Likud vs Labour: what does it mean?
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-07-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
AS we go to press, it is still unclear who is going to form the next government in Israel, although some form of Labour-Likud 'national unity' government seems likely. The latest figures give Labour 45 seats, and Likud 41, in the 120-seat parliament.
Labour has certainly not got the majority it had hoped for. Many people internationally will be disappointed too. The US quite openly favoured a Labour government that would be more Many people on the left also felt that a Labour victory would be in the interests of peace. The British Labour Party has always had links with its Israeli 'counterpart' and Poale Zion, an element in the Israeli Labour alignment, is affiliated to the British But the Israeli Labour Party is not a socialist or a working class party. Clive Bradley reviews a pamphlet on the history of "Labour Zionism: socialist or colonialist?' - 35p plus postage from the Labour Movement Campaign for Palestine, 28 Carlton YOU'VE probably seen Frank Bough, Sue Lawley and others on TV appealing for our help for the thousands of people affected by the drought and famine in the Sahel in Africa. Film of dying and severely undernourished adults and children has been very moving.
But the famine is not, as the TV appeals would have us believe, just an unfortunate freak of nature.
In the first place, the EEC and the US have food surpluses big enough to meet Africa's food shortage many times over - if only the governments would do something to make reparations for their pillage of Africa over the centuries, rather than hiving the problem off to individual charity.
And the food shortage itself is not just a fact of nature.
The Sahel (which consists of parts of Cape Verde, Mauritania, Senegal, Gambia, Upper Volta, Msii, Niger and Chad) has had droughts before. In fact its pre-caprialist economy, based on wandering people tending cattle, was well adapted to cope vith them.
What has made droughts cause serious famine is the of the p development of capitalism. Food production has been shifted towards exports rather than domestic consumption. And, as an Oxfam pamphlet comments, 'While the north of Upper Volta had almost no harvest in 1983 because of drought, in parts of the South, barns were overflowing with millet after a bumper harvest: farmers were worried about the low price they would receive for their crop"
Flour made available by the state grain agency at low prices was bought up by private traders to be sold at higher prices. The poor in the area simply cannot afford to buy food at the traders' prices.
It was the same story in 1982: soybean oil donated by Saudi Arabia was bought up by private traders and sold at high prices.
Also, as land cultivation has developed, the poor peasants have been forced onto the worst land. To feed their families, they have to exhaust the land: drought wreaks havoc with their livelihoods.
And governments in the Sahel rofit drive worsen the situation by restricting the sale of subsidised food to the towns: the badly affected rural areas hardly benefit at all.
But Western governments and financial institutions also bear a big responsibility.
The debt burden on countries throughout the Third World and in the Sahel is so great that new loans are now only paying off old ones. Since the world price of food commodities is falling, it means that the money to aid the starving in the Sahel is simply drying up.
And the US and its allies have cut their contributions to the aid provided by the International Development Association. In 1984 $16 billion was needed to keep IDA aid at its existing levels. Only $9 billion was provided.
And the 1983 programme of the International Fund for Agricultural Development was cut back by almost 30%; actual payments from Western governments were consistently lower than their pledges.
So the Sahel famine is not a natural disaster. It is a result of the irrational organisation of a world economy based on the thirst for profit.
By Clive Bradley OUR Labour Party has a long history of support for the existence and actions of the Israeli state. Part of the reason for this is the myth of Israel as a socialist state, beleaguered by Arab tyrannies.
Labour Zionism, in many respects the dominant wing of the Zionist movement, has historically quite close connec tions with the Labour Party, and often particularly with its left.
The pamphlet, produced by the Labour Movement Campaign for Palestine, is a critique of Labour Zionism, examining its ideas and - more importantly - its history and practice.
The early Labour Zionists at the beginning of this century believed that the creation of a Jewish state would redress the balance of the 'inverted pyramid' of Jewish society in Europe. In a Jewish state, a 'real' Jewish proletariat could be formed that could then commence its revolutionary struggle against the Jewish bourgeoisie. So Zionism was necessary for socialism, they argued.
Theory What this theory overlooked was the Arab population in Palestine. The reality behind the socialist claims of the Labour Zionists was that they were a colonising movement which could only establish its state by displacing the original inhabitants.
The colonial logic behind Labour Zionism - however sincere as socialists its theorists may have been - meant that the Jews were pitted against the Arabs. And despite the 'anti-colonial' rhetoric of some of the Labour Zionists, the needs of the embryonic Zionist state in British-ruled Palestine in 1920-48 led Labour Zionists to look to colonial-imperialist powers (principally Britain) for support. Their ends could best be served if they convinced the imperialists that the Jewish state could protect their interests against Arab nationalist revolt.
The pamphlet demonstrates clearly that the reactionary core to Labour Zionism has always predominated. A statement from one Labour Zionist leader gives some indication of this.
Rothschild
David Hacohen, former Managing Director of Sollel Boneh (the building company of the trade union federation, the Histadrut) commented on the early colonial period:
"I had to fight my friends on the issue of Jewish socialism to defend the fact that I would not accept Arabs in my trade union ... to defend the fact that we stood guard at orchards to prevent Arab workers from getting jobs there, to attack Jewish housewives in the markets and smash Arab eggs they had bought ... to take Rothschild, the incarnation of capitalism, as a socialist and to name him the 'benefactor' -to do all this was not easy." But nevertheless they did it. responsive to its proposals. Labour Zionism that shows its real nature.
Mansions, Holmleigh Rd., London N16. Likud leader Yitzhak Shamir During the war that created the Israeli state in 1948, the Labour Zionists were not as overt and brutal as Begin's right wing forces; but they shared the essential strategy. According to Harry Sacher, a prominent British Labour Zionist, "For strategic purposes the Jews began to blow up the Arab villages which they had occupied The massacre of Deir Yassin by the Irgun (Begin's group) was a turning point. It became the rule that, when the Jewish forces advanced, the Arab inhabitants ... fled; nor was the flight always without stimulation and encouragement from the Jews."
The pamphlet shows how two of the central myths of post-1948 Labour Zionism are false. The kibbutzim are in reality both an effective form for a colonisation process, and are based upon the exploitation of Arab labour. "Calling the kibbutzim "socialist' . is like justifying a landlord throwing his tenants into the street because he says he wants to rent the house to a commune."
The trade union federation, the Histadrut, with which the Labour Party has links, is not, the pamphlet shows quite clearly, a genuine trade union: it is "after the State itself, the largest employer in Israel (And) working for a Histadrut owned company is no different from working for a capitalist enterprise."
Finally, the pamphlet deals with the history of the relationship between Zionism and the Labour Party. It shows for example, how a 1945 Labour Party policy argued that "the Arabs should be encouraged to move out of Palestine as the Jews move in"
And it traces the development of this general policy of support for the Zionist state, until the successful passing of the pro-Palestinian motion at the 1982 Party Conference.
This pamphlet will be very useful to activists campaigning in the labour movement for the rights of the Palestinians. It is tightly argued, and provides a coherent and logical critique of Labour Zionism that avoids the demonology of much that is written on the subject.
I. have one criticism: it is not the stated purpose of the pamphlet, but I feel a more extensive treatment of the policies of Labour Zionist governments up to 1977 would have been useful - to show that their hypocrisy did not end with the creation of the Israeli state.
That aside, this is an important and informative pamphlet which should have a wide circulation.