit-by-bit reform of the system.

Generally the CP has distinguished itself from the SP by low-grade verbal sparring -there was a big dispute in the late 70s about exactly how many nationalisations the joint programme of the Left should promise - and, shamefully, by a more strident nationalism. 'No to a German Europe' was a CP poster a few years ago.

The other asset the CP used to have and the SP lacked was links with the USSR — socialism in practice, or so millions thought. But that asset is now a liability. Only 35% of CP voters, according to a recent poll, have a positive opinion of the USSR.

'Eurocommunism' was attempt to escape from that liability by distancing the CP from the USSR. But it made the CP appear as no more than a second rate Socialist Party.

The CP's current troubles are not temporary, but part of a long-term decline.

TO THE Alternative Economic Strategy' (AES) is the British equivalent to the sort of programme which has guided the Left government in France.

In various different versions, it is the official policy of the TUC, the Labour Party, and the Communist Party.

Through planning agreements, through increased social spending, and through new nationalised industry, investment will be jacked up, so the argument runs. The increased investment will boost demand in the economy both directly and indirectly. It will thus pull the whole economy out of slump into expansion.

The import controls ensure that the increased demand does not just pull in more imports. And the price controls make sure it does not just lead to inflation. The other AES measures make sure the expansion benefits the working class.

Depending on the emphasis and on which other measures they add, versions of the AES can range from mild reformism to sweeping radicalism. But all the versions share-some key problems.

The policy of the capitalist state spending its way out of a crisis is at the heart of the AES. It is not a particularly socialist idea: it was first theorised by the Liberal economist J. M. Keynes in the 1930s.

It has been abandoned by the leading sections of the capitalist class because in today's conditions it leads not to expansion but to inflation, uncontrollable state deficits, and balance-ofpayments problems. France con firms that judgement.

Would tighter import controls solve the trade deficit problem? Yes - at a cost! The cost can be seen in countries like Brazil which have cut right down on imports in order to get trade surpluses and pay off their foreign debt — a huge slump in industry and rise in unemployment.

Moreover, tighter import controls all round - and that is the way the capitalist world is win Arguing ND SC for

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 189

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →